Prison experts call on Justice Minister Jody Wilson-Raybould to restrict solitary confinement

Prison policy experts are urging the federal government to act fast on a promise to limit solitary confinement behind bars. A panel of academics and advocates plans to put pressure on new Justice Minister Jody Wilson-Raybould to abolish the practice they say violates human rights.

Advocate compares prolonged isolation practice to 'torture'

Prison experts and advocates are ramping up pressure on the Liberal government to end the practice of solitary confinement. (Fred Thornhill/Reuters)

Prison policy experts are urging the federal government to act fast on a promise to limit solitary confinement behind bars.

A panel of academics and advocates met Tuesday at the University of Ottawa to develop plans to pressure new Justice Minister Jody Wilson-Raybould to ban or restrict the practice they say violates human rights.

"It's torture," said Justin Piché, a criminology professor  who leads the university's Criminalization and Punishment Education Project.

In a mandate letter from Prime Minister Justin Trudeau, Wilson-Raybould is tasked with implementing recommendations from the inquest into the death of Ashley Smith, including better treatment for mentally ill inmates and tighter restrictions around the use of segregation.

Smith was 19 years old when she choked herself to death in a segregation cell in 2007 as guards stood watch outside. A subsequent coroner's inquest made 104 recommendations, but critics say they have been inadequately addressed.

"We need immediate prohibitions for solitary confinement for youth and for those with mental health concerns because those folks are the ones most susceptible to having the most damage done to them by solitary confinement," Piché said.

Smith was 14 years old when she was first arrested for pitching crab apples at a postal worker.

Piché said the practice should eventually be eliminated entirely, though he expects much resistance from the Correctional Service Canada. Piché said the prison service has a poor track record of making meaningful change.

Separation sometimes necessary

Catherine Latimer, executive director of the John Howard Society of Canada, says there may be some circumstances where separating violent inmates may be necessary to protect individual or institutional safety.

"But we need to find solutions to addressing those flare-ups within a short period of time," she said. "Immediate removal from a situation seems to be fine from my perspective, as long as the solution is being worked on immediately to get them out of segregation."

Latimer said firm time limits of 15 consecutive days and a maximum of 60 days a year, as dictated by United Nations standards for incarceration and recommended by the Smith inquest, must be immediately adopted.

She also called for a prohibition of segregation for anyone with mental illness and more external reviews to monitor the use of segregation.

She said the government could and should act quickly and that CSC would need to implement a plan to ensure no one is put in jeopardy. That could include ensuring gang members aren't on the same range and creating protective living units for people with mental illness.

Legal challenges underway

Ottawa-based human rights lawyer Paul Champ, who is working on a handful of cases challenging solitary confinement practices on constitutional grounds, said the federal government has long been "very well informed" about the problems and devastating impact of prolonged solitary confinement. 

"I think the minister of justice could consult and be in a position to introduce new laws controlling and limiting solitary confinement within the next six months," he said. "The minister of public safety should also direct the commissioner of Correctional Service Canada to take immediate steps to reduce the use of solitary confinement in all its forms and ensure there is a rigorous review of all ongoing cases."

Kim Pate, the executive director of the Canadian Association of Elizabeth Fry Societies, said being held in a cell the size of a small bathroom can make even someone not already suffering from mental health issues hallucinate that walls are closing in on them.

"Many become paranoid about ghosts or staff trying to harm them. They experience dissociation and flashbacks. They injure themselves in unimaginable ways and numbers," she said.

Pate believes Canada must reverse the trend of limiting investments in social, education and health programs and pushing the most marginalized people into an "ever-expanding" criminal justice system with more and more mandatory minimum sentences.

Canada should not only abolish the practice of segregation, but overhaul the entire system of over-crowded and isolating prisons, she said.

"Jails are not shelters or treatment centres. They are the least effective and most expensive non-responses to social justice issues. Around the globe, nation states are revisiting the rush to incarcerate. We need to join those ranks."


To encourage thoughtful and respectful conversations, first and last names will appear with each submission to CBC/Radio-Canada's online communities (except in children and youth-oriented communities). Pseudonyms will no longer be permitted.

By submitting a comment, you accept that CBC has the right to reproduce and publish that comment in whole or in part, in any manner CBC chooses. Please note that CBC does not endorse the opinions expressed in comments. Comments on this story are moderated according to our Submission Guidelines. Comments are welcome while open. We reserve the right to close comments at any time.

Become a CBC Member

Join the conversation  Create account

Already have an account?