Quebec religious symbols ban proposal roundly condemned

Quebec is about to launch its next debate on minority accommodation according to a report that says the provincial government is preparing to introduce restrictions on religious symbols and the wearing of head coverings in public sector workplaces.

Turbans, hijabs, kippas to face restrictions in province as part of 'Charter of Quebec Values,' report says

Quebec moves to ban religious symbols for public workers

10 years ago
Duration 2:34
Featured VideoPQ government wants to 'protect religious neutrality'

Quebec has launched its next debate on minority accommodation — and this one could make the erstwhile soccer-turban ban look like a leisurely stroll on the pitch.

The government is preparing to introduce long-awaited legislation that would restrict religious symbols in numerous places.

A media report Tuesday with leaked details of the Parti Quebecois government's "Charter of Quebec Values" says the proposed policy will prohibit public employees from donning Sikh, Jewish and Muslim headwear in the workplace.

It appears the PQ hopes to cash in at the ballot box by championing a position on secularism that polls have suggested has considerable support in the province.

Soccer turban fight a preview

'This will feed an attitude of exclusion. It will send a message to people who don't feel comfortable here — who feel rejected in Quebec'—Charles Taylor, academic and former accommodation commissioner

The fiery debate that erupted over a recent ban on wearing turbans on Quebec soccer fields offered a sneak peek of the what could be in the political pipeline for the national assembly's fall session.

The turban ban was lifted by the Quebec Soccer Federation due to external pressure — but not before it made headlines around the world. Inside Quebec, Premier Pauline Marois rushed to the defence of the soccer federation and accused its detractors of Quebec-bashing.

Tuesday's report in the Journal de Montréal says the PQ government is set to prevent employees in public institutions like schools and hospitals from wearing religious symbols such as turbans, niqabs, kippas, hijabs and highly visible crucifixes.

The approach is being roundly condemned by civil-rights experts, including prominent lawyer Julius Grey, who expects any such legislation to face court challenges under the Charter of Rights.

"The type of secularism that is being promoted goes beyond what is acceptable," he said in an interview.

"Now, it doesn't mean that the Supreme Court will not uphold it. Legal decisions aren't made in a vacuum and maybe our atmosphere, our social climate, is changing to the point where this will be the future. I hope not."

'Unprecedented' approach

Charles Taylor, a well-known political philosopher who co-presided over Quebec's commission on the accommodation of minorities, expressed outrage at the policy.

He told the French-language CBC that it's one thing to ban a teacher from wearing a burka, because an impediment to clear face-to-face communication could have an impact on other people — namely, the students.

Philosopher Charles Taylor co-presided over a commission that looked at the accommodation of minorities in Quebec in 2007 and 2008. (Ryan Remiorz/Canadian Press)

But he condemned a wall-to-wall, draconian approach.

"It's unprecedented," he told Radio-Canada Tuesday.

"This will feed an attitude of exclusion. It will send a message to people who don't feel comfortable here — who feel rejected in Quebec."

He said as his commission toured the province, immigrants repeatedly told him that the reason they came here was for freedom.

"Now we're slamming the door in their face," Taylor said.

The idea of a blanket ban on the wearing religious symbols "is like something we would see in Putin's Russia," he said.

Past opinion polls, however, suggest such policies enjoy broad public support in Quebec. A majority have told pollsters they supported the turban ban and also viewed hijabs and kippas as a cultural threat.

What's less clear is how the policy will hold up in the long term, in two key arenas: the court system, and the ballot box.

The PQ has in the past bluntly stated that it would gladly fight a legal battle up to the Supreme Court over the issue — and would hope to use the issue to stir up support for its main cause of separating from Canada.

Health care, economy still top voters' priority list

But before getting there, there's no guarantee the minority government could get the policy through the legislature or win an election on it.

As popular as the PQ's approach might prove to be, other polls suggest that only a minuscule sliver of Quebec voters actually care about this as an election issue — and that what really drives the Quebec electorate are bread-and-butter issues like health care, education and the economy.

A Leger Marketing poll before last year's election placed the issue of immigrant integration as the top electoral priority for a paltry one per cent of respondents — at No. 15 on voters' list of issues.

Other identity issues hardly fared better in that poll. Sovereignty was the 10th most-commonly cited issue, and the protection of French was at No. 12.

Health care, by comparison, was the No. 1 issue, cited by 35 per cent of respondents. Lowering taxes, fighting corruption, school fees, creating jobs, trimming down the civil service and the environment were Nos. 2 to 6 on the minds of the 1,648 respondents of the online poll.

Liberal leader Philippe Couillard reacted coolly Tuesday to the proposal, calling the details that were leaked to Le Journal de Montreal a "trial balloon."

He said it was the PQ's attempt to divert the public's attention away from economic issues, which aren't seen as the sovereigntist party's strong suit.

Federal NDP Leader Tom Mulcair also responded cautiously to the newspaper report Tuesday.

"I won't talk about hypotheses," Mulcair said in French Tuesday in Montreal.

with files from CBC News