Health

U.S. counties with highest virus surges overwhelmingly voted Trump, analysis shows

U.S. voters went to the polls starkly divided on how they see President Donald Trump's response to the coronavirus pandemic. But in places where the virus is most rampant now, Trump enjoyed enormous support.

Retooled public health message might unify Americans around lowering case counts

A poll worker displays a voter’s details against a barrier protecting her from possible COVID-19 on the last day of early in-person voting for the general elections in Cornelius, N.C., on Monday. U.S. voters went to the polls starkly divided on how they see President Donald Trump’s response to the coronavirus pandemic. (Jonathan Drake/Reuters)

U.S. voters went to the polls starkly divided on how they see President Donald Trump's response to the coronavirus pandemic. But in places where the virus is most rampant now, Trump enjoyed enormous support.

An Associated Press analysis reveals that in 376 counties with the highest number of new cases per capita, the overwhelming majority — 93 per cent of those counties — went for Trump, a rate above other less severely hit areas.

Most were rural counties in Montana, the Dakotas, Nebraska, Kansas, Iowa and Wisconsin — the kinds of areas that often have lower rates of adherence to physical distancing, mask-wearing and other public health measures, and have been a focal point for much of the latest surge in cases.

Taking note of the contrast, state health officials are pausing for a moment of introspection. Even as they worry about rising numbers of hospitalizations and deaths, they hope to reframe their messages and aim for a reset on public sentiment now that the election is over.

"Public health officials need to step back, listen to and understand the people who aren't taking the same stance" on mask-wearing and other control measures, said Dr. Marcus Plescia of the Association of State and Territorial Health Officials.

"I think there's the potential for things to get less charged and divisive," he said, adding that there's a chance a retooled public health message might unify Americans around lowering case counts so hospitals won't get swamped during the winter.

A woman inserts her ballot into a drop box in Salt Lake City on Nov. 2. Regardless of the presidential election outcome, a vexing issue remains to be decided: Will the U.S. be able to tame a perilous pandemic that is surging as holidays, winter and other challenges approach? Public health experts fear the answer is no, at least in the short term, with potentially dire consequences. (Rick Bowmer/The Associated Press)

The electoral divide comes amid an explosion in cases and hospitalizations in the U.S. and globally.

The U.S. broke another record in the seven-day rolling average for daily new cases, hitting nearly 90,000. The tally for new cases Thursday was on track for another day above 100,000, with massive numbers reported all around the country, including a combined nearly 25,000 in Texas, Illinois and Florida. Iowa and Indiana each reported more than 4,000 cases as well.

The AP's analysis was limited to counties in which at least 95 per cent of precincts had reported results, and grouped counties into six categories based on the rates of COVID-19 cases they'd experienced per 100,000 residents.

Voters differ on whether pandemic under control

Polling, too, shows voters who split on Republican Trump vs. Democrat Joe Biden differed on whether the pandemic is under control.

Dana Clark and her 18-month-old son, Mason, wait in line as early voting began on Oct. 16 for the U.S. presidential election in New Orleans. Clark was adjusting a 'safety pod' over her and her son at the voting line. (Kathleen Flynn/Reuters)

Thirty-six per cent of Trump voters described the pandemic as completely or mostly under control, and another 47 per cent said it was somewhat under control, according to AP VoteCast, a countrywide survey of more than 110,000 voters conducted for the AP by NORC at the University of Chicago. Meanwhile, 82 per cent of Biden voters said the pandemic is not at all under control.

The pandemic was considered at least somewhat under control by slim majorities of voters in many red states, including:

  • Alabama (60 per cent).
  • Missouri (54 per cent).
  • Mississippi (58 per cent).
  • Kentucky (55 per cent).
  • Texas (55 per cent).
  • Tennessee (56 per cent).
  • South Carolina (56 per cent).

In Wisconsin, where the virus surged just before the election, 57 per cent said the pandemic was not under control. In Washington state, where the virus is more in control now compared to earlier in the year, 55 per cent said the same. Voters in New York and New Hampshire, where the virus is more controlled now after early surges, were roughly divided in their assessments, similar to voters across the country.

Trump voters interviewed by AP reporters said they value individual freedom and believed the president was doing as well as anyone could in response to the coronavirus.

Michaela Lane, a 25-year-old Republican, dropped her ballot off last week at a polling site at an outdoor mall in Phoenix. She cast her vote for Trump.

"I feel like the most important issue facing the country as a whole is liberty at large," Lane said. "Infringing on people's freedom, government overrule, government overreach, chaos in a lot of issues currently going on and just giving people back their rights."

About half of Trump voters called the economy and jobs the top issue facing the country, roughly twice the percentage who named the pandemic, according to VoteCast. By contrast, a majority of Biden voters — about six in 10 — said the pandemic was the most important issue.

Election challengers observe as absentee ballots are processed at the central counting board on Wednesday in Detroit. (Carlos Osorio/The Associated Press)

In Madison, Wisconsin, Eric Engstrom, a 31-year-old investment analyst and his wife, Gwen, voted absentee by mail in early October.

Trump's failure to control the pandemic sealed his vote for Biden, Engstrom said, calling the coronavirus the most immediate threat the country faces. He and his wife are expecting their first child, a girl, in January and fear "the potential of one of us or both of us being sick when the baby is born," he said.

Engstrom called Trump's response to the virus abysmal. "If there was any chance that I was going to vote for Trump, it was eliminated because of the pandemic," he said.

The political temperature has added to the stress of public health officials, Plescia said. "Our biggest concern is how long can they sustain this pace?" he said.

Vaccine could offer a reset

Since the start of the pandemic, 74 state and local public health officials in 31 states have resigned, retired or been fired, according to an ongoing analysis by AP and Kaiser Health News.

As the election mood dissipates, rising hospitalizations amid colder weather create "a really pivotal moment" in the pandemic, said Sema Sgaier, executive director of the Surgo Foundation, a Washington, D.C.-based nonprofit that worked with Harvard University-affiliated Ariadne Labs to develop a tool for estimating vaccine needs in states.

"We really need to get our act together. When I say 'we' I mean collectively," Sgaier said. Finding common ground may become easier if one of more of the vaccine candidates proves safe and effective and gains government approval, she said.

"The vaccine provides the reset button," Sgaier said.

Dr. Anthony Fauci may be another unifying force. According to VoteCast, 73 per cent of voters countrywide approve of the way Fauci, the director of the U.S. National Institute of Allergy and Infectious Diseases, has been handling the pandemic.

Even among Trump voters, 53 per cent approve of Fauci's performance. About nine in 10 Biden voters approve.

Add some “good” to your morning and evening.

A variety of newsletters you'll love, delivered straight to you.

Sign up now

Comments

To encourage thoughtful and respectful conversations, first and last names will appear with each submission to CBC/Radio-Canada's online communities (except in children and youth-oriented communities). Pseudonyms will no longer be permitted.

By submitting a comment, you accept that CBC has the right to reproduce and publish that comment in whole or in part, in any manner CBC chooses. Please note that CBC does not endorse the opinions expressed in comments. Comments on this story are moderated according to our Submission Guidelines. Comments are welcome while open. We reserve the right to close comments at any time.

now