The dark side of Canada's new food guide — many Canadians can't follow it
Is it time to revive an old idea about a national school food program?
This is an excerpt from Second Opinion, a weekly roundup of eclectic and under-the-radar health and medical science news emailed to subscribers every Saturday morning.
If you haven't subscribed yet, you can do that by clicking here.
With headlines this week about changes coming soon to the Canada Food Guide one haunting fact remains — many Canadians don't have the time or the money to follow the national nutrition recommendations.
One possible strategy as old as the food guide itself — providing healthy meals in every Canadian school — was abandoned by the federal government more than half a century ago.
Today, Canada is the only G7 country that doesn't have a national school food program.
Meanwhile Canada's food statistics are grim.
Nearly one in every six children is affected by household food insecurity according to research by Prof. Valerie Tarasuk at the University of Toronto's department of nutritional sciences.
"Food insecurity" is defined as a lack of access to food because families can't afford to buy it.
The population needs to be outraged that six other G7 countries do better.— Prof. Sara Kirk, Dalhousie University
"We've got an accumulation of evidence that we've got a very significant problem on our hands," said Tarasuk.
And it's not because people don't have jobs. In the majority of households facing food insecurity, someone is earning a wage or a salary. They just don't make enough money to buy food.
Even when families can afford food, they're still not able to follow the aspirational goals of the food guide because of time constraints or other pressures.
A modest target — getting kids to eat enough daily fruits and vegetables — isn't happening most of the time.
One Canadian study showed that 90 per cent of students in Grades 6 to 12 are not eating the recommended daily servings.
It's an enormous missed opportunity with research suggesting that simply chomping on a few apples and carrots every day could prevent thousands of cases of heart disease and cancer later in life.
'No single step could be more valuable'
In 1942 when the Canada Food Guide was first introduced, a national school food program was also being planned.
"No single step could be more valuable for the health of Canadians of the future," deputy minister of pensions and national health, L.B. Pett, said at the time, according to food historian Ian Mosby, in his book Food Will Win the War, The Politics, Culture and Science of Food on Canada's Home Front.
Why in a wealthy country like Canada are so many children hungry and malnourished?— Sen. Art Eggleton
But while Canada's Food Guide has been updated seven times since the 1940s, the national school food program never happened. The idea was rejected by Mackenzie King's Liberal government.
In 2017 a UNICEF report ranked Canada near the bottom — 37th out of 41 high-income countries on children's access to nutritious food.
"The population needs to be outraged that six other G7 countries do better than we do on school food. I'm embarrassed by that," said Dalhousie University Prof. Sara Kirk who described how a national school food program could be implemented.
Her research has revealed psychosocial and mood problems associated with poor childhood nutrition. Other studies have linked poor teenage diets to depression and suicidal thoughts and other chronic health problems.
"So why in a wealthy country like Canada are so many children hungry and malnourished?" Sen. Art Eggleton asked last June, as he introduced a Senate motion calling for a "national cost-shared universal nutrition program."
It's a recurring theme. In 1997 the parliamentary finance committee recommended a school food program. In 2013 the Conference Board of Canada repeated the call.
Right now there's a national petition currently gathering names demanding that the minister of health establish an "adequately funded national cost-shared universal healthy school food program."
'No plans' for national school meal program
But it's not happening.
"There are currently no plans to implement a national school meal program in Canada," said Health Canada spokesperson Geoffroy Legault-Thivierge in an email to CBC News.
"The Healthy Eating Strategy focuses on regulatory and policy initiatives that aim to improve the food environment. Improving the food environment will ultimately improve access to nutritious foods for all Canadians including children and youth."
The federal poverty reduction strategy is probably to the most radical thing the Trudeau government has done.— Prof. Valerie Tarasuk, University of Toronto
Many Canadian students do get some food at school through a patchwork of programs run by some provinces, municipalities and non-profit organizations.
"But there's huge pockets of this country where none of that exists," said Diana Bronson, executive director of Food Secure Canada, a pan-Canadian alliance of food activist organizations.
"Seventy per cent of children in Nunavut go to bed hungry. I don't think we can say that statistic often enough."
"If you'd asked me what the political priorities would be, it wouldn't have been legalizing cannabis," said Kirk. "It would have been investing in school food."
Tarasuk said there's another way to solve the problem — increase people's income.
"People who are struggling to put food on the table because of a lack of finances, what they need is money."
"It's quite interesting how everybody is all over the food guide. You can't say enough about it," said Tarasuk. "And yet the federal poverty reduction strategy is probably the most radical thing the Trudeau government has done."
- Liberals unveil new anti-poverty law with targets to reduce poverty rates in Canada
- Liberals vow to lift 2 million Canadians out of poverty by 2030, with no new spending
The bill tabled two months ago would establish Canada's first official poverty line — a poverty threshold that would be measured, in part, by access to food.
"One of the things that I think going forward that will be very important to do is to reconcile that poverty line with the new ideas about healthy eating that are going to be articulated in the new food guide."
To read the entire Second Opinion newsletter every Saturday morning, please subscribe.