Academy apologizes for Oscars best picture gaffe

The Academy of Motion Picture Arts and Sciences is apologizing to the cast and crews of the films La La Land and Moonlight for the mistaken announcement of the best picture winner during Sunday night's Oscars award ceremony.

'PwC takes full responsibility for the series of mistakes and breaches of established protocols'

Emma Stone, centre, congratulates Mahershala Ali as Moonlight is announced as the true Oscar winner for best picture, minutes after La La Land was initially and incorrectly named. A bemused Ryan Gosling stands to the right. The Academy of Motion Picture Arts and Sciences and accounting firm PwC have apologized for the epic mix-up. (Chris Pizzello/Invision/AP)

The Academy of Motion Picture Arts and Sciences is apologizing to the cast and crews of the films La La Land and Moonlight for the mistaken announcement of the best picture winner during Sunday night's Oscars award ceremony.

Huge Oscar mix-up: wrong best picture announced

5 years ago
Duration 2:49
Presenters Beatty and Dunaway given incorrect envelope by mistake

The academy's apology comes after the accounting firm responsible for the integrity of the Academy Awards, PwC, said mistakes were made and its staffers did not move quickly enough to correct the biggest error in Oscars history.

"We deeply regret the mistakes that were made during the presentation of the best picture category during last night's Oscar ceremony," the Academy said in a Monday statement.

"We apologize to the entire cast and crew of La La Land and Moonlight whose experience was profoundly altered by this error."

The academy also apologized to presenters Warren Beatty and Faye Dunaway and to fans watching around the world.

It has emerged that actors Faye Dunaway and Beatty were handed the wrong envelope for the final award presentation Sunday night. (Kevin Winter/Getty Images)

The Academy's statement noted that PwC, formerly Price Waterhouse Coopers, has been entrusted with handling Oscar votes for 83 years but said the Academy "will determine what actions are appropriate going forward."

PwC wrote in its own statement that several mistakes were made and two of its partners assigned to the prestigious awards show did not act quickly enough when La La Land was mistakenly announced as the best picture winner. Three of the film's producers spoke before the actual winner, the coming-of-age drama Moonlight, was announced.

"PwC takes full responsibility for the series of mistakes and breaches of established protocols during last night's Oscars," PwC wrote. It said its partner, Brian Cullinan, mistakenly handed presenters Beatty and Dunaway an envelope containing the winner of the best actress award.

"Once the error occurred, protocols for correcting it were not followed through quickly enough by Mr. Cullinan or his partner," the statement read.

It did not address in detail which protocols were violated, or say whether a now-deleted tweet Cullinan sent about best actress winner Emma Stone before the best picture announcement contributed to the mistake.

'We failed the academy'

The firm, which has handled Oscar winner announcements for eight decades, apologized to Beatty, Dunaway, the cast and crew of La La Land and Moonlight, the Academy of Motion Picture Arts and Sciences, and host Jimmy Kimmel.

"We wish to extend our deepest gratitude to each of them for the graciousness they displayed during such a difficult moment," the statement said.

"For the past 83 years, the academy has entrusted PwC with the integrity of the awards process during the ceremony, and last night we failed the academy."

The statement came after nearly a day of speculation about how the worst gaffe in Oscars history unfolded. The fiasco launched countless punchlines, memes and a probe of what went wrong.

A now-deleted photo of best actress winner Emma Stone was apparently posted to Twitter by PwC partner Brian Cullinan from backstage at the Oscars minutes before the mix-up. (Twitter)

The mystery deepened Monday afternoon after the Wall Street Journal reported that Cullinan tweeted a behind-the-scenes photo of Stone holding her statuette. "Best Actress Emma Stone backstage!" the tweet read.

The tweet, sent moments before the best picture announcement, raised the question of whether the accountant was distracted from the task at hand. Although the tweet was deleted from the social media site, a copy of it was kept by Google and available through a cache page.

Cullinan is seen at left with Beatty, Oscar show producers and others in the show's chaotic final moments. (Lucy Nicholson/Reuters)

The mistaken announcement altered the usual celebration that follows the coronation of a best picture winner. The only Oscars mistake that came close occurred in 1964, when Sammy Davis was given the wrong envelope for best music score winner but made a quick correction.

The La La Land-Moonlight mix-up, in contrast, took a painfully long time to be announced, with two-plus minutes elapsing before it was announced to the moviemakers and the world at large.

The embarrassing episode stepped squarely on what should have been a night of high-fiving for the academy. After last year's awards were clouded by the #OscarsSoWhite protests, diversity ruled Sunday as actors Viola Davis (Fences) and Mahershala Ali (Moonlight) were among the people of colour claiming trophies, while Moonlight focused on African-American characters.

PwC, which originated in London over a century ago, was quick to apologize to the movies involved.

'Painstaking' process

PwC representatives Martha L. Ruiz and Brian Cullinan are seen on the red carpet ahead of the Academy Awards. (Christopher Polk/Getty Images)

On paper, the process for announcing Oscars winners seems straight-forward. As per protocol, Cullinan and PwC colleague Martha Ruiz toted briefcases to the awards via the red carpet, each holding an identical set of envelopes for the show's 24 categories. The accountants also memorize the winners.

During the telecast, the accountants were stationed in the Dolby Theatre wings, one stage left and one stage right, to give presenters their category's envelope before they went on stage. Most presenters entered stage right, where Cullinan was posted and where he handed Beatty and Dunaway the errant envelope.

Yet the previous award, best actress, had been presented by Leonardo DiCaprio, who entered stage left and received the envelope from Ruiz. That left a duplicate, unopened envelope for best actress at stage right.

It was more crazy onstage. I feel like backstage knew that something was wrong and they handled it- Matt Sayles, AP photographer backstage

"It's a simple process, if a painstaking one," said Dan Lyle, who had Oscar duties for Price Waterhouse for 11 years in the 1980s and '90s. Accountants attended rehearsals to learn whether presenters would enter from the right or left. But given the possibility of last-minute changes, both accountants had a full set of envelopes.

When Lyle ended up with a redundant envelope for a category handled by his colleague, he said, he got it out of the way by stuffing it in a pocket or otherwise discarding it before moving on to the next award.

Lyle said there were always nerves no matter how much care was taken. Each time an envelope was dispensed, he said, he hoped that "I handed over the right one." If the wrong winner was announced, a PwC accountant was to quickly dash to the stage to correct the error.

Confusion onstage

Such a rapid response should have occurred Sunday but didn't, as confusion reigned onstage. Backstage, however, people were working calmly to right the ship, said Matt Sayles, a freelance photographer for The Associated Press.

"It was more crazy onstage. I feel like backstage knew that something was wrong and they handled it," Sayles said. "They clearly knew that something was wrong."

Members of the stunned Moonlight team takes the stage to join Beatty, who shows their as the true winner of best picture Oscar. (Mark Ralston/AFP/Getty Images)

Sayles, who has shot five Academy Awards from a backstage position just out of the sight of television cameras, said the result of the mix-up was a more subdued celebration from winners including Moonlight director Barry Jenkins.

One observer said PwC is scrambling now. Nigel Currie, an independent branding specialist in London with decades' worth of industry experience, said this mistake is "as bad a mess-up as you could imagine."

"They had a pretty simple job to do and messed it up spectacularly," he said. "They will be in deep crisis talks on how to deal with it."


To encourage thoughtful and respectful conversations, first and last names will appear with each submission to CBC/Radio-Canada's online communities (except in children and youth-oriented communities). Pseudonyms will no longer be permitted.

By submitting a comment, you accept that CBC has the right to reproduce and publish that comment in whole or in part, in any manner CBC chooses. Please note that CBC does not endorse the opinions expressed in comments. Comments on this story are moderated according to our Submission Guidelines. Comments are welcome while open. We reserve the right to close comments at any time.

Become a CBC Member

Join the conversation  Create account

Already have an account?