O'Toole says Canada-U.S. relations have never been worse
Conservative leader says he's thankful U.S. president's 'Build Back Better' bill has been quashed
Conservative Leader Erin O'Toole said today the Canada-U.S. relationship is at its lowest point in decades — a development that threatens to stall Canada's growth and derail some sectors of the economy.
Speaking at a virtual event with Nova Scotia chambers of commerce, O'Toole said Prime Minister Justin Trudeau has done little to stop the U.S. from pursuing punitive policies. O'Toole pointed to a list of grievances, including recent hikes to softwood lumber tariffs and an ongoing dispute over P.E.I. potatoes.
In November, the U.S. Department of Commerce doubled the amount of duty it imposes on softwood lumber coming from Canada — a significant escalation in the years-long fight over this issue. Washington claims Canadian producers dump their product in the U.S. at subsidized prices, undercutting their American counterparts.
Last month, facing threats from the U.S., Canada voluntarily halted fresh potato exports from P.E.I. after a wart fungus was discovered at two of the province's farms.
And just last week, the U.S. Trade Representative's office claimed victory when Canada lost a fight over trade quotas for dairy products before a Canada-U.S.-Mexico Agreement (CUSMA) dispute panel.
Those trade losses follow U.S. President Joe Biden's earlier decision to cancel permits for the Keystone XL pipeline — a multi-billion dollar blow to Alberta's oilpatch. The Biden administration also has done little to stop Michigan Gov. Gretchen Whitmer, a Democrat, from trying to shut down Enbridge's Line 5 pipeline — a crucial artery that supplies oil products and natural gas to power huge portions of the Canadian economy.
"We have never seen, in modern Canadian history, Canada-U.S. relations at such a low point. We just lost a recent trade battle with respect to supply management — we've been losing on agriculture. We're losing on forestry products. There's been steel and aluminum tariffs and Buy America that has us losing on manufacturing," O'Toole said, pointing to a U.S. government policy to shift government procurement to American firms.
O'Toole said snarled Canada-U.S. supply chains also have resulted in higher consumer prices at home.
"Since the 1960s, Canada has had an integrated supply chain, particularly in manufacturing, with the U.S. and we should be restoring that relationship and making sure supply chain shortages — whether it's microchips or food — are solved on a Canada-U.S. basis," he said. "That would start easing off the pressure we're seeing with inflation."
While lamenting the state of bilateral relations, O'Toole cheered the apparent defeat of Biden's signature piece of domestic legislation, the Build Back Better Act.
That $1.9 trillion bill included a sizeable tax credit worth up to $12,500 US to buyers of new electric vehicles (EVs) — as long as those cars are manufactured by union workers in the United States. That credit had the potential to devastate the Canadian auto sector.
"Thankfully, the Build Back Better plan was held back by one U.S. senator," O'Toole said, referring to U.S. Senator Joe Manchin, a Democrat from West Virginia. "Mr. Biden's plan would have unfairly assisted electric vehicle manufacturing in the United States."
Before Manchin said he'd vote against the bill and the tax credits — the U.S. Senate is evenly split between Democrats and Republicans and his support was central to the bill's passage — the Canadian government vowed to take strong retaliatory action.
In a statement to CBC News, a spokesperson for International Trade Minister Mary Ng said the government "will take no lessons from Conservatives when it comes to defending Canadians interests."
"When we retaliated against unfair U.S. steel and aluminum tariffs, Conservatives urged us to stop fighting back. When we were negotiating for a better CUSMA deal, the Conservatives wanted Canada to capitulate to U.S. demands," Alice Hansen said.
"In a relationship as large and significant as the one we have with the United States, there will always be challenges. We have worked together and have resolved many of these in the past, and that work continues and we will continue to get it done."
On softwood lumber, Ng recently filed a challenge under CUSMA, the North American trade pact, against the new U.S. softwood lumber duties. Canadian and U.S. officials are also scheduled to meet this week to negotiate an end to the dispute over P.E.I. potatoes.
It's not the first time the opposition leader has lambasted Trudeau's handling of the bilateral relationship. At the North American Leaders' Summit in November, Biden said Canada was one his "easiest" relationships, a comment that prompted O'Toole to call Trudeau a "pushover" and remark that "a one-way street is quite easy."
"It is no wonder President Biden said that Canada under this prime minister is his 'easiest' relationship. It is easy for the U.S. to win under this government," O'Toole said in a December speech in the House of Commons.
"The current prime minister has led our country through the steepest decline in Canada-U.S. relations in the modern age over the course of three different administrations," O'Toole said in another November speech.
"It is easy for the U.S. to dominate, easy for the U.S. to win with the current prime minister and easy to ignore Canada under the current Liberal government."
To encourage thoughtful and respectful conversations, first and last names will appear with each submission to CBC/Radio-Canada's online communities (except in children and youth-oriented communities). Pseudonyms will no longer be permitted.
By submitting a comment, you accept that CBC has the right to reproduce and publish that comment in whole or in part, in any manner CBC chooses. Please note that CBC does not endorse the opinions expressed in comments. Comments on this story are moderated according to our Submission Guidelines. Comments are welcome while open. We reserve the right to close comments at any time.
Become a CBC Account Holder
Join the conversation Create account
Already have an account?