The virus behind COVID-19 is mutating and immune-evasive. Here's what that means
COVID-19 cases in Canada could increase in the new year, health officials say
As COVID-19 approaches its fourth year, Omicron continues to mutate and become more immune-evasive, health officials say.
In December, the World Health Organization said variants descending from Omicron show more capacity to escape our immune system.
"Omicron, the latest variant of concern, is the most transmissible variant we have seen so far, including all the sub-variants that are in circulation," Maria Van Kerkhove, WHO's technical lead for COVID-19, said on Dec. 21.
Whether that's enough to drive new waves of infections depends on conditions such as the size and timing of previous Omicron waves, the regional immune landscape and COVID-19 vaccination coverage, the United Nations public health agency said.
In Canada, differences in population-level immunity and global trends suggest COVID-19 cases could increase in the new year, health officials said last week.
But what does mutation mean, what doesn't it mean and why does immune evasiveness matter? Here are some answers based on what we know at this stage in the pandemic.
What's a mutation?
A mutation is a change in the genetic code of the COVID-19 virus. Some mutations have no effect. Others lead to changes in proteins, which can be helpful to the virus by making it more transmissible — the ability to pass from one person to another. Or the mutation could be harmful to the virus if your immune system gains an advantage over the pathogen.
The WHO notes that there are currently about 540 Omicron sub-variants, but only five are "under monitoring" for changes such as mutations or rise in prevalence.
The variants of concern show one or several traits compared with the original or ancestral version of the virus:
- Spread more easily.
- Cause more severe illness.
- Evade or escape current vaccines or treatments.
In particular, physicians and scientists are watching for mutations to the virus's spike protein. That's what the virus uses to grab onto our cells and then enter them.
The BQ 1.1 subvariant of Omicron is immune evasive to the point where an antiviral treatment doesn't work, Dr. Theresa Tam, Canada's chief public health officer, said in mid December.
"We have to monitor susceptibility of the virus to these medications," Tam said.
Genetic sequencing data also suggests the more immune-evasive variants are increasing, while BA.5 that dominated in the summer is decreasing, Tam said.
At a minimum, it means COVID cases will decline more slowly with a higher plateau of infections and hospitalizations as the respiratory virus season plays out, she said.
How does immunity work?
From the perspective of the virus, immunology professor Dawn Bowdish at McMaster University in Hamilton said if the virus allowed our immunity system to fend it off then it would be game over for the microbe. To survive, Omicron's offspring variants like BQ1.1 skirt our immune defences.
The virus infects hosts to make copies of itself. In the process of using our cells as a virus factory, we get sick.
But not everyone who is exposed to the virus falls ill. As for why, think of the immune system like a medieval castle with different barriers, such as a wall surrounding the building, a moat and then armed guards.
First, there's the outer wall to keep out invaders. For us, the main barrier to keep out respiratory pathogens is the nose. In the case of COVID-19, what scientists call "mucosal immunity" is found in the nasal passages and pharynx, commonly called the throat.
When the virus approaches, our natural immune response tries to summon for help.
"When they [Omicron subvariants] get into your nose, your mouth, when you first breathe them, they have ways of shutting off our natural antiviral immune responses," said Bowdish, who holds the Canada Research Chair in aging and immunity.
Once the virus makes it through the first layer of defence, antibodies then act. Antibodies are proteins that your immune system makes to help fight infection. They also work to protect you from getting sick with the same virus in the future.
Antibodies need "to stick" to the virus to be effective, Bowdish said. Weeks after someone's been vaccinated, the immune system produces lots of antibodies. Even if they don't stick so well, the sheer number are likely to offer protection.
The tradeoff is that it takes us a lot of energy to make antibodies, which wane or decrease over weeks and months.
"In the context of Omicron, it's well documented that the closer you are to your vaccine, the less likely you are to be infected with the virus because weeks after you receive your vaccine, your antibody levels are sky high," Bowdish said.
COVID-19 can evade immunity
But SARS-CoV-2, the virus that causes COVID-19, has other ways to overcome antibody defences.
"It's also very good at hiding out from those antibodies," Bowdish said.
Since Omicron subvariants evade the immune system's capacity to fully control it, we're more prone to re-infections now than with earlier variants, said Dr. Hélène Decaluwe, an immunologist and clinician-scientist.
"Most Canadians have been either infected or vaccinated," said Decaluwe, who is also an associate professor at the University of Montreal. "Despite that, we cannot completely block the transmission."
Decaluwe said antibody levels are an important way to block transmission, but their levels also decrease after a first infection.
"If you have your primary series of two vaccine doses and you have your booster with that third [dose], we can see in patients that have been infected [the combination] probably leads to better long-term memory of the infection," she said.
That's because the body's immune system has been exposed to not only the viral spike protein but also others that are important to protect us from severe disease.
What happens when antibodies don't protect us?
That's what Decaluwe and her lab team research: T-cell response. T cells, a type of white blood cell that help protect the body from infection, are like the armed guards throwing spears at the COVID virus from the castle's tower.
When antibodies fail to take care of the virus, T-cells kick in to prevent hospitalization and death from COVID-19 by targetting and destroying virus-infected cells. T cells do not prevent infection but set to work after a virus has penetrated.
Decaluwe and her colleagues with the Coronavirus Variants Rapid Response Network (CoVaRR-Net) use whole blood samples from nearly 600 individuals and advanced technology to study T-cell responses.
Decaluwe said about half of the subjects continue to provide blood samples to help researchers look at antibodies and other immune cells to detail the quality of their response.
Antibodies get created by another type of immune cells known as B cells.
When immune defences in the nose and antibodies aren't efficient enough to block infection, then T-cells and B- cells enter the picture. One role of B-cells is to remember an invader to help make antibodies when reinfected. It's as if B-cells are armed with a most-wanted poster to use their bow and arrows or catapults against Omicron.
Despite the advantages of the immune system and vaccinations, about 250 people in Canada a week continue to die from COVID-19 for the most recent two weeks that data are available. Many of them are older than 65.
Older individuals and those with immune compromising conditions are at increased risk of having severe COVID and are most in need of protective boosters, Decaluwe said.
Their vulnerability means medical researchers need to continue to keep watch for increased immune escape.
- A previous version of this story incorrectly provided the daily average of COVID-19 deaths in Canada as the weekly average.Dec 26, 2022 12:47 PM ET
To encourage thoughtful and respectful conversations, first and last names will appear with each submission to CBC/Radio-Canada's online communities (except in children and youth-oriented communities). Pseudonyms will no longer be permitted.
By submitting a comment, you accept that CBC has the right to reproduce and publish that comment in whole or in part, in any manner CBC chooses. Please note that CBC does not endorse the opinions expressed in comments. Comments on this story are moderated according to our Submission Guidelines. Comments are welcome while open. We reserve the right to close comments at any time.
Become a CBC Account Holder
Join the conversation Create account
Already have an account?