NDP MP asks public safety minister to trigger RCMP probe into coerced sterilization

An NDP MP has written to Public Safety Minister Ralph Goodale urging him to use "all legitimate tools" to have the RCMP open an investigation into coerced sterilization allegations that have come from mostly Indigenous women across the country.

Public Safety Minister Ralph Goodale's office says it recognizes barriers keep victims from coming forward

Public Safety and Emergency Preparedness Minister Ralph Goodale's office is encouraging victims of coerced sterilization to come forward. (Sean Kilpatrick/The Canadian Press)

An NDP MP has written to Public Safety Minister Ralph Goodale urging him to use "all legitimate tools" to have the RCMP open an investigation into coerced sterilization allegations that have come from mostly Indigenous women across the country.

About 100 allegations of coerced sterilization have surfaced across the Prairies and in Ontario and Quebec since 2017, when a lawsuit was filed in Saskatchewan.

Don Davies, NDP MP for Vancouver Kingsway, handed the letter to Goodale on Thursday after question period.

"I ... request that you use all legitimate tools at your disposal to ensure that the RCMP opens an investigation into all allegations of forced or coerced sterilization within its jurisdiction in Canada and lay appropriate charges against those responsible for committing them," wrote Davies in the letter.

In a statement, Goodale's office said coerced sterilization was "a serious violation of human rights."

However, the statement sidestepped Davies' request saying that the RCMP is one of 300 police forces across Canada and can't investigate crimes outside of its jurisdiction.

"We encourage anyone with specific criminal allegations to report them to the police of jurisdiction," said the statement. "There is no time limit to report an assault to police."

The minister's office said it recognized that "survivors may feel barriers to reporting to police" and that it would "welcome Mr. Davies' collaboration to help explore any barriers so they can be broken down."

NDP MP Don Davies wrote a letter urging Public Safety Minister Ralph Goodale to trigger an RCMP probe into allegations of coerced sterilization. (Adrian Wyld/Canadian Press)

Davies said in an interview that Ottawa was ignoring its international obligations as a party to the UN Convention Against Torture which requires governments to proactively investigate violations of human rights.

"We have over 100 women say they have been assaulted, with names, dates and places. We are obligated by international law to investigate," said Davies.  

"The ministers of the Crown acknowledge that these are crimes but the police force and the minister of public safety don't think they need to investigate. It think this is a disgrace."

UN committee called for probe

The UN Committee Against Torture released a report in December 2018 calling on Ottawa to investigate "all allegations of forced or coerced sterilization" and hold those responsible accountable.

The UN report also called on Ottawa to criminalize coerced sterilization but the federal government said it wouldn't amend the Criminal Code to outlaw it, saying existing criminal provisions were enough.

Davies previously wrote to RCMP Commissioner Brenda Lucki in February asking her to investigate allegations of coerced sterilization but she responded that a review of the federal police force's national database revealed no complaints of coerced sterilization. She wrote in her reply that she had asked detachment commanders to review their files and that the RCMP would also liaise with other police agencies on the issue.

Davies has said he was "shocked" by Lucki's response and wrote to Goodale in hopes the minister would step in and ensure the Mounties opened a probe into the allegations that primarily stem from Saskatchewan, which includes Goodale's riding.

"These are clear crimes under Canadian law, and police should act when evidence of a crime emerges regardless of whether a specific complaint has been lodged," said Davies, in his letter.

Latest allegation from December 2018

Earlier this month the Saskatchewan Health Authority said it was investigating an allegation of coerced sterilization that occurred at a Moose Jaw, Sask., hospital in December 2018. The Saskatoon police also confirmed to CBC News this month that it had investigated a separate complaint of coerced sterilization in 2018 but it led to no charges.

Alisa Lombard, a lawyer and partner with Semaganis Worme Lombard, told a Senate committee that a Nakoda woman faced coerced sterilization at a Moose Jaw, Sask., hospital last December. (CBC News)

Alisa Lombard, a partner with law firm Semaganis Worme Lombard, is representing two Saskatchewan women in a lawsuit filed in 2017 against Ottawa, the provincial government, the Saskatoon Health Region and medical practitioners.

Lombard has said about 100 mostly Indigenous women across the country have contacted her alleging they were victims of coerced sterilization. In addition to Saskatchewan, Lombard said the allegations came from women in Alberta, Manitoba, Ontario, Quebec and the Northwest Territories.

About the Author

Jorge Barrera is a Caracas-born, award-winning journalist who has worked across the country and internationally. He works for CBC's Indigenous unit based out of Ottawa. Follow him on Twitter @JorgeBarrera or email him