Health

Blood flow restriction training finds fans at the Olympics, but it comes with risks

A newly popular and physically uncomfortable training technique being used by some competitors at the Olympics has experts torn on its benefits and risks.

'It's, like, a horrible experience,' physiotherapist says

Blood flow restriction bands popular among some athletes, but do they work?

2 months ago
1:57
Blood flow restriction is the latest training trend that athletes are using in their quest to be the best at the Tokyo Olympics. But some researchers question whether it even works. 1:57

A newly popular and physically uncomfortable training technique being used by some competitors at the Olympics has experts torn on its benefits and risks.

Athletes at Tokyo 2020 — like Americans Kayla Miracle, a wrestler, and Michael Andrew, a swimmer — have been seen on social media and in the practice pool restricting blood flow to certain limbs with tourniquets.

Blood flow restriction (BFR) training started out in Japan and flew under the radar for decades before gaining popularity in recent years, according to researcher Jamie Burr, an associate professor of human health and nutritional sciences at the University of Guelph. He's been studying BFR for more than a decade in his lab.

BFR lets athletes do lighter workouts while tricking their body into responding as if they were training harder, he said in an interview with CBC News. But it comes with risks.

"It actually feels like you're lifting much heavier weights," said Burr, who's tried it himself.

The effect is small, he said, but worthwhile for elite athletes. 

"The changes we're talking about are typically in the range of, let's call it one to three per cent. At the Olympic Games, that's the margin within being on the podium or being off the podium or maybe not even making the finals."

But BFR carries risks, including neurological damage and blood clots, if done incorrectly, he said.

Studies of BFR have seen mixed results. Two small studies, of 17 powerlifters and 31 rowers, found that BFR increased muscle gains and maximum oxygen uptake, respectively.

But other meta-analyses have found that lifting lighter weights with BFR is either equally effective or less effective than just lifting heavier weights.

'Horrible experience'

Some players on Canada's Olympic rugby team use BFR, but only for rehab training after an injury, according to Danielle Mah, a physiotherapist who worked with some of the players until they left for Tokyo.

"It's, like, a horrible experience, but they undertake it, for sure," she said.

An athlete wears bands restricting blood flow to their legs while working out. The technique is being used by some athletes at Tokyo 2020, and by members of Canada's rugby team after injuries. (Turgut Yeter/CBC)

"It's an uncomfortable process, but the fact that they can retain muscle mass after surgeries, situations where they aren't able to train, it's a fantastic tool."

She said the rugby team doesn't use it for general training because the benefits are minimal compared to traditional weight training. 

Dr. Christopher Raynor says he's skeptical that blood flow resistance training works for athletes who aren't recovering from an injury. (CBC)

Dr. Christopher Raynor, an orthopedic sports medicine physician in Cornwall, Ont., says rehab training is the right time to use BFR. He says it works for patients who are physically limited, like people who have just been injured or had surgery, but he wants to see more evidence that it works for more general training.

"Maybe this works, but I can't really hang my hat on it," Raynor said in an interview.

The studies that have been done used small sample sizes, he noted, and the ideal amount of compression is not yet known.

Canada's Lucas Hammond, right, Phil Berna, center right, and Theo Sauder, compete in a men's rugby sevens placing match at Tokyo 2020 on Wednesday. (Shuji Kajiyama/The Associated Press)

He says Olympic athletes can try BFR because they're in a unique position.

"They're willing to take the risk because, if you can finish one hundredth of a second before your opponent, that makes you the gold medallist and them the silver medallist. So they're willing to do that," he said. 

"But we have to also keep in mind that when they travel, they have a complete medical team that is with them."

Timothy Caulfield, the Canada Research Chair in health, law and policy at the University of Alberta, says BFR is different than other fitness trends that pop up at every Olympic Games. 

It has "biological plausibility," he said, whereas trends like cupping — which Michael Phelps and Prime Minister Justin Trudeau both tried — did not. Cupping is a technique that uses heated cups to create suction on the skin to relieve pain.

"I think we always need to be careful about how science is translated, especially in the exercise space where there's so many variables involved," Caulfield said. 

"Often these things that are presented as if they're going to have this huge, huge benefit. But often for the recreational athlete, the benefit might be much, much smaller, if it exists at all."

With files from Vik Adhopia and Melanie Glanz

Comments

To encourage thoughtful and respectful conversations, first and last names will appear with each submission to CBC/Radio-Canada's online communities (except in children and youth-oriented communities). Pseudonyms will no longer be permitted.

By submitting a comment, you accept that CBC has the right to reproduce and publish that comment in whole or in part, in any manner CBC chooses. Please note that CBC does not endorse the opinions expressed in comments. Comments on this story are moderated according to our Submission Guidelines. Comments are welcome while open. We reserve the right to close comments at any time.

Become a CBC Member

Join the conversation  Create account

Already have an account?

now