Health

Will warmer weather help stop coronavirus? Surge in Southeast Asia raises doubts

A dramatic surge in coronavirus infections in Southeast Asia in recent days has increased doubts over a theory that warmer weather could stem the spread of the virus, health experts say.

Relatively low cases in Southeast Asia had given hope to Europe, North America that spring would stem tide

A police officer checks the body temperature of motorists attempting to cross a checkpoint put in place amid a lockdown of the Philippines capital, to contain the spread of coronavirus, in the outskirts of Manila. (Eloisa Lopez/Reuters)

A dramatic surge in coronavirus infections in Southeast Asia in recent days has increased doubts over a theory that warmer weather could stem the spread of the virus, health experts say.

Relatively low cases of infections in many southeast Asian countries had been cited as possible evidence that hotter weather was suppressing the virus, giving hope to Europe, Canada and the United States as they head into spring.

But countries from Indonesia to Thailand to Malaysia and the Philippines have recorded their highest rate of infections in recent days as testing has ramped up, in a sign seasonal factors may only play a limited role in the spread of coronavirus.

"The temperature theory doesn't really hold up given what's happening right now in much of Southeast Asia," said Tikki Pangestu, a professor at Singapore's Lee Kuan Yew School of Public Policy.

"People in Europe hope warm weather will kill the virus. I doubt this will be the reality."

The coronavirus, which causes a respiratory disease called COVID-19, has infected almost 170,000 and more than 6,500 have died.

Winter influenza partly linked to crowding together inside

Though a limited amount is known about the new virus, some of the symptoms show similarities with winter influenza, which is more widespread in colder temperatures, although this is partly attributed to people crowding together inside.

Places where the virus has been felt most severely, such as Wuhan in central China, northern Italy and parts of the U.S., share similar climates and temperatures.

The 2002-03 epidemic of severe acute respiratory syndrome (SARS) eased over the summer months, although it is not clear if that was related to weather or coincided with tighter public health interventions.

The World Health Organization (WHO) said this month that there was no evidence that temperature would play a role in the coronavirus outbreak, but it was an avenue worth exploring.

In Southeast Asia, which shares a hot tropical climate, many countries had reported few cases even months after the initial outbreak at the end of last year in China, despite the region's close travel, business and investment ties to China.

But health experts said, rather than the hot climate, this was more down to limited testing, under-detection due to a lack of resources and more imported cases as the virus moves to multiple epicentres outside of China.

At best, warm weather might influence the spread but it will not see the end of it.- Dale Fisher, Global Outbreak Alert and Response Network

"At best, warm weather might influence the spread but it will not see the end of it," said Dale Fisher, chair of the Global Outbreak Alert and Response Network co-ordinated by WHO.

"What is important is how effectively countries are isolating cases, removing people from communities. That's the biggest factor, not the weather."

The spike of cases in many southeast Asian countries has been dramatic in recent days, leading governments to take drastic action to stem the tide.

New cases in Philippines, Malaysia, Thailand, Indonesia

In the Philippines, deaths more than doubled to 12 at the weekend, with confirmed cases rising to 140 — compared to three 10 days ago — prompting authorities to place the entire capital, Manila, under "community quarantine."

Malaysia reported a further 125 coronavirus cases on Monday — bringing its total to 553 — the highest in Southeast Asia. Many were linked to a single event at a mosque.

A woman wears a protective face mask due to the coronavirus outbreak, at a supermarket in Bangkok on Monday. (Soe Zeya Tun/Reuters)

Thailand, which reported 33 new cases Monday, its biggest daily jump, plans to close schools, bars, movie theatres, cockfighting arenas and other entertainment centres.

Indonesia confirmed 17 more cases Monday, taking its toll to 134, amid concerns that there could be large under-reporting in the world's fourth most populous country.

Indonesia, which only recorded its first cases on March 2, had carried out only 220 tests a week ago but that has now risen to nearly 1,000.

Wave of imported cases in Singapore

Singapore, which has been widely praised for its monitoring and isolation of infected patients, from Monday implemented tighter restrictions on visitors from other southeast Asian countries after a wave of imported cases from the region.

With so much still not known about the coronavirus, health experts said countries should not rely on warmer weather to slow the rapid spread of the virus across the globe.

"It is too simplistic to suggest a tropical climate can stop coronavirus because there are many other factors, like human-to-human contact, which can happen very fast," said Sugiyono Saputra, a microbiology researcher at the Indonesian Institute of Sciences.

"Environmental factors may not affect the virus at all."

Comments

To encourage thoughtful and respectful conversations, first and last names will appear with each submission to CBC/Radio-Canada's online communities (except in children and youth-oriented communities). Pseudonyms will no longer be permitted.

By submitting a comment, you accept that CBC has the right to reproduce and publish that comment in whole or in part, in any manner CBC chooses. Please note that CBC does not endorse the opinions expressed in comments. Comments on this story are moderated according to our Submission Guidelines. Comments are welcome while open. We reserve the right to close comments at any time.