Canada threatens U.S. with tariffs, partial suspension of CUSMA over electric vehicle tax credit
Deputy PM Chrystia Freeland and International Trade Minister Mary Ng made threat in letter to U.S. senators
Deputy Prime Minister Chrystia Freeland has written to top U.S. senators threatening to suspend parts of the CUSMA trade agreement and impose tariffs on American goods unless U.S. officials back away from a proposed tax credit for American-built electric vehicles.
"We are deeply concerned that certain provisions of the electric vehicle tax credits as proposed in the Build Back Better Act violate the United States' obligations under the United States-Mexico-Canada Agreement," Freeland and International Trade Minister Mary Ng say in the letter.
"The proposal is equivalent to a 34 per cent tariff on Canadian-assembled electric vehicles," the letter says. "The proposal is a significant threat to the Canadian automotive industry and is a de facto abrogation of the USMCA."
The Canada-U.S.-Mexico Agreement (CUSMA) is known as the United States-Mexico-Canada Agreement (USMCA) in the United States.
Congress is proposing sizeable tax credits worth up to $12,500 US to buyers of new electric vehicles — as long as those cars are manufactured by union workers in the U.S.
Experts agree the tax measure would deal a major blow to the Canadian automotive sector, which is trying to attract new investment as the industry transitions away from internal combustion engines.
In the letter addressed to Senate Majority Leader Charles Schumer and Senate Minority Leader Mitch McConnell — along with six other senators who sit on key Senate committees — Freeland and Ng point to the integrated nature of the North American automotive industry.
"We have been building cars together for over 50 years," the letter says. "Canadian-assembled vehicles ... contain approximately 50 per cent U.S. content and Canada imports over $22 billion worth of automotive parts from the U.S. annually."
Reviving the threat of tariffs
The letter asks senators "not to discriminate against" Canada and to work together to build electric cars in a way that does not undermine the integrated continental carmaking industry.
"We want to be clear that if there is no satisfactory resolution to this matter, Canada will defend its national interests, as we did when we were faced with unjustified tariffs on Canadian steel and aluminum," the letter says.
Watch: 'Canada is prepared to stand up for our national interests,' says Ng.:
In 2019, the U.S. Department of Commerce slapped tariffs of 25 per cent on imports of steel and 10 per cent on aluminum, citing national security interests. Canada, Mexico and a number of other countries were affected.
Canada retaliated with its own tariffs of 25 per cent on steel and 10 per cent on aluminum, and also imposed a 10 per cent tariff on multiple consumer items, targeting U.S. politicians in states where those products are made.
That product list included Kentucky bourbon, lawn mowers, ketchup, maple syrup, appliances, boats and many other items. The federal government said it was targeting goods that Canadians could otherwise buy from domestic suppliers.
'We do not wish to go down a path of confrontation'
The letter threatens "tariffs on American exports in a manner that will impact American workers in the auto sector" and tariffs on U.S. consumer items.
"In the coming days, we are preparing to publish a list of U.S. products that may face Canadian tariffs if there is no satisfactory resolution of this issue," the letter said.
Watch: Canada pressures U.S. on trade:
The letter comes a week after Mexico threatened its own trade action against the U.S. over the tax credit, which it says violates the trade deal between the three countries.
According to the Associated Press, Tatiana Clouthier, Mexico's secretary of the economy, said her country "would apply trade reprisals" — a reference to possible tariff action.
"This bill is not consistent with the U.S. obligations under the [CUSMA] and the rules of World Trade Organization," the agency reported her saying.
- VideoCanada won't resolve electric vehicle dispute with U.S. by citing new NAFTA, former ambassador says
Freeland and Ng also say in the letter that they will "consider the possible suspension of USMCA concessions of importance to the U.S." They specifically mention the possible suspension of "USMCA dairy tariff-rate quotas" and the possibility of delaying implementation of CUSMA copyright changes.
"To be clear, we do not wish to go down a path of confrontation," the letter says. "That has not been the history of the relationship between our two countries – nor should it be the future.
"There is an opportunity to work together to resolve this issue by ensuring Canadian-assembled vehicles and batteries are eligible for the same credit as U.S.-assembled vehicles and batteries."
Ng said the letter is Canada's way of indicating that it's prepared to play hardball on the trade file, although she would prefer to come to a compromise that avoids trade actions.
"We are, of course, preparing for the worst. We have to prepare for the worst because it's our responsibility to do that but it is our objective to continue to work with the Americans," Ng told CBC News Network's Power & Politics on Friday.
"We are continuing to have discussions with the American administration, with congressional leaders. That work continues. We also are communicating that Canada is prepared to stand up for our national interests."