Singer's live performance in computer-generated nightclub could be a model for concerts in a COVID world

Virtual reality team recreates legendary, long-demolished nightclub for Jill Barber's live online show.

Virtual reality team recreates legendary, long-demolished nightclub for Jill Barber's live-streamed show

Jill Barber opens her live show at The Palomar

CBC News

8 months ago
Jill Barber opens her livestreamed XR (extended reality) concert, set in a recreation of Vancouver's legendary nightclub The Palomar. 1:49

How's this for a pandemic performance: a Vancouver singer recently gave a live concert at a downtown supper club to an estimated 4,000 fans. Don't be alarmed — it was a COVID-safe show at a time when stages across much of the country are off-limits.

So, what's the catch?

Vancouver singer Jill Barber, who admits she used to be "afraid of tech," performed in front of a massive green screen, her band wearing motion capture monitors. At the back of the room, a team of technicians huddled over their computers and streamed the show to an online audience.

Using animation technology usually associated with video games and motion pictures, Barber was transported from a sterile suburban studio into a once-legendary Vancouver supper club, The Palomar, torn down more than 60 years ago.

Jill Barber and her band rehearse in front of a giant green screen at a studio in Burnaby, B.C. The live concert was streamed to several thousand people, with virtual reality technology making it appear that the band was performing in the long-demolished Palomar night club. (Ian Hanomansing/CBC)

Barber, who performs a range of genres including jazz, said she was enchanted by the history of The Palomar, which she discovered in the book Vancouver After Dark.

"It was a legendary hotspot in the '30s and '40s, where artists like Ella Fitzgerald, Billie Holiday and Nat King Cole played. I got pulled into the nostalgia, the spirit of the place."

So when film production company Shocap Entertainment pitched Barber on the idea of doing a live concert in a virtual setting, she pitched them on The Palomar.

They set out on an ambitious project: a mind-bending combination of a live performance in a venue that no longer exists, while quite possibly providing a model for future concerts in a COVID-19 world.

"I found the idea compelling," Barber said. "In these times when we are housebound, we can't go out on a night on the town, how cool to create the atmosphere of a bustling, busy nightclub and beam it into homes."

It took a cast and crew of about 50 people working for a month and a half to put together the extended-reality live show. (Ian Hanomansing/CBC)

Recreating that nightclub required some archival research and a little artistic licence.

Creative director Athomas Goldberg said his team pieced together the few pictures they had of the original Palomar, including "some souvenir photos, sort of early selfies where a photographer would take a picture and at the end of the night bring you the photo."

It was a big project. Shocap says it took a cast and crew of about 50 people six weeks to pull it off.

The costs were covered, in part, by grants from the Canadian Media Fund, Creative BC and Epic MegaGrants. An investment, perhaps, in future concerts. Shocap says it is creating "software tools to make this more accessible, especially for Canadian artists."

On a Friday night at 6 p.m. Pacific time, Barber took to the stage. As fans watched on their screens, they saw her singing live, her band transformed into ghostly images from decades ago. In the background, small, authentic details: liquor bottles, menus and posters on the wall of some of the acts that played The Palomar.

Jill Barber sings Joue Avec Le Feu

CBC News

8 months ago
Jill Barber sings Joue Avec Le Feu during her extended-reality livestreamed concert, set in a recreation of now-demolished Vancouver nightclub The Palomar. 0:58

While computer-generated animation is a staple of movie making, Goldberg says combining it with a live performance adds an extra dimension.

"It's an untapped opportunity for this kind of technology to reconstruct places and eras that no longer exist, and do it in a way that makes it accessible to a contemporary audience," he said.

"Once you make it live, it's no longer a documentary. It becomes this living thing, and you're transporting the audience to that place rather than them watching an archive of it."

Barber is quick to say she was skeptical of turning to technology during the pandemic. She started small this summer, with a couple of concerts streamed on Zoom. She sat down in her living room with her guitar, a few hundred fans watching and sometimes interacting.

Four months later, she was playing The Palomar and loving it.

Jill Barber and her band, seen here in rehearsals for the live show, wore motion-capture monitors, and the virtual-reality system made it appear to the audience that they were playing in The Palomar. (Ian Hanomansing/CBC)

In the end, Barber says, this wasn't an attempt to replace performing in person, but instead to create something entirely new.

"In these times when so many events are forced to happen online, I was pleased to be part of an event that was meant to be online. It was truly the result of collaboration and coming together to do something creative, fun and cool and connected for our audience.

"I think we've been missing a sense of magic. This had magic, nostalgia, stepping back in time and leaping forward at the same time."

Barber says she's taking another time-travelling trip into XR, or extended reality. The decade, Canadian city, and genre of music are all a secret for now. But the date for her next concert couldn't be more traditional: Valentine's Day.

Jill Barber's finale at The Palomar

CBC News

8 months ago
Jill Barber sings 'Leaving You,' the finale of her livestreamed concert which was set in a virtual-reality replica of the legendary Palomar nightclub. 1:00


Ian Hanomansing is the co-host of The National. Since 1986, he has had a wide variety of assignments for CBC as a reporter, anchor and interviewer. He also has a law degree from Dalhousie University in Halifax.


To encourage thoughtful and respectful conversations, first and last names will appear with each submission to CBC/Radio-Canada's online communities (except in children and youth-oriented communities). Pseudonyms will no longer be permitted.

By submitting a comment, you accept that CBC has the right to reproduce and publish that comment in whole or in part, in any manner CBC chooses. Please note that CBC does not endorse the opinions expressed in comments. Comments on this story are moderated according to our Submission Guidelines. Comments are welcome while open. We reserve the right to close comments at any time.

Become a CBC Member

Join the conversationCreate account

Already have an account?