Express entry could sideswipe high-skilled foreign workers

Some employers fear Americans working in Canada through the North American Free Trade Agreement, foreign nationals who have transferred to a Canadian branch and international youth working in Canada could be sideswiped by rules under the new express entry system that starts Jan. 1.
Immigration Minister Chris Alexander has said that skilled immigrants who receive a permanent job offer from a Canadian employer or who have been nominated for immigration by a province or territory will be "picked first" under a new express entry system. (Sean Kilpatrick/Canadian Press)

Some employers fear Americans working in Canada through the North American Free Trade Agreement, foreign nationals who have transferred to a Canadian branch and international youth working in Canada could be sideswiped by rules under the new express entry system that starts Jan. 1.

New regulations suggest employers who want to offer permanent jobs to high-skilled temporary foreign workers who are already working here will not only have to ask them to apply for permanent residency under express entry, they will also have to prove they made every effort to hire a Canadian first.

Many employers are currently allowed to hire foreign nationals on a temporary basis through various international mobility programs without needing a labour market impact assessment or LMIA, a document needed to hire a foreign worker over a Canadian one.

Sarah Anson-Cartwright, the director of skills policy at the Canadian Chamber of Commerce — one of nine groups the government has been consulting on express entry since 2013 — said she only learned of the new rules during a meeting with immigration officials at the end of November.

"We weren't aware that a labour market impact assessment was going to be required for virtually every candidate to be eligible to apply for permanent residency, but that's the new scenario," she said.

Under the new express entry points system revealed earlier this month, high-skilled immigrants who receive a permanent job offer backed by a positive LMIA will be among the first to receive an offer to apply for permanent residency.

Mark Holthe, a partner at the immigration law firm of Holthe Tilleman, said the new regulations also took him by surprise.

Holthe, who is based in Calgary where businesses have felt the impact of the overhaul to the Temporary Foreign Worker Program, said the new rules will come as an added burden for employers trying to hire and retain high-skilled workers.

"When we're competing for 'the best and the brightest,' as the government says, I'm just not so sure how attractive that kind of a model will be," he said.

Holthe said "the uncertainty" surrounding express entry has employers feeling anxious.

"Right now the employers are still trying to figure out what they are supposed to do."

List of 50 occupations 'unnecessary'

The federal government has also decided that starting Jan. 1, at the of the launch of express entry, it will abandon a list of 50 eligible occupations it was using to recruit high-skilled immigrants. Instead, the government will allow employers to decide what jobs need filling.

As CBC News reported, last May the government more than doubled the number of professions skilled immigrants could apply for under the federal skilled worker program​ in preparation for the launch of express entry.

The list, which included doctors, registered nurses, engineers and accountants, surprised CBC News readers, who said they couldn't understand how employers were unable to find Canadians to fill jobs in any of those high-skilled occupations.

Now, seven months later, the government says the list of 50 occupations is no longer necessary.

A spokeswoman for the Department of Citizenship and Immigration said the list was put in place "to better align programs with labour market needs."

"The reforms to the economic immigration system and the introduction of express entry have rendered the occupation list approach unnecessary," Sonia Lesange told CBC News in an email.

This will allow the federal government "to be more nimble," Lesange said, "but also give employers and provinces the ability to play a greater role in the immigration system, making it faster and more flexible for all."

According to figures posted on the Citizenship and Immigration Canada website, the government has received 9,939 completed applications under the federal skilled worker program as of on Dec. 11.

Exactly 5,000 of those applications were received under the five following occupations:

  • Financial and investment analysts.
  • Information systems analysts and consultants.
  • Software engineers and designers.
  • Computer programmers and interactive media developers.
  • Registered nurses and registered psychiatric nurses.

The department has said it will process all applications received before Jan. 1 "on a parallel track" as those received on or after the launch of express entry.

Anson-Carwright from the Chamber of Commerce said it makes sense for employers not to be tied to a predetermined list.

"For them to go through those efforts to fill a position would suggest it's a position they really need filled and it is in demand for them in that circumstance."

Six months earlier, a spokeswoman for Immigration Minister Chris Alexander told CBC News the list comprised "occupations that were found to be in demand nationally or regionally, based on recent labour market data from Employment and Social Development Canada and input from provinces and territories on regional labour market needs."

Employment Minister Jason Kenney has conceded there are existing gaps in Canada's efforts to collect labour market information.

He announced in June the government will be spending $15 million a year to fund two new labour market information studies — a quarterly study on job vacancies and an annual survey on wage rates.


To encourage thoughtful and respectful conversations, first and last names will appear with each submission to CBC/Radio-Canada's online communities (except in children and youth-oriented communities). Pseudonyms will no longer be permitted.

By submitting a comment, you accept that CBC has the right to reproduce and publish that comment in whole or in part, in any manner CBC chooses. Please note that CBC does not endorse the opinions expressed in comments. Comments on this story are moderated according to our Submission Guidelines. Comments are welcome while open. We reserve the right to close comments at any time.

Become a CBC Member

Join the conversation  Create account

Already have an account?