Freeland grilled over mounting cost of pandemic aid programs for business

Finance Minister Chrystia Freeland was grilled Thursday over the mounting cost of providing relief programs to help Canadians and businesses weather the COVID-19 pandemic.

Liberals have reached an agreement with opposition parties to fast-track latest emergency aid legislation

Deputy Prime Minister and Minister of Finance Chrystia Freeland faced questions Thursday in the House of Commons about the government's programs to help businesses through the pandemic. (Adrian Wyld/The Canadian Press)

Finance Minister Chrystia Freeland was grilled Thursday over the mounting cost of providing relief programs to help Canadians and businesses weather the COVID-19 pandemic.

During a four-hour question-and-answer session in the House of Commons, Freeland refused to provide any new numbers about the size of this year's deficit, the overall federal debt or the potential ballooning cost of servicing that debt should record-low interest rates begin to rise.

She told MPs that those projections would come in a fiscal update later this fall, not before. She declined to set a date for that update.

"I don't think the minister has given a single number with regards to any of these questions," Conservative finance critic Pierre Poilievre complained at one point during a series of sharp exchanges with Freeland.

"She won't tell us the limits on the debt, she won't tell us how much the Bank of Canada has printed to fund her government's debt, she won't tell us whether the debt will be paid back before interest rates rise. Is there anything mathematical or numerical that anyone on the government side can share with the Canadian taxpayers who will have to repay that debt?"

Freeland countered with two numbers, arguing that debt servicing charges as a share of GDP "are the lowest in 100 years" and that 76 per cent of Canadians who lost their jobs due to the pandemic are back at work.

But Poilievre accused Freeland of a coverup and of being afraid of disclosing the real costs of the billions in relief programs the government has created.

"I'm not afraid of much," Freeland countered, challenging Poilievre to come clean with Canadians.

Conservative Member of Parliament Pierre Poilievre and Freeland sparred over the size of Canada's deficit. She said financial projections would come in a fiscal update later this fall, not before. (Sean Kilpatrick/The Canadian Press)

"The Conservatives need to decide, are they the party of austerity or do they believe in supporting Canadians through this crisis."

The grilling took place as part of an agreement among all parties to fast-track the government's latest emergency aid bill, which would provide rent relief for businesses and extend the wage subsidy program.

Bill C-9 would extend the federal wage subsidy until next summer, cancelling a previously planned decline in its value, as well as expand a popular business loan program.

The legislation would also redo a rent relief program that was widely criticized because its original design needed buy-in from landlords, many of whom did not participate.

And it would also provide top-up help for businesses whose revenues crash because of local lockdowns to slow the spread of COVID-19.

Parties used subsidies when donations fell

Freeland referenced the bill in a tweet earlier Thursday as she voiced support for an extension of restrictions in Canada's largest city for another week.

"I know these restrictions are difficult for many Toronto businesses. That is why we (are) working very hard to extend the wage subsidy, create a new rent subsidy, and provide extra lockdown support."

The Liberals reached an agreement with opposition parties on Wednesday to fast-track the legislation through the House of Commons and have it passed by Friday.

It will still need Senate approval before being enacted. The Senate agreed Thursday to have its finance committee launch a pre-study of the bill, which is expected to occur next week while the rest of Parliament is on a break.

Earlier Thursday, Bloc Quebecois Leader Yves-Francois Blanchet told reporters he wants to make sure the bill includes a provision to prohibit political parties from benefiting from the wage subsidy.

The Liberals, Conservatives, New Democrats and Greens all used the program earlier this year when their donations dried up from the pandemic.

"They should never, even if they would have been in difficulty, have touched that money," Blanchet said.

Freeland warns of rolling aid back too quickly 

The bill comes on top of billions already rolled out to sustain individuals and businesses across the country during the pandemic.

The government's last look at the books in July estimated a deficit of $343.2 billion this fiscal year, but that was before added promises laid out in September's throne speech.

Freeland has warned against rolling back aid too soon because it would cost the country more in the end.

Statistics tracked by The Canadian Press show there have been about 1.8 million claims for employment insurance since the system came back online at the end of September (after having been temporarily replaced by the Canada Emergency Response Benefit), and about $1.15 billion paid in benefits.

About one million more people have applied for the new Canada Recovery Benefit, which is paid to those who don't qualify for EI.

The parliamentary budget officer will report Friday on how much spending he believes the federal treasury can handle before deficits spiral out of control.

The New Democrats put a proposal to the House of Commons on Thursday to cover the aid bill via a wealth tax on those worth more than $20 million, which the PBO estimated would rake in $5.6 billion, and tax what the party called excess profits for large corporations.

NDP Leader Jagmeet Singh said excess profits would be anything well above the normal trend lines for business earnings, with an assessment of how much of that was due to COVID-19.

"Instead of putting the burden on people, we should ask those who have done really well in this time to pay their fair share," he said.

Add some “good” to your morning and evening.

A variety of newsletters you'll love, delivered straight to you.

Sign up now


To encourage thoughtful and respectful conversations, first and last names will appear with each submission to CBC/Radio-Canada's online communities (except in children and youth-oriented communities). Pseudonyms will no longer be permitted.

By submitting a comment, you accept that CBC has the right to reproduce and publish that comment in whole or in part, in any manner CBC chooses. Please note that CBC does not endorse the opinions expressed in comments. Comments on this story are moderated according to our Submission Guidelines. Comments are welcome while open. We reserve the right to close comments at any time.

Become a CBC Member

Join the conversation  Create account

Already have an account?