Budget sales job won't include paid ads, Bill Morneau says

As Prime Minister Justin Trudeau and Finance Minister Bill Morneau continue to pitch the virtues of their first Liberal budget across Canada this week, one thing noticeably absent from the annual post-budget sales job is a government ad blitz.

But promotional campaign well underway with speaking tours - and New Brunswick MP's ad

Prime Minister Justin Trudeau and Finance Minister Bill Morneau continue to pitch the virtues of their first Liberal budget across Canada this week, but that won't include paid government ads, Morneau says. (Sean Kilpatrick/Canadian Press)

There's no pricey government ad campaign in the works to promote the first federal Liberal budget, says Finance Minister Bill Morneau.

But that doesn't mean no advertising will roll out eventually, nor does it mean taxpayer funds aren't being used now to sell the big-spending Liberal blueprint.

Morneau was in New York on Wednesday as part of his budget road show and will be in Paris on Thursday — with travel costs that should be itemized and reported under any new system designed to check government self-promotion, according to "Brand Command," an important new book on centralized government communications.

Finance Minister Bill Morneau is in New York City selling the virtues of investing in Canada. 2:20

"We as a government have decided to take a much different approach in how we present ourselves more broadly and we're going to be very careful about what we spend in all areas of advertisement and this is no exception," Morneau said Tuesday during a budget-promoting stop in Montreal.

"We won't be doing any paid advertising for the budget."

Finance officials offered a more nuanced assessment Wednesday.

New Brunswick Liberal MP Karen Ludwig ran this full-page ad in the Telegraph Journal to promote the Liberal government's first budget. The ad, which was paid for by the MP's budget, includes the party's election slogan, "Real Change." (Supplied photo)

Once the budget is passed in Parliament, the government may do paid promotions to inform Canadians of specific measures that affect them, such as changes to the student loans program. But rather than big-budget TV spots common under previous governments, the Liberals say they're looking at targeted, digital campaigns.

The promotional campaign is already quietly underway.

Finance Canada has created a dedicated budget web page, complete with a cheery animated video portraying the document's voter-friendly highlights. The page and video are being promoted on social media by a variety of federal departments. There's also a full-page budget ad in the New Brunswick Telegraph Journal under the name of local Liberal MP Karen Ludwig.

Ludwig said it was her decision to run the ad, which was paid for out of her MP budget, to inform constituents in her large rural riding of New Brunswick Southwest about measures in the budget that might affect them.

"It was really about getting an important message out to constituents, as clearly as I could," Ludwig said.

Prime Minister Justin Trudeau, meanwhile, spent his second day in Alberta pitching the government's changes to employment insurance and other budgetary measures, while other ministers are spreading the gospel elsewhere across the country.

Branding seen as critical

Without a multimillion-dollar government ad campaign, establishing the Liberal brand around the new budget is clearly a priority.

Alex Marland, a political scientist at Memorial University, writes in "Brand Command," released this month by UBC Press, that promoting a brand is critical to government communications in the fast-paced, digital news age.

Finance Minister Bill Morneau brought down his first budget last week. Its title, Growing the Middle Class, echoed the main Liberal campaign theme. (Adrian Wyld/Canadian Press)

The former Conservative government came under frequent fire for spending tens of millions of dollars on ads touting the benefits of its economic action plan, which was a whole-of-government branding exercise for the annual federal budget. It also used public resources to redo government web sites in Conservative blue and rebrand the government of Canada as the "Harper government."

Finance Canada alone spent $8 million on action-plan ads last year — the second-biggest single government ad campaign after recruiting advertising by the Defence Department

Other government departments and agencies, including the Canada Revenue Agency and Employment and Social Development Canada, each spent more than $6 million on blue-tinged, budget-themed advertising last year.

The Liberals campaigned last fall on a promise to appoint an advertising commissioner to help the auditor general ensure all government ads are non-partisan and "represent a legitimate public service announcement." That promise has yet to be fulfilled.

Trudeau critics like to attack what they see as an image-driven prime minister, but Brand Command chronicles the extent to which the Stephen Harper government obsessed over image-making to establish a Conservative brand.

Marland argues Trudeau will find it very difficult to resist the systemic forces that tend to centralize governments, including the need to establish an easily identifiable brand.

But he also observes that the camera-friendly Trudeau has a leg up in the branding game.

Among Marland's prescriptions for reforming federal communications is an annual report on "media pseudo-events," such as photo-ops, speeches and announcements away from Parliament Hill, including travel, signage, room rentals and other expenses.

He'd also like to see all government of Canada communications in red and white only — while barring political parties (hello Liberals) from using those colours and the red Maple Leaf prominently in their design and logos.

"Above all, what must be limited is the publicity state's contribution to the fusion of party and government brands," Marland writes.

with a file from CBC News


To encourage thoughtful and respectful conversations, first and last names will appear with each submission to CBC/Radio-Canada's online communities (except in children and youth-oriented communities). Pseudonyms will no longer be permitted.

By submitting a comment, you accept that CBC has the right to reproduce and publish that comment in whole or in part, in any manner CBC chooses. Please note that CBC does not endorse the opinions expressed in comments. Comments on this story are moderated according to our Submission Guidelines. Comments are welcome while open. We reserve the right to close comments at any time.