NDP satellite office controversy could claw back severance for any defeated MPs

If some New Democrat incumbents go down to defeat Monday, they stand to lose more than their seats. They could also lose some or all of the generous severance payments to which defeated MPs are normally entitled.

5 dozen New Democrats ordered to repay a total of $2.75 million for improper use of parliamentary budgets

Mulcair says NDP would scrap Board of Internal Economy

7 years ago
Duration 1:51
NDP leader asked whether his party would foot the bill to repay House of Commons for satellite offices.

If some New Democrat incumbents go down to defeat Monday, they stand to lose more than their seats.

They could also lose some or all of the generous severance payments to which defeated MPs are normally entitled.

That's because more than five dozen New Democrats have been ordered to repay the House of Commons a total of $2.75 million for improperly using their parliamentary office budgets to pay the salaries of staff in satellite party offices in Montreal, Quebec City and Toronto.

On average, the incumbents owe about $30,000 each but four of them are on the hook for more than $100,000.

The New Democrats have so far refused to pay, claiming they've done nothing wrong and are the victims of a partisan smear by Conservative and Liberal members of the board of internal economy, the secretive, multi-party body that polices Commons spending.

Nevertheless, as of July 1, Commons administrators were under instructions to begin collecting the money by refusing to reimburse the expense claims of the 68 MPs involved in the satellite office scheme.

The amount recovered thus far would be trivial, since Parliament was not sitting in July and no expenses could be claimed in any event after the election was called on Aug. 2.

However, if any of those MPs are defeated on Monday, they could find their final pay-outs from the Commons — severance and reimbursement of pension contributions — docked for the full amount of what they still owe.

Amounts owing exceed severance

Every defeated MP receives a lump-sum severance payment of half a year's salary — $83,700.

And those who've been MPs for fewer than six years also receive lump sum reimbursement of their pension contributions, which would amount to roughly another half year's salary.

Four NDP incumbents could wind up losing most or all their final payments, should they be defeated.

NDP leader Tom Mulcair's office is among those fingered for improper spending of parliamentary budgets, in a controversy over satellite offices set up by New Democrats that other parties say were doing partisan, not parliamentary, work. (Ryan Remiorz/Canadian Press)

Dan Harris, who faces a stiff challenge from Liberal contender and former Toronto police chief Bill Blair in Scarborough-Southwest, owes $141,467 for his share in the satellite office scheme.

Quebec incumbents Isabelle Morin, Alexandre Boulerice and Jean Rousseau owe $169,117, $122,122 and $142,548 respectively.

The party leader's office also owes $408,573 (racked up under both current leader Tom Mulcair and former interim leader Nycole Turmel) and the party House leader's office owes $189,714.

The NDP launched a court challenge a year ago after the board ordered reimbursement of the $2.7 million, as well as another $1.2 million for improper use of parliamentary mailing privileges. Most of the latter was supposedly owed to Canada Post, which has made no known move to collect.

The court case has languished ever since, with no attempt by the NDP or the board of internal economy to move it along. There was a brief attempt to negotiate a settlement which went nowhere.

The board will be reconstituted after the election and the new membership could decide to let the matter drop. However, both the Liberals and Conservatives have argued it's a matter of principle to ensure that taxpayer-funded resources are used to help MPs carry out their parliamentary duties, not to advance their political parties.


To encourage thoughtful and respectful conversations, first and last names will appear with each submission to CBC/Radio-Canada's online communities (except in children and youth-oriented communities). Pseudonyms will no longer be permitted.

By submitting a comment, you accept that CBC has the right to reproduce and publish that comment in whole or in part, in any manner CBC chooses. Please note that CBC does not endorse the opinions expressed in comments. Comments on this story are moderated according to our Submission Guidelines. Comments are welcome while open. We reserve the right to close comments at any time.

Become a CBC Member

Join the conversation  Create account

Already have an account?