Food irradiation for ground beef not imminent: Health Canada

Irradiated ground beef won't be sold before the end of the summer at the earliest, Health Canada says.

Industry groups in Canada have sought irradiation for over a decade as a way to prevent spread of E. coli

The Canadian Cattlemen's Association wanted to irradiate beef following the 2012 tainted beef recall from XL Foods plant in southern Alberta. (Jacques Boissinot/Canadian Press)

Irradiated ground beef won't be sold before the end of the summer at the earliest, Health Canada says.

A web page on the department's website states the proposed amendments would add fresh and frozen raw ground beef to a list of foods that are already permitted to undergo radiation treatment.

It says the purpose would be to allow, but not require, the beef industry to use irradiation to "improve the safety of their products."

Health Canada spokeswoman Maryse Durette said consumers won't see irradiated ground beef before the end of the summer.

There will be a public comment period on the proposed regulations surrounding the sale of irradiated fresh and frozen raw ground beef, according to the department's site.

Industry groups in Canada have sought irradiation for over a decade as a way to prevent the spread of E. coli and other dangerous bacteria, but negative public reaction has slowed progress.

The U.S. Food and Drug Administration's website defines food irradiation as the application of ionizing radiation to food "that improves the safety and extends the shelf life of foods by reducing or eliminating micro-organisms and insects."

When we ask Canadians if they think they should be able to purchase irradiated beef, they're accepting of it.- Mark Klassen, Canadian Cattlemen's Association

Health Canada earlier proposed to permit the sale of irradiated ground beef in 2002, but according to the web page it was never finalized "due to mostly negative stakeholder reaction."

"I think public perception has changed," says Mark Klassen, director of technical services with the Canadian Cattlemen's Association, based in Alberta.

 "When we ask Canadians if they think they should be able to purchase irradiated beef, they're accepting of it."

Irradiation involves bombarding meat with radiant energy similar to X-rays.

Critics claim it produces toxic compounds, like benzene, and reduces the nutritional value of food. They also say it changes the taste of meat.

The cattlemen's association first launched an application to use irradiation for ground beef in 1998. Its updated application in 2013 to irradiate all kinds of beef followed a tainted beef recall at what was then the XL Foods plant in southern Alberta.

In 2012, 18 people in British Columbia, Quebec, Alberta and Newfoundland and Labrador got sick from E. coli linked to beef from the facility, leading to the largest meat recall in Canadian history.

Monique Lacroix, a researcher at the Canadian Irradiation Centre and at INRS-Institute Armand Frappier in Laval, Que., says irradiation will not significantly affect food. Lacroix says benzene is a volatile compound normally present in stored meat, and that when irradiation is done at the low levels proposed for the meat industry it doesn't increase benzene or free radicals in an amount to be of concern.

"When you use the barbecue, you produce billions of free radicals. You also produce toxic compounds because you burn the fatty acids," she says.

Labelling symbol?

Lacroix also notes irradiation will not significantly alter the taste or reduce nutrients at the radiation doses that would be used for meat, a conclusion she notes was confirmed by a joint committee of the World Health Organization, the International Atomic Energy Agency and the Food and Agriculture Organization of the United Nations.

Currently, onions, potatoes, wheat, flour, whole wheat flour, and whole or ground spices and dehydrated seasonings are approved for irradiation and sale in Canada.

Health Canada's website says irradiated ground beef would need to be clearly labelled like all other irradiated foods.

Bruce Cran of the Consumers Association of Canada, which has been lobbying for irradiation, is pleased with Health Canada's decision to move forward on ground beef. But he says chicken and salad vegetables should be irradiated, too.

"The science has been in on this one for decades that it does no harm," says Cran, who adds the risk of food-borne illnesses is high without it.

With files from The Canadian Press


To encourage thoughtful and respectful conversations, first and last names will appear with each submission to CBC/Radio-Canada's online communities (except in children and youth-oriented communities). Pseudonyms will no longer be permitted.

By submitting a comment, you accept that CBC has the right to reproduce and publish that comment in whole or in part, in any manner CBC chooses. Please note that CBC does not endorse the opinions expressed in comments. Comments on this story are moderated according to our Submission Guidelines. Comments are welcome while open. We reserve the right to close comments at any time.

Become a CBC Member

Join the conversation  Create account

Already have an account?