Ebola drugs can be tested on patients even if unproven, WHO says

Ebola outbreak patients in West Africa can ethically be treated with experimental treatments or vaccines that haven’t yet been tested on humans, the World Health Organization says.

Agency sidesteps the key questions of who should get the limited drugs

Testing unproven Ebola drugs on patients is ethical: WHO

8 years ago
Duration 3:04
Agency sidesteps the key questions of who should get the limited drugs

Ebola outbreak patients in West Africa can ethically be treated with experimental treatments or vaccines that haven’t yet been tested on humans, the World Health Organization says.

The United Nations health agency said Tuesday that, as of Saturday, 1,013 people have died during the outbreak in Guinea, Liberia, Nigeria and Sierra Leone. Nearly 2,000 others are infected

The WHO also announced its panel of experts assessed the ethical implications of using experimental interventions and approved the idea with conditions. There is currently no registered drug to fight Ebola.

"In the particular circumstances of this outbreak, and provided certain conditions are met, the panel reached consensus that it is ethical to offer unproven interventions with as yet unknown efficacy and adverse effects, as potential treatment or prevention," the agency said in a statement.

"There was unanimous agreement that there is a moral duty to also evaluate these interventions [for treatment or prevention] in the best possible clinical trials under the circumstances in order to definitively prove their safety and efficacy or provide evidence to stop their utilization."

The death rate in the outbreak is estimated at about 50 per cent, according to the UN, which has added to the urgency to use experimental approaches to try to save lives.

But it’s unknown whether the experimental treatments or vaccines do in fact help fight Ebola or what the side-effects might be.

Marie-Paule Kieny, the WHO's assistant director general for health systems and innovation, acknowledged during a news conference that supplies are currently tight for ZMapp —  an experimental  drug made by U.S. biotech company Mapp Biopharmaceutical that was partly developed at Canada's National Microbiology Laboratory in Winnipeg.

ZMapp was given to two American health workers infected with Ebola in Liberia. It has been reported that a treatment course was obtained for an infected Spanish priest who was taken to Madrid for care. The priest, Miguel Pajares, 75, had been treated with ZMapp, but doctors say it's impossible to tell if it helped or hindered his care or those of the aid workers in the U.S.

Two more courses of ZMapp were reportedly heading Tuesday to Liberia to be used on two infected doctors — the first Africans to receive the experimental drug.

"There was a lot of discussion knowing, for example, whether health-care workers would have priorities based on the principle of reciprocity because they put their lives in danger," Kieny said. "There was some support to this, but on the other hand, there was also voices within the expert group who said, 'Well, wait a minute, … the people who are in this  community who are sick should also have priority."

The panel of ethicists included a University of Toronto professor, Dr. Ross Upshur, a representative of a patient advocacy group in the U.S., and others.

Currently, efforts to contain Ebola focus on isolating cases, tracing their contacts and monitoring them for signs of infection, and following infection control practices for health-care workers.

"We are now talking about treatment, but we should really be talking about quarantine efforts and about getting health-care workers over there to help with containment efforts," said Ubaka Ogbogu, an assistant professor with the faculties of law and pharmacy and pharmaceutical sciences at the University of Alberta in Edmonton.

"I think we may be moving away from the real issue here, which is how do we prevent further spread of the disease," Ogbogu told CBC Radio's The Current guest host Piya Chattopadhyay.

Also on Tuesday, UN Secretary General Ban Ki-moon urged the international community to respond to a shortage of doctors, nurses and equipment in West Africa to stem the Ebola outbreak.

"We need to avoid panic and fear," Ban said. "Ebola can be prevented."

Experimental drug options

WHO's medical ethicists did not directly address who should get the limited drugs or how those decisions should be made, but said ethical criteria, such as transparency about informed consent and confidentiality, must guide the determinations.

The WHO plans to reconvene the panel, drawing in other experts as well, before the end of the month to work on more questions about the ethical use of available drugs and vaccines, and how to ensure that when they are used their efficacy is monitored.

As well as ZMapp, researchers and biotech companies are working on several other potential drugs, including B.C.'s Tekmira Pharmaceuticals, Biocryst Pharmaceuticals and Siga Technologies.

Researchers also plan to start a small clinical trial in humans of an experimental Ebola vaccine that was developed by U.S. National Institute of Allergy and Infectious Diseases and licensed to GlaxoSmithKline, as soon as next month.

Another experimental vaccine was developed at Canada’s National Microbiology Lab.

Ban also announced the appointment of UN public health expert David Nabarro to co-ordinate WHO's effort to fight Ebola. Nabarro previously led earlier UN efforts to fight infectious diseases such as SARS.

With files from The Associated Press, The Canadian Press and Reuters


To encourage thoughtful and respectful conversations, first and last names will appear with each submission to CBC/Radio-Canada's online communities (except in children and youth-oriented communities). Pseudonyms will no longer be permitted.

By submitting a comment, you accept that CBC has the right to reproduce and publish that comment in whole or in part, in any manner CBC chooses. Please note that CBC does not endorse the opinions expressed in comments. Comments on this story are moderated according to our Submission Guidelines. Comments are welcome while open. We reserve the right to close comments at any time.

Become a CBC Member

Join the conversation  Create account

Already have an account?