Decade-long wait for surgery 'ruining her life,' Alberta woman says
Health minister's office promises to get to the bottom of delay after Go Public inquiries
An Alberta woman says her life is wasting away after a series of missed communications, long waits and gaps in the system have left her waiting more than a decade for surgery to relieve the severe pain in her back and neck.
"It's such a waste of my life, when I know it could be fixed. It's so frustrating. I sit around and do nothing and watch life pass me by," Cathie Burnup told Go Public. "So the last 10 years are pretty much a waste of my life, waiting for surgery that could have been done years ago."
Burnup is from Strome, Alta., a small village southeast of Edmonton. She has a history of congenital scoliosis and osteoarthritis.
The 56-year-old had to quit her job 10 years ago and now spends her days lying on the couch wearing a neck brace. She takes high doses of fentanyl for the pain as she waits for surgery to fuse two disks in her neck and a joint in her pelvis.
"Life is awful. It's chronic pain, so it's lonely, because you really don't fit in with society, you can't interact with people so you kind of become a hermit," she said.
Successful surgeries in the US
When Burnup was a teenager, Alberta doctors sent her to the Twin Cities Spine Center in Minneapolis for several surgeries in the early 1970s.
After Burnup was injured in a car accident in 1982, Alberta Health agreed to pay for another surgery in Minneapolis when doctors recommended she return to the same hospital that had performed her earlier procedures.
In 2005, Burnup's condition started to deteriorate and doctors told her she needed more surgery.
Go Public put together a timeline based on doctors' letters and referrals that shows big gaps, long waits and a failure to communicate within the health system.
- December 2005: Burnup's doctor gets a response back from an Alberta neurosurgeon saying he is too busy to see Burnup, suggesting she be referred to another doctor or back to the doctor who originally performed her surgery in Minneapolis.
- 2006-10: Burnup is bounced from doctor to doctor and department to department within Alberta Health waiting to hear if the surgery will be done in either in Alberta, B.C. or Minneapolis.
- March 2010: Alberta Health finally agrees to pay for Burnup's trip to Minneapolis, but only for a consultation.
- April 2010: Burnup sees Dr. Joseph Perra in Minneapolis who confirms the need for surgery and suggests the option of getting a Canadian surgeon to do it.
- Late 2010: Burnup is told by Alberta Health she won't be going for surgery in the U.S., but would instead be sent to the Vancouver Spine Surgery Institute at Vancouver General Hospital.
- January 2011: A letter is sent to Burnup saying she is approved for travel funding for an appointment with Vancouver surgeons.
- Early 2013: Burnup calls the Vancouver Spine Surgery Institute to ask about an appointment and is told she is on the wait list and would be notified when an appointment became available.
- March 2013: The Vancouver Spine Surgery Institute tries to contact Burnup for an appointment time, but finds her number had been disconnected and her doctor did not have a new number. However, the number the institute called was not Burnup's general practitioner but one of the surgeons in Minneapolis. Burnup is unaware of the miscommunication.
- After three failed attempts to contact Burnup, the Vancouver Spine Surgery Institute puts her file into what it calls the "incomplete cabinet."
After Go Public's inquiries, patient services manager Brendan Tompkins said the Vancouver Spine Surgery Institute would pull Burnup's file and restart the process. The wait for a consultation is now a year to 18 months, and because so much time has passed, Burnup needs to update her medical file with a new MRI or CT scan.
Go Public also provided the institute with the correct contact information for Burnup's doctor.
Health ministry promises answers
Go Public also put Burnup's case to Alberta's Ministry of Health and to the province's health advocate. Both said they wouldn't go into specifics "out of respect for patient confidentiality."
"We would like to help the patient resolve this situation. The minister's office has reached out to this individual to hear her story, and we want to ensure that she, like all Albertans, can access the care that she needs," wrote ministry spokeswoman Carolyn Ziegler in an email.
After CBC's inquiries, Burnup got two calls, one from the Ministry of Health promising to get to the bottom of what happened, and another call from Alberta Health offering to help Burnup get an appointment with an Alberta neurosurgeon.
Many patients lost in health-care limbo
The father of an Alberta man who died weeks after being diagnosed with testicular cancer says stories of patients being lost in a kind of health-care limbo are common.
Dave Price said his son died after being failed multiple times by the health-care system. Greg Price, 31, died on May 19, 2012, three days after surgery to remove a cancerous testicle.
The Health Quality Council of Alberta released a review of Price's experience with the system. The report found breaks in continuity of care, lost information and poor communication between health-care providers is common.
Price said there have been improvements since his son died, but there are still big gaps.
"That is the reality of the way the system operates," Price said, adding that patients need to be assertive to make sure all the doctors involved in their care are collaborating and sharing information.
"There are way too many stories where there are gaps. It might be inadvertent on the caregiver's end, but on the patient's end it is critical," he said.
The Health Quality Council of Alberta and Price are recommending an online "patient portal," a way patients and doctors can track the process to get treatment.
Submit your story ideas
Go Public is an investigative news segment on CBC-TV, radio and the web.
We tell your stories and hold the powers that be accountable.
We want to hear from people across the country with stories they want to make public.
Submit your story ideas at Go Public.
Follow @CBCGoPublic on Twitter.