Asthma diagnosis 'trivialized,' fuels overdiagnosis, doctors say

More than 30 per cent of Canadians diagnosed with asthma don't in fact have it, a specialist says, on the heels of a British commentary that questions how inhalers have become "almost a fashion accessory."

Inhalers sometimes used under inappropriate situation but more stringent diagnosis would help

Asthma overdiagnosis

6 years ago
Duration 2:23
Some children with the label don't actually have asthma and could be using medication unnecessarily

More than 30 per cent of Canadians diagnosed with asthma don't in fact have it, a specialist says, on the heels of a British commentary that questions how inhalers have become "almost a fashion accessory."

Dr. Shawn Aaron is a respirologist at the Ottawa Hospital. His research involving roughly 500 adults, published in 2010, suggests asthma is overdiagnosed in about a third of Canadian adults and he's updating the findings.  A recent Dutch study on more than 600 children diagnosed as having asthma found nearly 54 per cent likely did not have it. 

"In adults we can do lung function tests because adults will co-operate with those," Aaron said. "But in children under six it's impossible to do these tests."

A lung function test such as spirometry involves breathing into a tube on a device that measures air flowing out of the lungs.

Aaron agrees with a British commentary in the April issue of the Archives of Disease in Childhood, titled, "Is asthma overdiagnosed?"

In the commentary, Dr. Andrew Bush of the Paediatric Respiratory Medicine department at Royal Brompton Hospital says the hallmark of asthma — wheeze — is used imprecisely by both parents and healthcare professionals.

Proper use of asthma medications dramatically improves quality of life, and reduces risk of asthma attacks and deaths, the commentators said. 

Besides the cost of inhalers, the commentary points to the potential hazards of putting children on long-term treatment without making every effort to diagnose with stringent, objective criteria.

The commentary also notes inhalers do have side-effects including growth suppression, adrenal failure and increased risk of respiratory infections.

Long-term inhaled steroids can also result in cataracts, glaucoma and osteoporosis, Aaron said.

"We propose that one contributing factor is that the diagnosis of asthma has been trivialized and inhalers dispensed for no good reason, and have become almost a fashion accessory," Bush and his co-author Louise Fleming of the U.K. National Heart and Lung Institute wrote.

Last year, the Canadian Thoracic Society and Canadian Paediatric Society released a joint position paper on the diagnosis and management of asthma in preschoolers.

For example, if a child starts to wheeze, it could caused by a viral infection that will go away, Aaron said. 

He suggests if a physician wants to keep a patient on medications for more than three to six months then parents should ask about diagnostic tests to confirm.

Elijah Ullmann compares an asthma attack to being underwater and unable to surface. (CBC)

"Sometimes we are using inhalers in an inappropriate situation and you definitely want to match therapy to the disease process," said Dr. Tania Samanta, a pediatric respirologist at St. Joseph's Health Centre in Toronto.

Since asthma fluctuates depending on the season and triggers, Samanta said she follows patients on a regular basis. 

An asthma attack is frightening, said Elijah Ullmann, 12, a patient at the clinic.

"Your body feels like it's shutting down," Elijah said. "It's like you're underwater and you can't come up."

His mother, Randi Hampson, said Elijah was diagnosed with asthma as a toddler after he was hospitalized for about 10 days following a respiratory infection. 

"He was on a number of different medications and they've been reducing the dosages of those medications over the years," Hampson said. "We want him to be a happy, healthy kid and to not use unnecessary treatment. That's the goal." 

No one should stop asthma medication on their own without consulting a physician, Aaron cautioned. 


To encourage thoughtful and respectful conversations, first and last names will appear with each submission to CBC/Radio-Canada's online communities (except in children and youth-oriented communities). Pseudonyms will no longer be permitted.

By submitting a comment, you accept that CBC has the right to reproduce and publish that comment in whole or in part, in any manner CBC chooses. Please note that CBC does not endorse the opinions expressed in comments. Comments on this story are moderated according to our Submission Guidelines. Comments are welcome while open. We reserve the right to close comments at any time.

Become a CBC Member

Join the conversation  Create account

Already have an account?