Why pay for Ontario's hydro mistakes now when we can pay (more) for them later?: Robyn Urback

The promise of lower hydro bills wouldn't be a proper Wynne government "gift" if it didn't come with a few asterisks.

Ontario's government says it will lower hydro bills by stretching out financing over a longer period of time

The promise of lower hydro rates wouldn't be a proper Wynne government gift if it didn't come with a few asterisks. (Eduardo Lima/Canadian Press)

Christmas in Ontario comes roughly every 3½ years, and also in certain emergencies, such as whenpolls show the Liberals flirting with third-party status and Premier Kathleen Wynne's approval rating dipping below the teens.

Gifts during this festive time come in the form of, for example, a greater share of the provincial gas tax going from the province to municipalities, an endowment that spared Toronto-area voters — oops, I mean "commuters" — from having to payroad tolls on certain highways. Remember who saved you that extra expense come election time, everyone!

Gifts are also handed out to the Ontario Liberals' key election-time allies — oops, that should read "Ontario's valuable public sector unions" — which, just last month, reached contractextension deals with the government after years of negotiation. Don't forget who gave you those four per cent raises, teachers!

Lower hydro bills

And now: a gift for everyone. The Liberal government has heard your cries about the ballooning cost of hydro (funny, those cries only really became audible once they began sounding like "PC super majority") and it is now promising to lower everyone's electricity bills by 25 per cent. Rejoice!

Just try not to think about which party locked Ontario into decades-long deals to pay above market value for electricity in the first place — the governing party that has seen off-peak rates jump nearly 150 per cent over the past ten years, to say nothing of delivery charges. Instead, focus on which party is now promising to reduce your monthly payments in the short term, and keep reminding yourself of that until, say, June 7, 2018.

Premier Kathleen Wynne discusses how hydro bills for residential and small business customers in Ontario will drop by eight per cent on Jan. 1, as the government begins a rebate of the provincial portion of the HST on electricity. 0:57

According to the Toronto Star, Ontario plans to finance this 25 per cent reduction by "smoothing out" electricity generation costs over a longer period of time, which will translate to smaller payments over an extended period. From a political strategy perspective, the Liberals are quite obviously banking on the notion that most voters either won't understand that they'll be paying even more for electricity by extending the amortization period, or that they won't care, which will probably be the case —understandably so — among those rural Ontarians who are struggling month after month to literally keep the lights on.

But this wouldn't be a proper Wynne government gift if it didn't come with a few asterisks. The first: this 25 per cent reduction in hydro rates is actually a 17 per cent reduction, considering it includes the eight per cent rebate on the provincial portion of the harmonized sales tax on hydro bills, which came into effect Jan. 1. The second: that eight per cent rebate isn't really a rebate at all, since it is effectively cancelled out by the added costs of Ontario's new cap-and-trade program — which is estimated to cost the average household an extra $156 per year.

Most Ontarians should be able to recognize this 'gift' for what it is: an attempt to rescue the Liberals' nosediving support. (Colin Perkel/Canadian Press)

So, the actual savings will be much less than whatever figure the Liberals will champion in their re-election campaign commercials, and rather inconsequential considering how quickly hydro rates have and continue to rise in the province.

The whole thing is sort of like someone selling you a $35 organic cheeseburger and then offering you $3 off as a gesture of goodwill. The burger-slinger will tell you that organic burgers are just more expensive — like green energy! — but organic burgers only get to be that expensive if the cook has a nasty habit of burning every second burger and occasionally lighting his hair on fire. 

Most Ontarians should be able to recognize this "gift" for what it is: an attempt to rescue the Liberals' nosediving support by kicking the can down the road with a bit of temporary relief. But hydro users won't really be paying less; they just won't be getting ripped off quite as much — and only in the short term. Let's not forget what got us in this situation in the first place. Worst Christmas ever.

This column is part of CBC's Opinion section. For more information about this section, please read this editor's blog and our FAQ.

About the Author

Robyn Urback


Robyn Urback is an opinion columnist with CBC News and a producer with the CBC's Opinion section. She previously worked as a columnist and editorial board member at the National Post. Follow her on Twitter at:


To encourage thoughtful and respectful conversations, first and last names will appear with each submission to CBC/Radio-Canada's online communities (except in children and youth-oriented communities). Pseudonyms will no longer be permitted.

By submitting a comment, you accept that CBC has the right to reproduce and publish that comment in whole or in part, in any manner CBC chooses. Please note that CBC does not endorse the opinions expressed in comments. Comments on this story are moderated according to our Submission Guidelines. Comments are welcome while open. We reserve the right to close comments at any time.