Federal Court orders government, RCMP to hand over Quebec gun registry data

A Federal Court judge has ordered that Public Safety Minister Steven Blaney and the commissioner of the RCMP immediately hand over an external hard drive containing a copy of all Quebec gun registry data.
A Federal Court judge has given the federal government until Tuesday morning to turn over a hard drive containing gun registry data for Quebec, until all legal proceedings related to the data are exhausted. (Sean Kilpatrick/Canadian Press)

 A Federal Court judge has ordered that Public Safety Minister Steven Blaney and the RCMP commissioner immediately hand over an external hard drive containing a copy of all Quebec gun registry data.

Judge Luc Martineau gave the government until 10 a.m. Tuesday morning to deliver the hard drive to the court _ effectively issuing a vote of non-confidence in government assurances that all the remaining long-gun registry records would be preserved while court challenges continue.

It's the first decisive legal skirmish in a battle that could last for some time between information commissioner Suzanne Legault and the Harper government over the long-defunct long-gun registry.

Legault will be launching a constitutional challenge Tuesday against retroactive gun registry provisions buried in the Harper government's latest omnibus budget bill.

Martineau's order came after a day-long hearing in which Justice department lawyers argued it was unnecessary to produce an actual physical copy of the records because the public safety minister had issued "four separate undertakings" to preserve the data.

Lawyer Richard Dearden, representing Legault, presented affidavits, letters and email evidence showing that previous assurances from the Conservative government in 2012 were ignored as it pushed for the speedy destruction of all gun registry records outside the province of Quebec.

"I don't like using the words, 'Can't be trusted,' but as you heard me say in the court, I don't take comfort in an assurance not to destroy records when there's destruction plans ongoing at the same time — and in fact destruction did occur," Dearden said outside the hearing room.

'The will of Parliament has been clear on multiple occasions; all copies of the registry are to be destroyed.  We will continue to stand up for this position in court,' - Spokesman for Public Safety Minister Steven Blaney

It was the destruction of disputed records in 2012 that led Legault to issue a report this spring accusing the Mounties of breaking the Access to Information Act. The Ontario Provincial Police are now investigating the allegation.

The Harper government responded by retroactively rewriting the law, granting amnesty to anyone involved in the document destruction, backdating the changes to 2011 and then inserting the provisions in this spring's 167-page budget bill.

Monday's court setback didn't change the government line.

"The will of Parliament has been clear on multiple occasions; all copies of the registry are to be destroyed," Blaney's spokesman Jeremy Laurin said in an email. "We will continue to stand up for this position in court."

Legault has called the retroactive move in the face of an alleged crime a "perilous precedent'' that could be used to retroactively absolve and cover up electoral fraud, expense scandals or other serious crimes.

Martineau sparked dismayed and alarmed glances Monday among three government lawyers when he mused aloud in court about retroactively absolving Nazis of war crimes and backdating the law to 1940.

The Conservative budget bill, C-59, was poised to clear its final Senate vote on Monday evening, adding urgency to the emergency Federal Court hearing to seal the remaining records.

Government lawyer Gregory Tzemenakis dodged a direct question from Martineau over whether the government would respect an order to preserve the data once Bill C-59, which provides immunity from prosecution, came into force.

Tzemenakis asserted that "absent a constitutional challenge," the bill's new provisions will be the law.

In response to a question from Martineau, Tzemenakis said there's no transitional measure in the new bill to preserve the previously existing rights of Bill Clennett, the original requester of the gun registry data.

"Parliament can divest individuals of rights, as long as it doesn't infringe the charter," said the government lawyer.

Clennett, most famous for being throttled by former prime minister Jean Chrétien during a 1996 demonstration that coined the term "Shawinigan handshake," issued a long manifesto on the need for governments to obey the law before Monday's hearing.

He was sporting a grin as he departed the court at day's end.

"It's a good first step, for sure," Clennett said.


To encourage thoughtful and respectful conversations, first and last names will appear with each submission to CBC/Radio-Canada's online communities (except in children and youth-oriented communities). Pseudonyms will no longer be permitted.

By submitting a comment, you accept that CBC has the right to reproduce and publish that comment in whole or in part, in any manner CBC chooses. Please note that CBC does not endorse the opinions expressed in comments. Comments on this story are moderated according to our Submission Guidelines. Comments are welcome while open. We reserve the right to close comments at any time.