Justin Trudeau says Canada expressed 'dissatisfaction' over Chinese minister's outburst

Prime Minister Justin Trudeau says the Canadian government has expressed its dissatisfaction with China after its foreign minister lashed out at a Canadian reporter over a question on human rights this week in Ottawa.

PM responds to Wang Yi's berating of Canadian journalist for asking about human rights in China

Prime Minister Justin Trudeau told reporters following his speech to the Federation of Canadian Municipalities in Winnipeg Friday that Canada has expressed its "dissatisfaction" over the visiting Chinese foreign minister's admonishment of a Canadian reporter. (John Woods/Canadian Press)

Prime Minister Justin Trudeau says the Canadian government has expressed its dissatisfaction with China after its foreign minister scolded a Canadian reporter over a question on human rights.

"I can confirm that both (Foreign Affairs Minister Stéphane) Dion and department officials from Global Affairs Canada have expressed our dissatisfaction to both the Chinese foreign minister and the ambassador of China to Canada — our dissatisfaction with the way our journalists were treated," Trudeau said in Winnipeg on Friday, after he gave a speech to the Federation of Canadian Municipalities.

"The fact of the matter is freedom of the press is extremely important to me," the prime minister said.

Chinese Foreign Minister Wang Yi called a Canadian journalist "irresponsible" for asking about human rights during a news conference in Ottawa on Wednesday.

Trudeau acknowledged that it's the media's job to ask "tough questions" and said he encouraged journalists to do so.

The prime minister also said he has not shied away from raising with Chinese officials the issue of human rights, including the case of Canadian Kevin Garratt.

Trudeau says Canada has expressed 'dissatisfaction' with China

7 years ago
Duration 2:11
Prime Minister Justin Trudeau says he also raised the case of imprisoned Canadian Kevin Garratt and human rights in talks with China's foreign minister.

"Every time I have had an opportunity to meet with any representatives of the Chinese government or of China in general, I have highlighted our concerns around human rights and specifically brought up the case of Kevin Garratt, a Canadian citizen imprisoned for espionage without any evidence to support the allegations and accusations."

"We will continue to bring up human rights concerns every chance we get while at the same time we work to create economic opportunities both for Canadians and for Chinese citizens," Trudeau said on Friday.

Prime Minister Justin Trudeau, right, meets with Chinese Foreign Minister Wang Yi on Parliament Hill in Ottawa, Wednesday. Trudeau said he raised human rights and the case of imprisoned Canadian Kevin Garratt with Wang. (Adrian Wyld/Canadian Press)

The question that provoked Wang's outburst on Wednesday came from Amanda Connolly of iPolitics and was initially addressed to Dion.

Connolly was asking the question agreed to by a number of journalists representing several news organizations at the event, including The Canadian Press, The Globe and Mail, Reuters, The Wall Street Journal and The Tyee.

The Trudeau government remained publicly silent for nearly 48 hours after the incident, until Dion tweeted about the issue Friday morning.

During a conference call Friday, Dion was asked why he did not intervene following the Chinese foreign minister's remarks during Wednesday's press conference.

"Because I consider Madame Connolly as a professional with a thick skin, and she does not need me to go to her rescue," Dion said on the teleconference from Paris, where he was attending a ministerial meeting about the Middle East peace talks.

Dion added that he raised the issue of human rights "very clearly" during the press conference with the Chinese foreign minister.

Human rights cases were discussed "very, very frankly" in his meeting with Wang, he said, including the rights for Chinese journalists in China. "I think that's the best way to see progress made."

Conservative foreign affairs critic Tony Clement said in a post on Twitter that Dion's delayed response was "Feeble, but better late than never."

Clement, who served as a cabinet minister under the previous Conservative government, argued on Thursday that such behaviour would never be tolerated from any Canadian official during an official trip to China.

"If we go to Beijing, as ministers or MPs, we were always told there are certain historical and cultural aspects of the Chinese that we have to be deferential to — and respectful of — and then he comes here and disrespects our values," he told CBC News. "So that was unacceptable."

Trudeau: "We respect journalists in this country"

7 years ago
Duration 0:55
Justin Trudeau responds to Liberal supporter heckling a reporter

Friday's remarks were not the first time Trudeau made a point of publicly defending freedom of the press.

During a campaign stop in Montreal days before the recent federal election, a group of Trudeau supporters were heard booing a CTV journalist for asking about Liberal campaign co-chair Dan Gagnier, who had resigned over his connection to the energy sector.

Trudeau turned to the crowd and told them to cut it out.

"Hey, guys, guys. Hey, we have respect for journalists in this country. They ask tough questions and they're supposed to, okay?"

With files from CBC's Janyce McGregor


To encourage thoughtful and respectful conversations, first and last names will appear with each submission to CBC/Radio-Canada's online communities (except in children and youth-oriented communities). Pseudonyms will no longer be permitted.

By submitting a comment, you accept that CBC has the right to reproduce and publish that comment in whole or in part, in any manner CBC chooses. Please note that CBC does not endorse the opinions expressed in comments. Comments on this story are moderated according to our Submission Guidelines. Comments are welcome while open. We reserve the right to close comments at any time.

Become a CBC Member

Join the conversation  Create account

Already have an account?