Who should win - and who will win - at the 2015 Oscars?

As the long road to the Oscar red carpet finally draws to an end we're making a few final predictions for who should - and who will - take home a trophy this Sunday.

Our Oscar expert weighs in with his final predictions

Eli's 2015 Oscar predictions


6 years ago
CBC film critic Eli Glasner on who should win at this year's Academy Awards 5:35

After months of campaigning the race for best picture for 2014, the top prize for the 87th Academy Awards has come down to two unlikely candidates: Boyhood v. Birdman.  One, a laid back cinematic scrapbook compressing 12 years into 166 minutes. The other, a flashy firework of a film about an actor in the midst of a mental breakdown. So as the accountants begin tallying the ballots for this Sunday’s show, here's my best guesses on the results.

J.K. Simmons, left, and Miles Teller in a scene from Whiplash. (Daniel McFadden/Sony Pictures Classics/AP photo)


Will Win: J.K. Simmons for Whiplash

The distinctively bald character actor has had this category in the bag for months for his performance as Fletcher, the jazz instructor who showers his students with saliva and abuse in Whiplash. Sure it’s a one-note symphony of vitriol and rage, but Simmons plays it perfectly.

Should Win: Mark Ruffalo for Foxcatcher

While I’ll be happy to see J.K. Simmons take home the Oscar, Mark Ruffalo's wonderfully low-key turn as wrestler Dave Schultz​ in Foxcatcher deserved more attention.

Patricia Arquette and Ellar Coltrane in a scene from the Oscar-nominated film Boyhood. (IFC Films/AP)


Will Win: Patricia Arquette. 

As raw as it is real, Boyhood’s Patricia Arquette will take home the Oscar for her role as the long suffering mother. Arquette set the tone for the film right from the first scene telling her daughter to cut out her "horseshit" and continued right up to the tear-your-heart-out scene as she’s packing, when she explodes in tears asking, "Is that all there is?"

Should Win: Happy to see Arquette win, but if by some surprise Laura Dern won for her live wire of a mom in Wild, it would be a wonderful thing.

Eddie Redmayne as Stephen Hawking in The Theory of Everything. (Focus Features, Liam Daniel/Focus Features/AP)


Will Win:  Eddie Redmayne for The Theory of Everything.

While the industry's love of Michael Keaton has given Eddie a run for his money, this role is Oscar catnip for voters. A handsome young actor taking on a true story of overcoming challenges and the added bonus of a performance where the character's journey is manifest by an extreme physical transformation?  Sorry Keaton, maybe next time.

Should Win:Jake Gyllenhaal for his role as Lou the sycophantic salesman in Nightcrawler.

Oh wait he wasn’t nominated was he?  (Shakes fist at heavens.)

Julianne Moore wins for best actress in a mini-series in Game Change.


Will Win: Julianne Moore in Still Alice.  

An amazing performance in an imperfect film, Moore — who is practically Hollywood royalty — will finally take home an Oscar for her role as a linguistics professor struggling with Alzheimer's.  

Should Win: Wild featured something from Reese Witherspoon that frankly I didn’t think she was capable of. A vivid primal scream of a performance as a woman who hiked her way to sanity.

Actress Patricia Arquette and Boyhood director Richard Linklater. (Mark Renders/Getty Images)


Will and should win:  Richard Linklater for Boyhood.

Boyhood would not have happened if it wasn't for Linklater, who took a gamble on an inspired idea and found a way to make it work. The film is the essence of Linklater's directing style, a movie that feels like non-fiction and was, in fact, informed by Linklater’s own boyhood, growing up with divorced parents.

Michael Keaton as Riggan in a scene from Birdman. (Atsushi Nishijima/Fox Searchlight/AP)


Will Win: Birdman

Should Win: Boyhood 

Here’s where things get messy in what’s become one of the tightest races this year. For a while now the conventional wisdom was that in the face of a weak year Boyhood was a lock for best picture. But since the nominations were announced Birdman has been coming on strong winning a number of guild awards. Also, keep in mind the Academy has a soft spot for movies that celebrate the act of filmmaking (remember The Artist?).

While many critics have been clinging to the hope that Academy will reward Boyhood's groundbreaking nature, I have trouble believing the generally conservative members of the Academy will "get" Boyhood and enjoy the slow-paced reflective story for what it is. Faced with the choice of the quiet pleasures of Boyhood and Birdman, the latter a movie overflowing with emotion and visual pyrotechnics, look to see the Birdman swoop in for the win. 


To encourage thoughtful and respectful conversations, first and last names will appear with each submission to CBC/Radio-Canada's online communities (except in children and youth-oriented communities). Pseudonyms will no longer be permitted.

By submitting a comment, you accept that CBC has the right to reproduce and publish that comment in whole or in part, in any manner CBC chooses. Please note that CBC does not endorse the opinions expressed in comments. Comments on this story are moderated according to our Submission Guidelines. Comments are welcome while open. We reserve the right to close comments at any time.

Become a CBC Member

Join the conversationCreate account

Already have an account?