Energy East pipeline to face Ontario scrutiny

Ontario's energy minister is asking the Ontario Energy Board to consult citizens of the province and prepare a report on the potential benefits and drawbacks of TransCanada Pipelines' proposed Energy East Pipeline.

The province outlines 6 principles that will guide all future assessments of pipeline projects

TransCanada CEO Russ Girling, right, and TransCanada president of energy and oil pipelines Alex Pourbaix announce the company is moving forward with the 1.1 million barrel-per-day Energy East Pipeline project at a news conference in Calgary on Aug. 1, 2013. Ontario announced it will conduct its own consultations separate from the National Energy Board hearings. (The Canadian Press/Jeff McIntosh)

The Ontario government appears to be taking a page out of Britsh Columbia's oilsands pipeline handbook and asking "what's in it for me?"

Provincial Energy Minister Bob Chiarelli announced today that he is asking the Ontario Energy Board to consult citizens of the province and prepare a report on the potential benefits and drawbacks of TransCanada Pipelines' proposed Energy East Pipeline. The regulator's report will be used to inform the Ontario government's testimony at the National Energy Board yet to be announced hearings into the Energy East project. 

"It is not the intention of the Ontario government to add additional oversight. Rather our intent is to ensure the voices and concerns of all Ontarians find expression during the coming federal regulatory process," Chiarelli explained at a news conference this morning at Ottawa City Hall.
Ontario Energy Minister Bob Chiarelli has asked the province's Energy Board to consult citizens on the Energy East pipeline proposal. (The Canadian Press/Matthew Sherwood)

The pipeline currently carries natural gas from Western Canada to Ontario, Quebec and parts of the United States. TCPL wants to turn it into an oil pipeline carrying diluted bitumen from Alberta's oilsands to the port of Saint John, N.B., for export. 

6 principles to guide assessment

In announcing his request to the provincial regulator, Chiarelli also explained that the Ontario government will be adopting six principles when assessing proposed pipeline projects:

  • Pipelines have to meet highest technical standards to protect the public and environment.
  • World-leading emergency response.
  • Fulfil duty to consult Aboriginal communities.
  • Consult local communities.
  • Demonstrable short- and long-term economic benefits for Ontario.
  • Companies must carry all economic and environmental responsibilities and prove that they are able to pay for that responsibility.

The Ontario principles bear a striking resemblance to B.C.'s five conditions that were announced in response to public concerns over Enbridge's proposed Northern Gateway pipeline that would carry oilsands bitumen from Edmonton to Kitimat, B.C., on the coast. 

For the Energy East Pipeline proposal specifically, Chiarelli wants the OEB to look in four areas, three of which relate directly to the six principles. 

The fourth area asks the regulator to look into the "impacts on natural gas consumers, in particular those in Eastern and Northern Ontario in terms of rates, reliability and access to supply." TCPL's Canadian Mainline pipeline - the one that will eventually be the backbone or the Energy East project - supplies up to 40 per cent of Ontario's natural gas demand in the winter months.

Environmentalists think the province has done the right thing by ordering the OEB to consult with the public.

"We're glad that the province is stepping up especially since the federal government has moved out of that area," said Gillian MacEachern, campaigns director for Environmental Defence, referring to the NEB's new, more restrictive rules on who can testify at its hearings. 

Ontario does not regulate interprovincial pipelines. That is the responsibility of the federal government.


To encourage thoughtful and respectful conversations, first and last names will appear with each submission to CBC/Radio-Canada's online communities (except in children and youth-oriented communities). Pseudonyms will no longer be permitted.

By submitting a comment, you accept that CBC has the right to reproduce and publish that comment in whole or in part, in any manner CBC chooses. Please note that CBC does not endorse the opinions expressed in comments. Comments on this story are moderated according to our Submission Guidelines. Comments are welcome while open. We reserve the right to close comments at any time.

Become a CBC Member

Join the conversation  Create account

Already have an account?