Greenpeace calls for Elections Canada probe of Ethical Oil

Greenpeace Canada is asking Elections Canada to investigate whether the Ethical Oil Institute is colluding with the Conservative Party in order to get around rules that limit donations to political parties.

The environmental advocacy group alleges some political parties use 3rd parties for fundraising

Keith Stewart, Climate and Energy Campaign Coordinator for Greenpeace, says his organization is concerned a political party is using a third-party organization to get around election financing laws. (greepeace.org)

Greenpeace Canada is asking Elections Canada to investigate whether the Ethical Oil Institute is colluding with the Conservative Party in order to get around rules that limit donations to political parties.

Keith Stewart, the climate and energy campaigner for Greenpeace, has written a letter to the commissioner of Canada Elections complaining that Ethical Oil is using money raised from individuals and companies to attack government critics.

As well, the letter alleges, "mirrored messaging" is going on between Ethical Oil spokespeople and Conservative cabinet ministers.

The complaint also alleges "multiple crossovers" between Ethical Oil spokespeople and Ottawa ministerial staff.

Stewart repeated the complaints at a press conference in Ottawa on Tuesday morning.

The Ethical Oil Institute, founded by writer and television host Ezra Levant, runs a website called EthicalOil.org that urges people to support Canada's oilsands. The site, set up in 2011, claims Canada's oil is inherently more ethical than oil produced by non­democratic countries headed by dictators.

Ethical Oil's first spokesperson was Alykhan Velshi, who left Jason Kenney's staff when he was immigration minister to work for the group. A few months later, Velshi returned to a senior position in the Prime Minister's Office.

In its letter, Greenpeace notes that Velshi's successor at Ethical Oil was Kathryn Marshall, who is married to Hamish Marshall, a former strategic planning manager in the PMO.

Kathryn Marshall, according to Greenpeace, was then replaced by Jamie Ellerton, a former assistant to Kenney as well as to Ontario Conservative Party Leader Tim Hudak.

CBC News has asked Ethical Oil and the Conservative Party for comment on Greenpeace's complaints.

Donation limits to political parties

Political party financing laws limit individual donations to a total of $1,200 a year and ban corporate donations entirely.

Ethical Oil asks for donations from individuals and companies on its website, and has a PayPal button to facilitate sending money to the site, but it does not issue charitable receipts.

It also encourages activist participation, and in 2012 urged its supporters to write to then Natural Resources Minister Joe Oliver to tell him "we don't want foreign interests or their local puppet groups manipulating our decision about our pipelines."

Those groups were identified by Ethical Oil as the West Coast Environmental Law Association, Environmental Defence Canada and the Pembina Environmental Association, among others.

Greenpeace argues election financing laws are breached even if a third party — in this case Ethical Oil — does not directly transfer money to a political party. There is no allegation in the letter that Ethical Oil is transferring money to the Conservatives.

Greenpeace is urging the commissioner of elections to find that if Ethical Oil spends funds it raises on activities supporting a political party's agenda, and has been set up by someone involved in the political party, then political donation limits have been contravened.

Stewart was asked by a reporter whether Greenpeace has at times aligned itself with the policies of the NDP or the Green Party.

"You don't see the same kind of cooperation," Stewart replied. "We've been around since 1972 and we have a mandate. We will work with anybody, and we'll challenge anybody."

Greenpeace wants ruling before 2015

"We think there's a good chance the oil patch could put a bunch of money into Ethical Oil in the lead­up to the 2015 election, and we would like Elections Canada to rule on this now," Stewart said in an interview.

Ethical Oil differs from other advocacy groups that may have connections with political parties, Stewart said.

"This was a group set up by Conservative staffers, run by Conservative staffers, and everyone has direct links to the Conservative Party and it has been set up to further that party's agenda."

Ethical Oil has been singled out by critics for its Conservative Party connections before, but this is the first time it has been accused of transgressing election financing laws.

Cory Hann, a spokesman for the Conservative Party, said in an email he did not want to comment on Greenpeace's allegations, which he termed "ridiculous."


To encourage thoughtful and respectful conversations, first and last names will appear with each submission to CBC/Radio-Canada's online communities (except in children and youth-oriented communities). Pseudonyms will no longer be permitted.

By submitting a comment, you accept that CBC has the right to reproduce and publish that comment in whole or in part, in any manner CBC chooses. Please note that CBC does not endorse the opinions expressed in comments. Comments on this story are moderated according to our Submission Guidelines. Comments are welcome while open. We reserve the right to close comments at any time.