Zika virus: new ways to fight mosquitoes needed after dengue failure, WHO says

The World Health Organization says that the traditional insecticide spraying methods have had no significant impact in slowing dengue, raising significant questions about how officials might stop the spread of the Zika virus, also spread by mosquitoes.

'Evidence is missing' that classical ways of fighting dengue reduced cases

Virus outbreak could be long over by the time scientists come up with a vaccine 1:42
The World Health Organization says that traditional insecticide spraying has had no significant impact in slowing dengue, raising major questions about how officials might stop the spread of the Zika virus, also spread by mosquitoes.

At the conclusion of a three-day Zika research and development meeting on Wednesday, WHO's Marie-Paule Kieny said that "evidence is missing" that the classical ways of fighting dengue have made any substantial dent in cases. She says the same challenge might apply to Zika.

"Everything that was done in the country to control [mosquitoes] apparently didn't work," said Jorge Kalil, director of the Butantan Institute in Sao Paolo, Brazil, who attended the meeting.

"The problem right now is it's very difficult to fight the [mosquito], there are billions and billions of insects."

Kalil said Brazilian officials may try a more targeted approach calling for more involvement from villages and individuals. Kalil was also optimistic that the coming winter season might help reduce mosquito populations.

Kieny said insecticide spraying and other techniques of mosquito control — some that have been used for decades —  "haven't been able to interrupt the transmission of dengue," and it's not known whether such methods would work with Zika.

"Certainly it is worth continuing to try to use this method for the lack of other interventions, but what the scientists said is that there is an urgent need to also put in place studies to evaluate whether it has a benefit or not," Kieny said.

Brazilian authorities have tried to fight mosquitoes for decades, such as with techniques like deploying insecticide-sprayers in coloured suits in rural areas or sending out advisers to help city residents identify and root out their breeding places in homes.

Kieny also noted another possible complication: that other mosquito species beyond Aedes aegypti might spread Zika. She said that while scientists have observed that other mosquito species can carry the virus, it's unclear if they can actually infect people.

Kieny said experts at the meeting discussed whether innovative methods like using genetically modified mosquitoes might be necessary to stop the outbreak, but noted that "extreme rigour" must be used in evaluating such new tools.

Last month, WHO declared the explosive spread of Zika in the Americas to be a global emergency, due to its link to the spike in the number of babies born with abnormally small heads and the rise in a rare neurological syndrome that can cause paralysis and death.

Most people who catch Zika only experience mild symptoms like fever, skin rash and muscle pain. There is currently no licensed treatment or vaccine.

So far, Zika has triggered outbreaks in 41 countries, although confirmed cases linking Zika to babies with birth defects have only been seen in Brazil and French Polynesia. Nine countries have reported a spike in cases of Guillain-Barre syndrome, a neurological condition that typically affects people after infections.

Kieny said vaccine development is still at an early stage and that although the most advanced candidates are still months away from preliminary trials, a Zika vaccine is "technologically feasible" based on the development of other vaccines for related diseases like dengue and Japanese encephalitis.

She said work is being done by more than 30 companies to develop a better diagnostic Zika test, since current tests often mix up Zika and dengue infections.


To encourage thoughtful and respectful conversations, first and last names will appear with each submission to CBC/Radio-Canada's online communities (except in children and youth-oriented communities). Pseudonyms will no longer be permitted.

By submitting a comment, you accept that CBC has the right to reproduce and publish that comment in whole or in part, in any manner CBC chooses. Please note that CBC does not endorse the opinions expressed in comments. Comments on this story are moderated according to our Submission Guidelines. Comments are welcome while open. We reserve the right to close comments at any time.