Justin Trudeau upset Tory MP questioned his faith

Liberal MP Justin Trudeau says he is upset and offended by a Tory MP who publicly questioned his adherence to the Catholic faith and his suitability to speak to students at a Catholic school.
Liberal MP Justin Trudeau casts his vote in Canada's federal election in Montreal, May 2, 2011. Trudeau says he's offended that Conservative MP Dean Del Mastro is questioning his commitment to his Catholic faith. (Graham Hughes/Canadian Press)

Liberal MP Justin Trudeau says he is upset and offended by a Tory MP who publicly questioned his adherence to the Catholic faith and his suitability to speak to students at a Catholic school. 

Dean Del Mastro, the parliamentary secretary to the prime minister, said on Facebook last month that it was "outrageous" the Catholic school board in Peterborough, Ont. had invited Trudeau to speak for a second time in three years.

"If they are looking for a truly great speaker, who also happens to be Catholic, perhaps they might invite [Immigration] Minister Jason Kenney," Del Mastro wrote on Oct. 12.

"Are there any tenets of the Catholic faith that Justin supports?"

Trudeau had been asked by the Peterborough Victoria Northumberland and Clarington Catholic School Board to speak to 300 students from six area high schools on Oct. 13 at a downtown hall.

Trudeau says he spoke for free, and the topic was the importance of young people showing leadership.

The 39-year-old son of former Liberal Prime Minister Pierre Trudeau said he was raised Catholic by his father, going to church every weekend and saying prayers nightly as a family.

The elder Trudeau's Catholicism has been well documented in biographies, including one book specifically on his faith. The former prime minister was educated by the Jesuits and admitted to going regularly to church up until the last years of his life.

"I have to say, I'm really surprisingly upset. I didn't think I would be, but I am," Trudeau told The Canadian Press on Tuesday evening. 

"For someone to start questioning my own faith and accusing me of being a bad Catholic, is something that I really take issue with. My own personal faith is an extremely important part of who I am and the values that I try to lead with."

Trudeau added that neither he nor his father saw any incongruity between enshrining the rights of gays and lesbians, for example, and the tenets of Catholicism. He notes that he is personally very opposed to abortion, but still believes nobody can tell a woman what she should do with her body.

"My own credo is completely consistent with that, and I'll defend my own faith and my own values to the utmost extent," Trudeau said.

"To have someone like Dean Del Mastro question me on that is, I think, we're sinking to definite new lows in politics and it doesn't surprise me, it just manages to continue to dismay me."

Del Mastro stands by comments

Del Mastro stands by his original comments, saying Wednesday that Trudeau's public positions "are often not in any accordance with the Catholic faith." He has been critical in the past of Trudeau receiving money to speak at different venues.

The Conservative MP says he takes issue specifically with the message that Trudeau is sending to the young people. He points to a recent radio interview Trudeau gave.

"So what I'd like to do is I encourage them to connect with their world, to go out and occupy something, you know, to get involved in creating a community group, get involved in creating a protest group," Trudeau told CFRA radio on Monday.

Says Del Mastro: "I don't encourage people to go out and occupy things. I encourage them to follow through on their education and support them. I don't think that's something that most parents in the Catholic system would appreciate being presented to their kids."

The Peterborough teacher who first invited Trudeau to speak says he finds Del Mastro's comments "petty."

"First of all, my question is: who is the faith police? Who are the people who are supposed to be judging somebody's faith?" said Trevor Digby, department chair of Canadian and world studies at Holy Cross Secondary School.

"Is that not a private matter? When we invite speakers, we don't go out and do a police record check on their faith, unless they've done something outrageous."

'Between God and me'

Green Party Leader Elizabeth May, who has studied to be an Anglican minister, says judging who best adheres to their faith doesn't have a place in Parliament – or in society.

"It is not for someone else ever, and frankly it's against scripture, to take that view of someone else," she told CBC News.

May says it's fair to ask politicians about their beliefs, but it's offensive for Del Mastro to judge Trudeau.

"There's only one entity that's supposed to be judgmental, and it's not in that House," she said.

Trudeau said Thursday he's had a lot of public support on the issue.

"My faith is between God and me, and even the Conservatives with their majority don't have the power to intervene," Trudeau told CBC News.

With files from CBC News