More than 20 child killers sent to healing lodges since 2011, figures show

More than 20 child murderers have been transferred to Indigenous healing lodges since 2011, according to numbers from the Minister of Public Safety's office.

Offenders were transferred under both Conservative and Liberal governments

Terri-Lynne McClintic, convicted in the death of 8-year-old Victoria Stafford, is escorted into court in Kitchener, Ont., on Wednesday, September 12, 2012. (Geoff Robins/Canadian Press)

More than 20 child murderers have been transferred to Indigenous healing lodges since 2011, according to numbers from Public Safety Canada.

At least 14 of those offenders were held in healing lodges while the previous Conservative government was in power.

The federal government released those numbers in response to a request from CBC News Network's Power & Politics in the wake of a wave of outrage over child killer Terri-Lynne McClintic's transfer to an Indigenous healing lodge in southern Saskatchewan last December.

She was transferred back to a traditional prison in Edmonton last week.

McClintic is serving a life sentence for the brutal rape and murder of Tori Stafford, 8, of Woodstock, Ont.

News of McClintic's transfer to a healing lodge became public in September and quickly became a point of heated political debate in the House of Commons. The Conservatives tabled a motion, later voted down, that demanded the Liberal government condemn the transfer and overturn it. Prime Minister Justin Trudeau, in response, accused the Official Opposition of being "ambulance chasers."

Trudeau on "ambulance chasing politicians"

4 years ago
Duration 1:08
Prime Minister Justin Trudeau accused the Conservatives of being "ambulance chasing politicians" for the manner in which the party is using the case of Tori Stafford's killer being transferred to a healing lodge during question period in the House of Commons.

Responding to a request from CBC News, a spokesperson for the Minister of Public Safety Ralph Goodale said child killers were sent to healing lodges under the Conservative government of Stephen Harper as well.

McClintic's case was not unique

As of September 23, 2018, there were 11 people convicted of first or second degree murder of a minor serving time in healing lodges, said Goodale's press secretary Scott Bardsley. Between the fiscal years of 2011-2012 and 2018-19, 22 convicted child-killers have been held for some period of time in healing lodges.

There are currently 11 offenders convicted of first or second degree murder of minors held in healing lodges, according to the Office of the Minister of Public Safety. (CBC )

Between the fiscal years 2011-12 and 2014-15 — when Conservatives Vic Toews and Steven Blaney were ministers of public safety — 10 new offenders were sent to healing lodges.

Since the Liberals came to power in 2015, at least four offenders — including McClintic — were sent to healing lodges. Three child-killers were sent to healing lodges in 2015-16; it's not known whether those transfers took place under the Harper or Trudeau governments.

CBC News asked if the Conservative Party disputed the numbers; Brock Harrison, a spokesperson for Conservative Leader Andrew Scheer, did not address the question directly.

"Individual correctional transfers often only become known if a family member or someone connected to the case makes it public," said Harrison in a statement.

Between the fiscal years 2011-12 and 2014-15 — when Conservatives Vic Toews and Steven Blaney were ministers of public safety — 10 new offenders were sent to healing lodges. (CBC/Office of the Minister of Public Safety)

"Our Conservative government also acted swiftly whenever these types of bad decisions in the criminal justice system became known."

Harrison said he couldn't cite instances of Conservative ministers reversing the transfer of a child-killer to a healing lodge — but he did point to the former Harper government acting to prevent serial child killer Clifford Olson from collecting social security benefits, and to end conjugal visits for serial murderer Paul Bernardo.

Harrison also took issue with the time it took for McClintic to be transferred back to a conventional prison. 

"They had the power and the duty to act, and they failed to do so for weeks," he said.

Liberals tighten transfer policies

In an interview last week with Power & Politics host Vassy Kapelos, Karen McCrimmon, parliamentary secretary to Goodale, criticized the Conservatives for not addressing the issue of healing lodge transfers during their time in power.

"They had 10 years to fix it and they didn't," she said.

Karen McCrimmon: 'There were child murderers transferred to healing lodges under the Conservative government'

4 years ago
Duration 0:33
'They had 10 years to fix it and they didn't,' says the parliamentary secretary to the Public Safety Minister.

Goodale has said he has no legal power to intervene in individual cases, and that decisions about correctional and security classifications are made by public servants based on what is considered best for the offender's rehabilitation and for public safety.

Last week, Goodale announced stricter transfer policies for Indigenous healing lodges for women. Under the new policy, transfers will have to be authorized by Correctional Service Canada's deputy commissioner for women, who will be required to ensure that Indigenous communities are engaged in transfer recommendations.

McClintic is not eligible for parole until 2031.

According to Statistics Canada, 540 children under the age of 18 were murdered between 2007 and 2017. Of those victims, 276 were under the age of 12 and 264 were between the ages of 12 and 18.

  Child victims of murder by age and year. Source: Statistics Canada 
Victims 0-1125293430323223262916
Victims 12-1731304232261619232223
Total per year56597662584842495139


To encourage thoughtful and respectful conversations, first and last names will appear with each submission to CBC/Radio-Canada's online communities (except in children and youth-oriented communities). Pseudonyms will no longer be permitted.

By submitting a comment, you accept that CBC has the right to reproduce and publish that comment in whole or in part, in any manner CBC chooses. Please note that CBC does not endorse the opinions expressed in comments. Comments on this story are moderated according to our Submission Guidelines. Comments are welcome while open. We reserve the right to close comments at any time.

Become a CBC Member

Join the conversation  Create account

Already have an account?