Crucial for health system, many caregivers are struggling financially and emotionally, report says

More than one-third of caregivers surveyed in Ontario report feeling depressed and many have suffered financial consequences, including time off work or turning down career opportunities.

Caregivers are 'glue that keeps the health-care system together,' foundation says

Stephane Alexis embraces his brother Torence, left, as they are photographed in their family home near Ottawa. Stephane helps provide care for his brother, who has cerebral palsy. (Justin Tang/Canadian Press)

They come from all walks of life, young and old: millions of Canadians who are unpaid caregivers for aging parents, children with a disability or a sibling with a chronic illness. Yet a new survey reveals many are struggling, often in isolation, trying to fulfil a critical role with not enough support from the health-care system.

Results of the Ontario-based survey of 800 caregivers aged 16 and older, released Thursday by the Change Foundation, paints a picture of people often thrown unexpectedly into a role for which they typically aren't trained and one that has major effects on their physical and mental health, relationships and career paths.

"Family caregivers provide the vast majority of care that happens in between appointments with physicians or in between hospital stays or different interactions with the health-care system," said Christa Haanstra of the Change Foundation, an independent health policy think-tank dedicated to enhancing patient and caregiver experiences.

"There's a lot more health care happening in the home, provided in large part by family caregivers," said Haanstra, noting that caregivers are often invisible in the health-care system, with their contributions going unrecognized as well as unrewarded.

"We really think about them as the glue that keeps the health-care system together."

Financial and emotional toll

The online survey, conducted in May by the polling firm Pollara Strategic Insights, found that caregivers overall appreciated the time spent with their loved ones and believed they were improving their lives.

But 61 per cent admitted they took on the role because they believed they had no choice, with many at times feeling trapped, helpless, frustrated and overwhelmed.

The survey found 36 per cent of caregivers felt depressed and 33 per cent were resentful of their role, with almost half overall saying caregiving had negatively affected their ability to have personal time, engage in travel or enjoy a social life.

One-third said they had experienced financial costs due to caregiving, including out-of-pocket expenses, time off work and turning down career opportunities. Eight per cent lost their jobs due to caregiving responsibilities.

"Family caregivers are providing care to almost everyone — siblings, parents, children — and they cover diseases across the spectrum," said Haanstra, who has a young child and also helps care for both her aging parents and a relative with a chronic illness.

"Obviously, the largest group is caring for people with health-care issues related to aging, Alzheimer's being one of them, frailty being another.

"But we are also talking about providing care to people with cancer, with disabilities, mental illness, chronic diseases of many varieties and acute illness, post-injury or accident," she said, noting that an estimated 28 per cent of Canadians over 15 have taken on a family caregiver role.

'Completely dependent'

One of those people is 25-year-old Stephane Alexis of Ottawa, Ont., who helps his parents care for his younger brother Torence, who has cerebral palsy and is non-verbal.

"He's completely dependent, he needs help with feeding, changing, even turning in bed," Alexis said of Torence, 22. "He's a pretty heavy dude, so there's a good amount of lifting involved."

Alexis, who attends a private photographic arts college, helps out after school and on weekends attending to his brother's needs, but their relationship goes far beyond that.

"He's completely dependent, he needs help with feeding, changing, even turning in bed," Alexis said of Torence, 22. "He's a pretty heavy dude, so there's a good amount of lifting involved." (Justin Tang/Canadian Press)

"I love my brother a lot. I love spending time with him. He's funny, he makes me laugh."

But Alexis admitted that even being a part-time caregiver comes at a cost. He's often exhausted, has little time to socialize with friends, and has had to put some life goals on hold.

"I was planning on moving out [of the family home] relatively soon, but I feel like I can't do that. I can't leave and just let my parents fend for themselves."

He's frustrated there's so little support from the health-care system: the family receives only 15 hours a week of help from two social services agencies.

"It doesn't seem like there's really any funding for home care. They kind of just leave you out there," said Alexis, who believes his brother's quality of life is "better at home" than it would be in a publicly funded residence for people with special needs.

"Why not use some of that money that you would be investing in a residence and use some of that money for home care?"

'I was worn to a frazzle'

For Don Mahood, frustration with the health-care system began when he was trying to get a diagnosis for his wife Mary Charlotte, who had been experiencing worsening memory problems for some years, forcing the registered nurse to give up her job.

"I tried to get her diagnosed with the doctor with difficulty," Mahood, 76, said from London, Ont.

"You'd get to the doctor and say my wife has some dementia. He would give her a test and talk to her for maybe 10 or 15 minutes and tell me she's perfectly fine. Anyone with Alzheimer's, especially in the early stages, can really mask it."

Mahood finally got a referral — a year later — to the Aging Memory Clinic in London, where doctors in 2012 confirmed his wife had Alzheimer's.

For the next six years, Mahood was Mary Charlotte's 24-7 caregiver, until his wife of more than 50 years was moved to a long-term care facility about a year ago.

"At the end, I had to dress her, bathe her. I had to do everything, she couldn't brush her teeth," he said. "When I look back, I don't even know how I did it myself.

"I was worn to a frazzle."

Though caring for his wife was a labour of love, the disease put an end to their plans to spend part of their retirement years in Florida. Mahood also had to give up activities such as playing hockey, and his social life faltered as long-time friends dropped by the wayside.

"So my friends became others that were going through it ... I would never have survived if I hadn't belonged to support groups. That really saved my life in a sense."

Haanstra said such stories, along with the survey results, demonstrate that the health-care system must do more to support caregivers and make it easier for them to access existing services.

"They're willing to do it, but we can't just send them home with no support and no information and expect that they're going to succeed."

Margin of error was not applicable to the survey findings because of its online methodology, the researchers said. But the margin of error on a representative sample of 800 people would be +/- 3.5%, 19 times out of 20.


To encourage thoughtful and respectful conversations, first and last names will appear with each submission to CBC/Radio-Canada's online communities (except in children and youth-oriented communities). Pseudonyms will no longer be permitted.

By submitting a comment, you accept that CBC has the right to reproduce and publish that comment in whole or in part, in any manner CBC chooses. Please note that CBC does not endorse the opinions expressed in comments. Comments on this story are moderated according to our Submission Guidelines. Comments are welcome while open. We reserve the right to close comments at any time.

Become a CBC Member

Join the conversation  Create account

Already have an account?