As cannabis vaping set to become legal, public health experts urge strict control
While legalization will help regulate what's in cannabis vapes, doctors worry about vaping-related illness
Some Canadian doctors and public health experts say Canada should hit pause on this week's legalization of cannabis oils, given the nearly 1,300 cases of vaping-related lung injury in the U.S. due to an unknown cause.
Cannabis vapes are among a series of new products — including edibles, extracts and topicals, like lotions — that officially become regulated on Oct. 17, 2019. The earliest these will be for sale legally in Canada is mid-December.
While doctors welcome the idea that the tetrahydrocannabinol, or THC, content in legalized products will be regulated, they are concerned about the health effects of vaping, which have yet to be well-researched and tested.
How do e-cigarettes work and what's in the devices?
Electronic cigarettes, or e-cigarettes, work by heating a liquid to produce an aerosol that users inhale into their lungs, a practice called vaping.
The U.S. Centers for Disease Control and Prevention (CDC) said the liquid can contain: nicotine, THC and cannabinoid (CBD) oils, and other substances and additives. THC is the main compound in marijuana that produces the "high."
Although currently illegal in Canada and parts of the U.S., cannabis oils for vaping are available online.
How are people falling sick from vaping?
The lung injury associated with vaping product use is now called EVALI, according to the CDC. More than three-quarters of patients who develop EVALI in the U.S. have said they used THC-containing products, with or without nicotine-containing products. Almost a third said they used THC only.
The first confirmed and probable cases of pulmonary illness related to vaping have been reported in Canada in Quebec and New Brunswick.
No single product or substance has been linked to all cases.
More information is needed to know whether a single product, substance, brand or method of use is responsible.
What's the uptake of recreational cannabis products?
Canada's Cannabis Act became law on Oct. 17, 2018, legalizing dried cannabis for recreational use.
From May to June 2019, about 4.9 million, or 16 per cent, of Canadians aged 15 and older reported using cannabis in the previous three months — unchanged from what was reported a year earlier, before legalization, according to Statistics Canada.
Just over three-quarters (77 per cent) of Canadians who reported using cannabis during the first half of 2019 consumed dried cannabis such as flower/leaf, which is currently legal. Other products used, currently illegal, included:
- Consumed edibles (26 per cent of users).
- Liquid concentrates (20 per cent of users).
- Cannabis oil cartridges or vape pens (19 per cent of users).
- Hashish or kief (16 per cent of users).
What's the advantage of legalizing cannabis oils?
Canada's chief medical officer of health, Dr. Theresa Tam, said the shift away from illicit cannabis for vaping in Canada is positive from a public health standpoint because what's in the products will at least be known.
"If there should be any issues or safety concerns, it's much easier to investigate products that are already regulated," Tam said on Sept. 20.
So far the only commonality among all cases in the U.S. and Canada is that patients reported the use of e-cigarette, or vaping, products.
The latest national and state findings in the U.S. suggest people obtained e-cigarette or vaping products containing THC off the street or from other informal sources (e.g. friends, family members, illicit dealers).
"Products obtained from the illegal market are not subject to any controls or oversight and may pose additional risks to your health and safety," Tam and her provincial counterparts said in a statement last week.
"You should never modify vaping products or add any substances to these products that are not intended by the manufacturer."
What's the concern about legalizing cannabis oils?
Public health officials hope that by regulating cannabis, the concentration of THC and other cannibinoids will be known and labelled, and contaminants, such as pesticides, and thickening agents, like vitamin E acetate, will be minimized.
But EVALI and its unknown cause or causes add another consideration.
For Dr. Samir Gupta, a respirologist at St. Michael's Hospital in Toronto, the deaths and severe lung injury that's landed young people in intensive care needing mechanical ventilation to breathe mean "we need to press the pause button" on legalizing cannabis vaping products.
He asks whether Canada is saying, "Let's release this, let's make it legal and once we have a spate of cases and maybe some people will die, we'll use that as a way to go back and trace and understand what the problem is? That is just not something that we as Canadians expect from our health regulatory agencies and that's not something the public should accept."
Canadians need to understand what's going into e-cigarette and vaping cartridges, and their short and long-term health effects before further legalization of cannabis, Gupta said.
David Hammond is a professor of public health at the University of Waterloo who has studied tobacco and uptake of vaping among Canadian youth. Hammond said as cannabis vapes are legalized, there should be tighter rules, such as limits on THC concentrations.
"Do we just let [cannabis] companies innovate and say 'Whoops we have a problem?'" Hammond said. "That's really the discussion we should be having around legalization. What are the products? How do we regulate them so consumers can have confidence in them and we minimize any risk. Quite frankly we haven't achieved that yet."
Before and after legalization, the consumer advice of "buyer beware" holds, as the government of Canada's database of safety alerts for cannabis continues to show instances of contaminated and inaccurately labelled products legally for sale.
A few legal cannabis producers have found to be "non compliant" by Health Canada for growing without prior approval, lax quality assurance and other issues.
- A previous version of this story reported that one of the anticipated benefits of marijuana legalization was that it would prevent "lacing" — mixing in other substances with the marijuana, such as opioids. The story should have noted that there have been no documented cases of marijuana laced with opioids in Canada, according to the Ontario Harm Reduction Network.Oct 18, 2019 3:47 PM ET