Politics

Annamie Paul says this is the moment for the Greens and now begins task of convincing voters

Newly minted Green Party Leader Annamie Paul says the party she now helms is the one Canadians need to guide them through "the challenges of this time," an ambitious pitch one observer says she will have to champion in a field of stiff political competition.

Greens must broaden appeal to other voters — without losing their own

New Green Party Leader Annamie Paul celebrates in Ottawa after securing the party's top job on Saturday. During her victory speech, Paul said the Greens were 'the party for this moment.' (Adrian Wyld/The Canadian Press)

Newly minted Green Party Leader Annamie Paul says the party she now helms is the one Canadians need to guide them through "the challenges of this time," an ambitious pitch one observer says she will have to champion in a field of stiff political competition.

"I think the challenge for the party today remains: what does it stand for and how does it compete with a crowded group of parties on the centre left … who all have strong environmental platforms?" said David Coletto, CEO of Abacus Data. "They really are competing against the same voters in that space."

According to a national survey recently conducted by the polling firm, 66 per cent of respondents said they would not vote for the party, while 34 per cent said they would either vote for the party or would be open to the idea.

The survey was conducted online from Sept. 23 to 28 with a representative sample of 2,400 Canadian adults and weighted to match Canada's population by age, gender, education, region and official language.

Paul, 47, won the leadership of the federal Greens on Saturday and is now tasked with charting a new path — and capturing new voters — for a party that was led by Elizabeth May for nearly 14 years. 

The Toronto lawyer ran on a moderate platform that didn't diverge from the party's vision during the last federal election, though she is pushing the Greens to embrace a policy that would slap a tariff on imports from countries with lax carbon emissions standards.

But Paul said that right now, her party's appeal extends far beyond its environmentally conscious reputation.

"The policies that have mattered the most and the policies that have been spoken about the most are not our environmental or climate policies at the moment," Paul told CBC News on Sunday. 

"It has been our social policies — our role in championing and leading the way on guaranteed livable income or universal pharmacare or reform to our long-term care system. People in Canada are starting to see all of the dimensions of the Green Party."

WATCH | Newly elected Green leader says social policies will grow party:

The federal Green Party's new leader, Annamie Paul, says policies like universal basic income and pharmacare will help the party expand in the next election. Paul was chosen as the party's leader Saturday night. 5:56

Attracting new supporters without alienating existing ones

In broadening the party's appeal, Paul will also need to avoid alienating more radical Green supporters.

Paul was not swiftly handed a victory on Saturday in large part because of those supporters. She won the leadership contest on the eighth ballot, edging out self-described "eco-socialist" Dimitri Lascaris by just over 2,000 votes. 

Eco-socialism, an ideology that combines elements of ecology and socialism, underpinned Lascaris's platform and that of another candidate in the race, Meryam Haddad. 

"I think the proof is going to be in the pudding," Lascaris said Saturday when asked if he thought Paul would be a voice for that wing of the party. "I think Annamie's certainly expressed an intention this evening to bring all the members of the party together."

Former Green Party leader Elizabeth May, left, speaks with Paul during a fireside chat in Toronto in 2019. Paul succeeds May, who stepped down last fall after leading the party since 2006. (Cole Burston /The Canadian Press)

Paul has not directly addressed how she plans to appeal to those supporters, instead choosing to focus on the party's progressive policies and shared values. 

Coletto said it may be "limiting" for the Greens to throw their support behind a socialist or eco-socialist agenda.

"Where I think the Green Party has had success provincially and federally is finding a way to build a coalition of voters who are looking for something different, who maybe want to do politics differently —  and that might be both on the left and the centre left and the right — and come together to support a green agenda," he said.

Byelection a 'tough first act'

For her part, Paul is confident that the party can secure a "great deal" of seats in the next federal election —a task that starts with locking down her own.

The new leader has been nominated to run in the Oct. 26 byelection in Toronto Centre, the riding previously held by former finance minister Bill Morneau. 

During her victory speech, Paul said she was tired of candidates "being parachuted" into the Liberal stronghold.

"I was born in Toronto Centre. My mother taught in the schools in Toronto Centre. My grandmother worked as a front-line service worker in the hospitals of Toronto Centre and broke her back doing it in the process," she said. "I will not abandon the residents of Toronto Centre to a Liberal Party that has neglected that constituency, that riding for the last 27 years."

Coletto said the upcoming vote will be a real test to see where the Greens stand when pitted against other parties. 

"It is a chance for the new leader of the Greens to go out, road test her message, introduce herself to voters. But because she is now the candidate in that riding, there may be even higher expectations on how she performs," he said. "So it's a tough first act."

With files from CBC's David Thurton

Comments

To encourage thoughtful and respectful conversations, first and last names will appear with each submission to CBC/Radio-Canada's online communities (except in children and youth-oriented communities). Pseudonyms will no longer be permitted.

By submitting a comment, you accept that CBC has the right to reproduce and publish that comment in whole or in part, in any manner CBC chooses. Please note that CBC does not endorse the opinions expressed in comments. Comments on this story are moderated according to our Submission Guidelines. Comments are welcome while open. We reserve the right to close comments at any time.

now