Eating more animal protein increases risk of death, plant protein reduces it

Cutting back on carbs and eating more protein can have positive health effects, but not all protein is equal — consuming more red meat, eggs and dairy could shorten your life, while eating more plant-based proteins like beans and nuts could help you live longer, a new study suggests.

Link vanishes among people with healthy lifestyle who mainly eat fish, poultry

A taco recipe by chef Michael Smith features green lentils and chickpeas. A newly released study suggests eating more plant-based proteins like those instead of meat, eggs and dairy can reduce your risk of death, especially if you're overweight, or you smoke or drink. (Tim Chin/Canadian Press)

People who eat more protein from plants and less from animals may live longer even when they have unhealthy habits like heavy drinking or smoking, a large U.S. study suggests.

The findings suggest that when it comes to protein, where it comes from may be just as important as how much people eat, said lead author Dr. Mingyang Song, a researcher at Harvard University and Massachusetts General Hospital in Boston.

"Plants are a better source than animal products," Song said by email.

"If people do have to choose among animal products, try to avoid processed red meat and choose fish or chicken instead," Song added.

Sesame crusted salmon with Asian greens and tamari dressing is a recipe designed by cookbook author and culinary instructor Nettie Cronish and dietitian Cara Rosenbloom. Based on the new study, researchers advise choosing fish or chicken over other kinds of animal protein. (Mike McColl)

The researchers noted that previous studies have indicated eating fewer starchy foods and more protein can help people manage their weight, blood pressure, sugar and blood lipids. They thought that looking at details such as the effect of different protein sources could help them provide more specific advice about what to eat.

Song and colleagues followed more than 130,000 nurses and other health professionals over several decades. Half of the participants were getting at least 14 per cent of their calories from animal protein such as meat, eggs and dairy and at least four per cent from plant protein sources such as pasta, grains, nuts, beans and legumes.

At the start of the study, participants were 49 years old on average. Most were women.

By the end of the study, about 36,000 people had died — about 8,850 of cardiovascular disease and roughly 13,000 of cancer.

After accounting for lifestyle factors such as smoking, drinking, obesity and physical inactivity, each three per cent increase in calories from plant protein was associated with a 10 per cent lower risk of death during the study period.

In contrast to the benefits seen with plants, each 10 per cent increase in the proportion of calories from animal protein was associated with a two per cent higher risk of death from any cause and an eight per cent increased risk of death from cardiovascular disease during the study period.

Animal protein deadlier for obese

This association between animal protein and mortality was even stronger for people who were obese or heavy drinkers, researchers report in JAMA Internal Medicine.

The researchers found that meat eaters with an unhealthy lifestyle and higher mortality risk tended to eat more red meat, eggs and high-fat dairy than the fish and poultry favoured by those with a healthy lifestyle. (hoosieragtoday)

"Obese individuals, as well as individuals with unhealthy lifestyle choices are more likely to have underlying metabolic 
or inflammatory disorders which could enhance the adverse effects of high animal protein intake," Dr. Pagona Lagiou, a 
nutrition researcher at the University of Athens who wasn't involved in the study, said by email.

The new study also found that meat eaters with a healthy lifestyle tended to consume more fish and poultry, while those with an unhealthy lifestyle and higher mortality risk — such as those who were overweight and drank at least one alcoholic beverage per day — tended to eat more red meat, eggs and high-fat dairy.

"So we suspect the different sources of animal protein between the two groups may contribute to the stronger results in the unhealthy lifestyle group," Song said in a news release.

Healthy lifestyle erases link

Animal protein, however, didn't appear linked to higher mortality for people with a healthy lifestyle. For these people, 
eating more plant protein also didn't seem tied to a longer life.

Because the study was observational, it can't prove that the type of protein people eat directly influences how long they may live, the authors note. It's also possible that the eating and lifestyle habits of health-care workers might not be representative of the broader population of adults.

For every 10 per cent increase in plant protein, such as nuts or beans, as a proportion of total calories, participants' average risk of death from all causes decreased three per cent and their risk of death from cardiovascular disease decreased 12 per cent. (Chloé Fedio/CBC)

The real risk of mortality from animal protein also appears largely tied to processed meat, such as bacon, salami and hot dogs, noted Dr. Dariush Mozaffarian, dean of the Tufts Friedman School of Nutrition Science and Policy in Boston.

"Other animal source foods seem pretty neutral overall but represent a diverse group, from chicken to eggs to yogurt, for which we need to understand each of their specific health effects, outside any single isolated nutrient such as protein," Mozaffarian, who wasn't involved in the study, said by email. 

"Based on a wealth of evidence, it's crucial to eats lots of specific, healthier plant-based foods: fruits, nuts, seeds, 
beans, non-starchy veggies," Mozaffarian added. "But don't focus on 'plant-based' per se: a lot of the worst choices in the food supply are plant-based, from French fries to soda to white bread and white rice."

With files from CBC News


To encourage thoughtful and respectful conversations, first and last names will appear with each submission to CBC/Radio-Canada's online communities (except in children and youth-oriented communities). Pseudonyms will no longer be permitted.

By submitting a comment, you accept that CBC has the right to reproduce and publish that comment in whole or in part, in any manner CBC chooses. Please note that CBC does not endorse the opinions expressed in comments. Comments on this story are moderated according to our Submission Guidelines. Comments are welcome while open. We reserve the right to close comments at any time.

Become a CBC Member

Join the conversation  Create account

Already have an account?