Politics

Liberals want another year of hybrid Parliament, which Tories reject as needless

Liberal House leader Mark Holland announced Monday that the government plans to allow members of Parliament to appear virtually for another year — but the opposition Conservatives have been insisting MPs should be in their seats except in special circumstances.

Conservatives have been insisting MPs should be in their seats except in special circumstances

Leader of the Government in the House of Commons Mark Holland speaks during a news conference on Nov. 22, 2021 in Ottawa. (Adrian Wyld/The Canadian Press)

The governing Liberals want members of Parliament to have the option to appear virtually for another year, while Conservatives contend they should instead be signalling it's time for Canada to return to a pre-pandemic normal.

Government House leader Mark Holland made the announcement Monday at the start of what is expected to be Parliament's final week of sitting before taking a break for summer, after speaking with House leaders from opposition parties.

Rules allowing MPs to appear virtually in the House of Commons — at first entirely and then in a hybrid format — were introduced near the start of the COVID-19 pandemic, after Parliament adjourned for a time when public health officials were urging people to work from home.

Members of Parliament cast their first virtual vote, using video-conference technology, in September 2020 and then were able to do so through an app the following spring.

Since then, millions of Canadians have been returning to work in different formats.

Holland said the government will be moving forward with a motion to extend the hybrid virtual Parliament for another year. Debate is expected to take place over Tuesday and Wednesday.

The House of Commons in Ottawa on Tuesday March 24, 2020. Rules allowing MPs to appear virtually in the House of Commons and to vote using an app on their phones were introduced at the start of the COVID-19 pandemic in 2020, when public health officials urged people to work from home. (Adrian Wyld/The Canadian Press)

He argued the flexibility is still needed. Last week, five members — including Prime Minister Justin Trudeau — had COVID-19 and could not appear in person.

Holland said he's sympathetic to calls from opposition benches to have MPs attend the House of Commons in person and is committed to having government members physically show up to provide answers during question period, barring illness or the emergence of a new COVID-19 variant that is cause for concern.

Conservative House leader pushes back against motion

Opposition House leader John Brassard challenged the Liberals to provide evidence the country faces the threat of another variant-driven wave when MPs are set to reconvene in the House of Commons in September. He said the extension is unnecessary.

Brassard said Parliament has proven it can adapt quickly when the pandemic flares up and suggested the Liberals should wait to see what happens in the fall rather than force MPs to spend the final days of its sitting debating the matter.

"If anyone or any institution is to signal to Canadians that we're getting back to some sense of normalcy, it should be the House of Commons," he told a news conference on Monday.

Brassard also pushed back on Liberal assertions the hybrid system of running Parliament worked well. Some committees descended into chaos because MPs appeared virtually, he said, citing one time that the app used for voting collapsed.

Opposition House leader John Brassard pushed back on Liberal assertions the hybrid system of running Parliament worked well. Some committees descended into chaos because MPs appeared virtually, he said, and cited one time that the app used for voting collapsed. (Sean Kilpatrick/The Canadian Press)

Moreover, he pointed to injuries reported by interpreters who provide language translation services to MPs because of the quality of programs being used to host virtual appearances.

The NDP has said it will support the motion to extend hybrid sittings. The Bloc Quebecois has not yet given its final decision on the matter.

Federal Labour Minister Seamus O'Regan praised the value of allowing MPs the chance to work from their constituencies instead of spending the time commuting back and forth to Ottawa on a weekly basis.

"To have flexibility for so many MPs with young kids and families, I think we'll get even better people if we can offer some flexibility," he said Monday.

Conservative MP Laila Goodridge said she and her husband regularly travel to Ottawa from her riding in northern Alberta with their son young and believes it's time for MPs to return to work in person.

"This is not necessarily the job if you are looking for work-life balance," she said.

Holland said the plan to extend hybrid Parliament includes a request for a parliamentary committee to study MPs' use of the virtual option and the voting app.

Monday marks the first day in months that MPs can enter buildings on the Parliament precinct regardless of their vaccination status.

It was announced last week that the COVID-19 vaccine mandate would be suspended for the area, following a government decision to lift a mandate covering federally regulated sectors like air travel and the federal civil service.

One MP who welcomed that news was rural Saskatchewan MP Cathay Wagantall.

She refused to disclose her vaccination status and has been unable to take her seat in the House since the rule took effect last November.

"I'm looking forward to being in my seat on Monday, if all the details can come together to enable me to be there, " she said in a statement last Friday.

"No longer being denied my right to represent my constituents in the House of a Commons is a welcome result and a good use of a unanimous consent motion."

Conservative MP Colin Carrie, who had also refused to disclose his vaccination status, appeared in the House of Commons on Monday for the first time since before the mandate.

"It's been a while," he said as he entered the building.

Comments

To encourage thoughtful and respectful conversations, first and last names will appear with each submission to CBC/Radio-Canada's online communities (except in children and youth-oriented communities). Pseudonyms will no longer be permitted.

By submitting a comment, you accept that CBC has the right to reproduce and publish that comment in whole or in part, in any manner CBC chooses. Please note that CBC does not endorse the opinions expressed in comments. Comments on this story are moderated according to our Submission Guidelines. Comments are welcome while open. We reserve the right to close comments at any time.

Become a CBC Member

Join the conversation  Create account

Already have an account?

now