Immigration critics press Liberals on costs, plan for asylum seekers

After hurling accusations of creating hysteria, crippling provinces and taking an ad-hoc approach to a crisis, MPs on the immigration committee agree to hold special hearings on the influx of people illegally crossing the border to claim asylum in Canada.

Liberal MP accuses Conservative opposition of creating 'hysteria' and dividing Canadians

Conservative MP Michelle Rempel arrives for an emergency meeting of the Citizenship and Immigration Committee on Parliament Hill on Monday. (Justin Tang/Canadian Press)

After hurling accusations of creating hysteria, crippling provinces and taking an ad-hoc approach to a crisis, MPs on the immigration committee agreed on Monday to hold special hearings on the influx of people illegally crossing the border to claim asylum in Canada.

Conservative immigration critic Michelle Rempel presented the motion for the summer sessions, insisting the Liberal government has failed to produce a comprehensive, costed plan. She accused the government of normalizing the trend of irregular border-crossers and wants to hold key ministers to account.

Immigration MPs to hold special emergency meetings

4 years ago
Duration 8:32
Immigration critics press Liberals on costs, plan for asylum seekers.

Calling it a "border crisis," Rempel said the issue has taken on new urgency, because many refugee claimants currently housed in university dorms will face eviction in early August. Cities such as Toronto and Ottawa are buckling under the strain of stretched resources, overcrowded shelters and increased demand on food banks, she said.

Rempel accused the Liberal government of accepting the ongoing situation without a long-term, permanent plan to ensure adequate supports and funds are in place to deal with the steady influx. The Canadian public must have the full information to assess what has become a new immigration policy, she said.

Committee chair and Liberal MP Robert Oliphant prepares for an emergency meeting of the Citizenship and Immigration Committee on Parliament Hill in Ottawa on Monday, July 16, 2018. (Justin Tang/Canadian Press)

"I think it is completely unacceptable for us to normalize the government being able to expend hundreds of millions of dollars in a piecemeal fashion without having that broader conversation," Rempel said. "This is a big departure from any immigration policy this government ran on."

The committee will hold at least two sessions, and will hear from about 10 witnesses. Immigration Minister Ahmed Hussen, Public Safety Minister Ralph Goodale and Social Development Minister Jean-Yves Duclos will be invited to testify.

Tense talks with Ontario

Today's meeting comes after tense discussions between Hussen and provincial immigration ministers Friday, which ended with the minister openly criticizing the Ontario government for what he called a dangerous and unCanadian approach to the issue of asylum seekers.

"They've chosen to use false language with respect to so-called queue jumping, when we have told them over and over again there is no such thing," Hussen told reporters in Winnipeg at the closing press conference.

"Asylum seekers are processed in a separate queue at the IRB and all the other regular immigration programs are processed by IRCC, and conflating the two knowingly is irresponsible, it's divisive, it's fearmongering and it's not Canadian, and it's very dangerous."

Today, the government announced that the $11 million earmarked for Ontario from a $50-million fund to assist the provinces and municipalities grappling with the bulk of newcomers will go directly to the City of Toronto.

"Direct funding was required after the province of Ontario chose to withdraw from its jurisdictional responsibility around housing," said a news release from the immigration department.

Numbers down in June

New numbers released Friday show the volume of people intercepted by the RCMP decreased significantly in June, with 1,263 entering the country outside official border points compared to 1,869 in May.

Kwan: How can anyone think the U.S. is a safe country

4 years ago
Duration 1:44
The NDP's Jenny Kwan blames the increasing number of asylum seekers coming to Canada on the politics of the Trump administration.

NDP immigration critic Jenny Kwan said the numbers are small in the overall context of the global migration crisis. She rejected the suggestion that there is a crisis underway, but said a comprehensive plan with additional resources is needed.

"This situation can be managed and should be managed effectively," she said.

Kwan repeated her call for the government to suspend the Safe Third Country Agreement, insisting that much of the current turmoil is created by U.S. President Donald Trump's immigration policies and that the U.S. can no longer be considered safe for asylum seekers.

A group of asylum seekers arrive at a temporary housing facility at the border crossing, May 9, in St. Bernard-de-Lacolle, Que. Almost 96 per cent of asylum seekers who have crossed illegally into Canada so far in 2018 have done so through the Quebec border. (Ryan Remiorz/Canadian Press)

Immigration committee chair Rob Oliphant said the issue is not a crisis.

"This is a problem and it's very appropriate for members of Parliament to get a briefing from ministers and other people to make sure everything is in order," he said.

Liberal MP Gary Anandasangaree insisted the government has a handle on the problem, and has a comprehensive plan that has evolved to changing events. He accused the opposition of torquing the situation.

"A lot of what we're hearing is based on a great deal of hysteria and misinformation and I think really trying to divide Canadians on this issue," he said.

Anandasangaree: We are othering those coming here

4 years ago
Duration 0:50
Liberal MP Gary Anandasangaree takes issue with language that he says encourages Canadians to think of asylum seekers in a negative light.

But Conservative MP Dave Tilson said mayors and municipalities are worried about the impact of asylum seekers. Even in his town of Orangeville, Ont., with a population of 30,000, the mayor is worried about asylum seekers being "shipped" to the community.

"The issue is clearly out of control," he said.

Hussen's spokesperson Mathieu Genest said the minister respects the independence of the committee and has always appeared when asked. The government is moving forward with a "clear plan" to address asylum seekers, he said.

"Last month saw fewest number of asylum seekers crossing the border irregularly in the past year. While these numbers are promising, Canadians expect all levels of government to work together to live up to our international and humanitarian obligations," he wrote in an email. "We continue to engage directly with the municipalities in order to ensure the orderly management of asylum seekers."

Trudeau's Liberals at odds with Ontario PCs over asylum seekers | Sunday Scrum

4 years ago
Duration 10:24
A bitter war of words is playing out between Ottawa and Doug Ford's new Ontario PC government over asylum seekers


To encourage thoughtful and respectful conversations, first and last names will appear with each submission to CBC/Radio-Canada's online communities (except in children and youth-oriented communities). Pseudonyms will no longer be permitted.

By submitting a comment, you accept that CBC has the right to reproduce and publish that comment in whole or in part, in any manner CBC chooses. Please note that CBC does not endorse the opinions expressed in comments. Comments on this story are moderated according to our Submission Guidelines. Comments are welcome while open. We reserve the right to close comments at any time.

Become a CBC Member

Join the conversation  Create account

Already have an account?