Are third-party ads just the start of big money politics in Canada?

Experts weigh in on how the arrival of PAC money in Canada will affect the upcoming federal elections.

Experts weigh in on the impact of PAC-type groups on the federal election

Former chief electoral officer Jean-Pierre Kingsley, warns that Canada is headed down the road well trodden in the U.S., where political action committees, or PACs, raise and spend staggering amounts of money to influence elections, without the same restrictions that apply to political parties. (Sean Kilpatrick/Canadian Press)

Experts are weighing in on how the arrival of big money in Canadian politics may affect the upcoming federal election.

Former chief electoral officer Jean-Pierre Kingsley says Canada is headed down the road well trodden in the United States, where political action committees, or PACs, raise and spend staggering amounts of money to influence elections, without the same restrictions that apply to political parties.

In Canada, such groups have been known as third parties and their activities are severely restricted during campaigns.

However, with the introduction of fixed dates for elections, third parties have been popping up like mushrooms months ahead of the actual election call, spending untold amounts on ads during a period when their activities are completely unregulated.

One of the newest groups on the block is HarperPAC — a name Kingsley described as "revealing" as its source of inspiration the big-money PAC phenomenon south of the border.


It is insulting to Canadian intelligence to say this is not American-inspired.- Jean-PierreKingsley, former chief electoral officer

"We are in, effectively, a free-for-all zone," Kingsley said in an interview. "It took us 40 years of scandal, sweat to come to a regime where we had the best in the world for control of money in politics ... now we are back in the jungle."

Stephen Taylor, a longtime Conservative and former director of the National Citizens Coalition who's now a HarperPAC adviser and spokesman, denied that the group is taking a page from the American political playbook.

The acronym simply offers a useful recognition factor, Taylor said. "It is really branding to let someone know, within the half second it takes to hear the word, what we are up to." he said. 

Kingsley, for one, isn't buying it.

"It is insulting to Canadian intelligence to say this is not American-inspired."

'Hardly a surprise'

A former adviser to Prime Minister Stephen Harper says it is "hardly a surprise" to see to see political organizers on the right side of the political spectrum pushing back against union-financed third-party groups on the left.

Tom Flanagan, a retired University of Calgary political science professor, said he's hopeful that HarperPAC will help to offset the pre-writ advertising efforts of its left-leaning counterparts.

"I think it is a matter of self-preservation for the Conservatives to be able to fight back," Flanagan said in a phone interview Wednesday. "If everybody starts doing it, we may well get some regulatory legislation, but there is none now."

Flanagan said he would favour disclosure legislation that would require all third-party groups to show who is donating money. But regulating pre-writ advertising is complex, he warned.

Taxpayers are already paying for free Conservative advertising in the form of federal cabinet ministers travelling across the country to roll out policy announcements ahead of the fall election, he said.

"Government has all kinds of levers to pull, which I don't think you can regulate away," he said. "If you try and regulate other forms of political expression, you leave the government holding more cards."

No limit, no disclosure

There is no limit on how much third-party groups can raise and spend prior to an election being called. Nor are they required to disclose their donors or how much they have raised.

That means pre-writ financial contributions can come from anyone, anywhere, said Kingsley, including corporations and unions, which are banned from contributing to political parties, and people who live outside of Canada.

The federal New Democrats used HarperPAC as an excuse to launch a fundraising campaign of its own Wednesday, calling on supporters to pony up $5 donations before the end of June in order to gird the party for battle.

"This week, we learned that Stephen Harper's friends have set up a U.S.-style group called the HarperPAC to spend an obscene amount of money on Harper's re-election," the fundraising email states.

"It's the kind of money we've never seen before in Canadian politics, and it's up to us to fight back right now."

'Of course it matters'

Kingsley said the situation was "foreseeable" as a consequence of a fixed election date, adding that he fears the situation will worsen if the issue is not addressed in the next Parliament.

"Money is the toughest thing to crack in politics," he said. "What people are doing right now is evaluating the success of what they are doing. If it is successful, they will want to do more."

Whether or not it is successful remains an open question.

Barry Cooper, a political science professor at the University of Calgary, said he doesn't believe third-party pre-writ campaigns will be "very effective on either side" of the political spectrum.

"I am not saying it is a waste of money," Cooper said. "I think they pretty much have to do this, but to think that it is going to be decisive, you're just fooling yourself."

Again, Kingsley was skeptical.

"Of course it matters," he said. "You don't spend millions of dollars unless it matters."


To encourage thoughtful and respectful conversations, first and last names will appear with each submission to CBC/Radio-Canada's online communities (except in children and youth-oriented communities). Pseudonyms will no longer be permitted.

By submitting a comment, you accept that CBC has the right to reproduce and publish that comment in whole or in part, in any manner CBC chooses. Please note that CBC does not endorse the opinions expressed in comments. Comments on this story are moderated according to our Submission Guidelines. Comments are welcome while open. We reserve the right to close comments at any time.

Become a CBC Member

Join the conversation  Create account

Already have an account?