Canada Without Poverty charity challenges Harper govt. audits at UN in Geneva

A small anti-poverty group, under audit for three years for its political activities, is arguing before the UN Human Rights Committee in Geneva this week that Canada Revenue Agency is violating Canada's commitment to uphold human rights. Canada Without Poverty wants the audits stopped.

Ottawa anti-poverty charity in Geneva this week arguing before UN that political-activity audits are an abuse

The Canada Revenue Agency is being called out in Geneva this week for its political-activity audits of charities. (Sean Kilpatrick/Canadian Press)

The head of a small Ottawa-based charity is in Geneva this week to complain to a United Nations committee about the Canada Revenue Agency's program of political-activity audits.

Harriett McLachlan, president of Canada Without Poverty, is pleading her case before the UN Human Rights Committee, arguing that a special audit program launched by the tax agency in 2012 violates Canada's international commitments on human rights.

The UN Human Rights Committee will hear complaints this week from a small Ottawa charity that the Harper government is violating its rights.
McLachlan says a rule limiting to 10 per cent the resources a charity can devote to political activities effectively silences groups like hers that want to hold the Canadian government accountable.

"If we want to write a petition, or be part of some kind of gathering, a protest, there's a fear there that we are stepping over the bounds," she said in an interview with CBC News.

"There's a potential of a gag being put over my mouth."

Canada under scrutiny

Canada Without Poverty is among 60 charities being hit with political-activity investigations under a $13.4-million special program by the Canada Revenue Agency. The group has been under continuous audit for three years.

The UN Human Rights Committee each year reviews the human-rights records of a handful of the 168 countries that have signed the International Covenant on Civil and Political rights. Canada's turn comes up this week.

A panel of 18 independent experts will listen to Canadian groups, such as Kairos and Amnesty International Canada, raising issues of human-rights abuses in Canada, including murdered and missing indigenous women, and the residential school abuse of indigenous children.

Poverty should not exist in a wealthy country like Canada.– Harriett McLachlan, president of Canada Without Poverty

Such groups will have their say Monday and Tuesday, and Canadian officials will appear before the panel the same week to answer questions and present the government's views. The panel will then announce its findings on July 23.

Canada Without Poverty's revenues last year were a modest $318,000, and it reported that just eight per cent of resources went to political activities. The group is primarily an advocacy organization, rather than one engaging in more traditional anti-poverty activities such as soup kitchens and food banks.

McLachlan, a Montreal social worker with 35 years' personal experience of poverty, says the group does not press for new legislation, insisting only that Canada live up to its international commitments.

"There should be space for people to hold the government accountable on these issues, human-rights issues," she said. "Poverty should not exist in a wealthy country like Canada."

The Canadian Union of Public Employees provided special funding for McLachlan and another member of the group to travel to Geneva for the hearings.

Net has broadened

The Canada Revenue Agency's political-activity audits initially targeted environmental charities in 2012-13 that were vocal critics of the government's energy and pipelines policies. The net has since broadened to include poverty, international aid and human-rights groups.

Canada Without Poverty, with just $318,000 in revenues, has been under a continuous political-activity audit for three years.
Critics say the audits have created an "advocacy chill," as some charities under scrutiny self-censor to avoid jeopardizing their charitable status, which can be revoked if the rules are broken. There have also been allegations that the government has selectively targeted opponents to its policies, and that the definition of political activity is unclear and malleable.

Revenue Minister Kerry-Lynne Findlay says the Canada Revenue Agency operates at arm's length from government, with no political direction, and makes its own decisions about whom to audit. The agency also says its definitions of political activity are clear and consistent.

Follow @DeanBeeby on Twitter


To encourage thoughtful and respectful conversations, first and last names will appear with each submission to CBC/Radio-Canada's online communities (except in children and youth-oriented communities). Pseudonyms will no longer be permitted.

By submitting a comment, you accept that CBC has the right to reproduce and publish that comment in whole or in part, in any manner CBC chooses. Please note that CBC does not endorse the opinions expressed in comments. Comments on this story are moderated according to our Submission Guidelines. Comments are welcome while open. We reserve the right to close comments at any time.

Become a CBC Member

Join the conversation  Create account

Already have an account?