End-of-life care in Canada more hospital-centric than in U.S., Europe

Canada has the highest proportion of people with cancer dying in hospital among seven developed countries, despite a mismatch with the type of end-of-life care many Canadians say they want, the author of a new study says.

U.S. offers example of how end-of-life care can evolve to reflect patient preferences

Palliative home care

5 years agoVideo
Patricia Goyette packs up her dad's boxes and talks about his death 1:48

Canada has the highest proportion of people with cancer dying in hospital among seven developed countries, despite a mismatch with the type of end-of-life care many Canadians say they want, the author of a new study says.

The study was conducted using administrative records for people over age 65 who died with cancer in Canada, Belgium, England, Germany, the Netherlands, Norway and the United States. It was published in Tuesday's issue of JAMA.

Canada had proportionately the highest number of people dying in acute-care hospital settings, at 52.1 per cent, followed by: 

  • Belgium — 51.2 per cent.
  • England  — 41.7 per cent.
  • Germany  — 38.3 per cent.
  • Norway — 44.7 per cent.
  • The Netherlands — 29.4 per cent.
  • U.S. — 22.2 per cent.

"Countries like the Netherlands and England tend to spend much less but generally have a much greater capacity to deliver palliative care and hospice care than countries like Canada and the United States that spend much more," said study author Dr. Robert Fowler, an intensive-care physician at Toronto's Sunnybrook Hospital and a scientist at the Institute for Clinical Evaluative Sciences (ICES).

No country has it right, but there are fewer opportunities to keep people out of hospital in Canada and the U.S. compared with the hospice movement's established roots in the U.K., he said.

"A lot of that treatment in hospital is a very big part of what drives up costs, and ironically it's driving up costs for care that most people would say it's not the kind of care that they want."

As a critical care physician, Fowler sees patients who say they'd like to die out of hospital, preferring somewhere quiet and private. But since home care, in-hospital palliative care and hospices aren't adequately staffed, hospitals — and the tests and scans they routinely perform — have become the default in Canada.

The lower rates of hospital admissions, length of stay and deaths in hospital in the U.S. and the Netherlands suggest end-of-life care can evolve to reflect patient preferences and goals, the researchers said.

Hospice Chaplain Lora Johnson talks with Gladys Hebenstreit just minutes before their horse-drawn carriage takes off to fulfil Hebenstreit's final wish in McMinnville, Ore. Hospices have expanded more in the U.S. in the last 30 years than in Canada, a new study suggests. (Beth Nakamura/The Oregonian/Associated Press)

"One of the strongest predictors of someone staying home to die is their personal wish to be at home," said Dr. Russell Goldman, director of the Temmy Latner Centre for Palliative Care at Toronto's Mount Sinai hospital.

Goldman, who was not involved in the study, called having these intimate conversations to guide patients to decisions that are consistent with their values and preferences one of the most rewarding parts of his job. 

Patricia Goyette's father, Hafiez Albert Abdull, was diagnosed with cancer in his salivary gland about a year ago. He was able to die at his home in Toronto on Jan. 11 with Goldman's medical supervision.

"He started receiving pain medication and it needed to be administered every two to three hours," Goyette recalled. "I was actually sleeping on this sofa because I wanted to make sure it was being taken correctly to minimize the level of pain throughout the day."

Goyette said she needed to be mentally strong during his final days. If she wasn't retired herself then the family likely would've needed private help.

"I was happy that he was at home, he was comfortable, he was at peace and I don't think he would have received any different care if he was in hospital." 

A day of care in an acute facility costs about $1,000 to 1,200 a day, Goldman estimated. A bed in a palliative care unit in a complex care facility costs about $300 to $500. 

Some data, such as information about hospice deaths in Canada, weren't available. Similarly, the U.S. data looked at a subgroup, namely fee-for-service Medicare recipients.

The study was funded by the Commonwealth Fund, the U.S. National Institute on Aging and U.S. National Cancer Institute.


To encourage thoughtful and respectful conversations, first and last names will appear with each submission to CBC/Radio-Canada's online communities (except in children and youth-oriented communities). Pseudonyms will no longer be permitted.

By submitting a comment, you accept that CBC has the right to reproduce and publish that comment in whole or in part, in any manner CBC chooses. Please note that CBC does not endorse the opinions expressed in comments. Comments on this story are moderated according to our Submission Guidelines. Comments are welcome while open. We reserve the right to close comments at any time.