Why CBC used sign language to interpret federal leader interviews

CBC presents an election first by adding sign language interpreting to interviews with the federal leaders. But some in the deaf community would rather see closed captioning on all the video CBC posts online.

It may be an election first, but is ASL better than closed captioning?

ASL edition produced for leaders interviews

7 years ago
Duration 1:17
In a first, CBC has produced sign language editions of federal leader interviews.

A television program that CBC News will broadcast on Saturday may create some election buzz — and debate — in one community.

In what is said to be an election first, a 90-minute special edition of Mansbridge One on One on the CBC News Network channel will include sign language interpretation of Peter Mansbridge's interviews with the federal party leaders.

Those interviews, with the interpretation and closed captioning, are now available online. Click on the links on this web page.

Gary Malkowski, an adviser to the president of the Canadian Hearing Society, says the broadcast is very significant, even historic, since it's the first time a Canadian broadcaster has showcased American Sign Language during a federal election.

But Michael Hale, an activist in the deaf community, said that while he salutes the broadcast, he says CBC shouldn't put more money into adding sign language to programs.

We'll come back to that debate later. First, here's a look how the program was created.

How and why it was done

Last weekend, the CBC producers worked in the studio with two deaf sign language interpreters and two hearing interpreters, all of whom had previously gone over video and transcripts of the interviews, which had already been broadcast.

The hearing interpreters stood beside the camera doing their interpretation, working in tandem with the deaf interpreters, who were on camera.

Laura Henry interprets Gary Malkowski at the Canadian Hearing Society during an interview with CBC News. He would prefer to watch news programs with sign language. (Kara-Ann Miel/CHS)

Malkowski says that sign language is like a native language for deaf persons and their interpretation, compared to a hearing interpreter's, is like the difference between when someone interprets spoken language into their mother tongue rather into a learned language. 

For a deaf person, a deaf interpreter "uplifts and supports that understanding, and the eyes of the viewer are that much more relaxed because they're not having to work at understanding, whereas with an ASL English hearing interpreter, they're really working to understand all of the context, all of the information." Malkowski said to CBC News through a hearing sign language interpreter.

Heather Boyce, CBC's director for accessibility, had been pushing for this kind of pilot project for some time and had hoped to do it for the debate that the major broadcasters would run. "Closed captioning doesn't do the job with debates," she says, due to all the overlapping chatter, plus it's hard for the captioners to keep up.

After the debate didn't happen, CBC opted to add sign language to the Mansbridge interviews.

Malkowski, a former Ontario politician, would prefer to watch news programs with sign language, while Hale, a business consultant specializing in accessibility and design, says he finds it very irritating and hates it, even though his first language is ASL. He recommends CBC not spend money on sign language interpreting but use those funds to make captioning an option on all their online video.

Closed captioning vs. sign language

Hale gave many reasons for favouring captioned video rather than adding sign language. Closed caption text is seen the same everywhere, he says, while ASL has an "accent," making it "problematic for deaf from different parts of the country," he told CBC News by email.

He also said that ASL has less technical detail than English, reading closed captioning is an excellent way for deaf persons to improve their literacy, and "ASL-dubbed is going to be super expensive."

Although Michael Hale's first language is ASL, he wants CBC to invest in closed captioning all their online video rather than adding sign language interpreting. (Cameron Arksey/WARPAINT Media)

Still, he's happy to see CBC doing an ASL pilot project and that it will mean a lot to the deaf community. But he says "ASL-dubbed is not a way to go," except for emergency announcements and government-related events like a speech from the throne, an election call or an election debate.

Malkowski, meanwhile, congratulates CBC for being a leader in accessibility for TV broadcasts and showcasing ASL. "It's going to help other TV broadcasters recognize the importance" of accessibility for the deaf community and he hopes "this starts a ripple effect and we do see more ASL content."

Audiences are different, Malkowski says, and so he favours a range of accessibility options. "Some will be looking at the captioning, other prefer to see the sign language." And more than the deaf community would access content in ASL, like the hearing children of deaf parents.

U.S. leads Canada

Both Malkowski and Hale say the United States is ahead of Canada on accessibility, especially for closed captioning of online video. The U.S. 21st Century Communications and Video Accessibility Act, which became law in 2010, requires broadcasters to include closed captioning for TV programs they post online, for example.

CBC's Boyce says the CRTC has been politely nudging Canada's mainstream broadcasters to do the same. She says CBC leads in online closed captioning but needs to do more, and that Shaw Communications is also captioning some online video. While CBC.ca has closed captioning online for programs that are broadcast on TV, there's very little on video clips, segments from programs or online-only content.

Wayne Nicholson interprets during a Peter Mansbridge interview. Ontario Interpreting Services provided the interpreters for the show. (CBC)

But she says CBC is working on that and getting close to finding a solution for maintaining the captioning option on video excerpted from programs. Closed captioning for online video remains "a big undertaking."

A big disappointment for Hale is that Rick Mercer's video clips don't have closed captioning.

For the federal election, he's started an online petition calling on the next Parliament to "provide an entitlement for deaf citizens to access media online with mandated closed captioning," similar to the provision in the U.S. accessibility act. "Technology changed and the rules didn't," his petition states.

Without online closed captioning "we are second-class citizens who can't get equal access," Hale told CBC News. "We can do anything but hear."

Mansbridge One on One: The Interviews airs Saturday, Oct. 17 at 6:30 - 8:00 p.m. ET on CBC News Network.

Sign language interpreter Timothy Mallach interprets Peter Mansbridge's interview with Tom Mulcair on Mansbridge One on One. The program airs Sat., Oct. 17 at 6:30 p.m. ET on CBC News Network.

Silent News, 1991

Long ago, CBC's news channel, then called Newsworld, presented Silent News, a weekly half-hour newscast in American Sign Language, interpreted for the hearing audience. Deaf anchor Henry Whelan presented the program in ASL. Closed captioning was still in its infancy and required decoders that sold for $400.

Silent News debuted July 6, 1991. Executive producer Peter Reynolds said the newscast lasted two seasons before funding provided by the Ontario government ran out.


To encourage thoughtful and respectful conversations, first and last names will appear with each submission to CBC/Radio-Canada's online communities (except in children and youth-oriented communities). Pseudonyms will no longer be permitted.

By submitting a comment, you accept that CBC has the right to reproduce and publish that comment in whole or in part, in any manner CBC chooses. Please note that CBC does not endorse the opinions expressed in comments. Comments on this story are moderated according to our Submission Guidelines. Comments are welcome while open. We reserve the right to close comments at any time.

Become a CBC Member

Join the conversation  Create account

Already have an account?