Childhood HPV vaccine lowers precursor to cervical cancer 'greater than expected'

Young women who received HPV vaccines have lower rates of precursor to cervical cancer, study finds.

The vaccine was most effective for girls vaccinated at ages 12 to 13

Scotland introduced a national immunization program against HPV in 2008, targeting girls aged 12 and 13, and a three-year catch-up program up to age 18. (Joe Raedle/Getty)
      Young women who received human papillomavirus (HPV) vaccines as adolescents had significantly lower rates of a condition that's a precursor to cervical       cancer, in a nationwide study in Scotland.     

"The magnitude of the effect is greater than expected," study author Dr. Tim Palmer from the University of Edinburgh told Reuters Health by email.


Receiving three doses of the vaccine at the recommended ages of 12 to 13 was associated with "a profound reduction of cervical disease seven years later," he and his colleagues report in the BMJ.



      One of the most common sexually transmitted diseases, HPV doesn't cause symptoms and usually goes away on its own. But the virus can cause cancer of the cervix, the fourth most common cancer in women, as well as cancers of the throat and penis.     

Study findings

      Palmer's team studied 138,692 women, about half of whom had been fully vaccinated against HPV either at ages 12-13, or later in their teens. At age 20, the women all had tests to look for abnormal cells on the cervix —         called cervical intraepithelial neoplasia, or CIN —        that can lead to cancer.     

Rates of CIN were low overall. But compared with unvaccinated women, vaccinated women had:

  • An 89 per cent lower rate of CIN Grade 3 or worse (0.59 per cent in unvaccinated women versus 0.06 per cent in the vaccinated group).
  • An 88 per cent lower rate of CIN Grade 2 or worse (1.44 per cent versus 0.17 per cent).
  • A 79 per cent lower rate of CIN Grade 1 (0.69 per cent versus 0.15 per cent).
      Grades 2 and 3 are usually treated with surgery.     

Girls who were vaccinated at ages 12-13 got a greater benefit: the vaccine was 86 per cent effective for them, and 51 per cent effective when given at age 17.


"The findings are dramatic and document a considerable reduction in high-Grade cervical disease over time," Julia Brotherton, medical director at VCS Foundation in East Melbourne, Australia, writes in an editorial published with the study.


Scotland, which has an organized national cervical screening program, introduced a national immunization program against HPV in 2008, targeting girls aged 12 and 13, followed by a three-year catch-up program up to age 18.




Herd protection protects spread of HPV

      The study also revealed a decreasing rate of disease in unvaccinated women. "This is called herd protection and is a function of the high uptake of vaccine in Scotland," Palmer       explained. Unvaccinated women are being protected because the spread of HPV between men and women has been interrupted because there are not enough susceptible women, he said.     

HPV doesn't cause symptoms and usually goes away on its own, but it can also cause cancer of the cervix, the fourth most common cancer in women. (CBC News)


There were an estimated 570,000 new cervical cancer cases globally in 2018, representing 6.6 per cent of all female cancers, according to the World Health Organization, with about 90 per cent of deaths from cervical cancer occurring in low- and middle-income countries.

      These countries, however, do not have the resources to support organized screening, the authors write, highlighting the importance of developing vaccines against the most important       cancer-causing HPV strains.     

Canada has organized cervical screening programs and introduced HPV vaccination programs in 2006. An estimated 1,550 Canadian women were diagnosed with cervical cancer in 2017, according to the Canadian Cancer Society.


In February, the WHO and cancer experts called the HPV vaccine a "critical" health tool and said access to it should be scaled up as swiftly as possible, especially in poorer countries.



To encourage thoughtful and respectful conversations, first and last names will appear with each submission to CBC/Radio-Canada's online communities (except in children and youth-oriented communities). Pseudonyms will no longer be permitted.

By submitting a comment, you accept that CBC has the right to reproduce and publish that comment in whole or in part, in any manner CBC chooses. Please note that CBC does not endorse the opinions expressed in comments. Comments on this story are moderated according to our Submission Guidelines. Comments are welcome while open. We reserve the right to close comments at any time.

Become a CBC Account Holder

Join the conversation  Create account

Already have an account?