Making a Murderer: Netflix series feeds our true-crime obsession

Netflix series is only the latest in a new wave of true-crime docudramas that is feeding a seemingly insatiable public appetite for the genre.

How the latest arrival in a wave of reality-focused TV engrosses audiences

Filmed over a 10-year period, Netflix's Making of a Murderer is the latest series in a new wave of true-crime drama that's feeding public obsession with the genre. (Making of a Murderer / Netflix.com)

It's been a decade in the making, but its popularity has been nearly instantaneous.

Making a Murderer — Netflix's hot new series released on Dec. 18 — is only the latest in a new wave of true-crime docudramas feeding a seemingly insatiable public appetite for the genre.

The series — shot over 10 years by filmmakers Moira Demos and Laura Ricciardi — centres on Steven Avery, a Wisconsin man who served 18 years in prison on a rape conviction before being exonerated by DNA evidence. Avery was released in 2003, only to be sent back to jail two years later for the murder of a young photographer.

Much has been said about the lack of narration in Making a Murderer. It heavily relies on interviews and old media reports to tell Avery's tale.

And Netflix's release format — dumping all 10 episodes at once — has helped spur the show's popularity by allowing viewers to watch the entire series over the holidays, despite the fact it isn't exactly feel-good TV for the season.

"We had always hoped that we would construct a narrative that really would draw viewers in and make them feel they were on the ground with us and inside the action," Ricciardi said in an interview with CBC News.

"Sure, this is a crime story; we're following a case. But it's also a story about government accountability, it's also a family drama — it has all of these ingredients, and people are really responding to different aspects of it."

Making a Murderer filmmakers discuss 'social justice' narrative


5 years ago
Moira Demos and Laura Ricciardi, the filmmakers behind Netflix's Making a Murderer, talk about what they hoped to achieve with the wildly popular 10-episode series 1:40

Making A Murderer follows in the footsteps of some widely popular true-crime docudramas that helped to prime its audience.

The renaissance of the genre has been largely attributed to Serial, a podcast released in October 2014 that delved into the 1999 strangling death of Baltimore high-school student Hae Min Lee. It featured in-depth, not-usually-heard interviews with the man convicted of Min Lee's murder, her ex-boyfriend Adnan Syed, who was 17 at the time of his arrest.

The first season of popular podcast Serial was focused on Adnan Syed, convicted in the 1999 strangling death of his ex-girlfriend in Baltimore. (Courtesy of This American Life/NPR)

Serial was an overnight sensation, becoming the fastest podcast in iTunes history to reach five million downloads/streams — an impressive feat for a format that has traditionally played on the fringes.

Serial is now in its second season, following the tale of Taliban-captured U.S. soldier Sgt. Bowe Bergdahl, and is set to be adapted into a "making of" TV series.

A few months later came The Jinx, an HBO miniseries about the reclusive millionaire Robert Durst and his connections to three mysterious deaths. The show's popularity reached a fever pitch when Durst was arrested on a first-degree murder charge in the death of L.A. writer Susan Berman the day before the finale aired.

Real estate heir Robert Durst was arrested a day before the final episode of HBO's The Jinx aired. (Pat Sullivan/Associated Press)

FX is also set to dabble in the genre with its series American Crime Story, airing Feb. 2. Its first season, The People v. O.J. Simpson, is a retelling of the infamous 1994-95 murder trial that dominated U.S. headlines for months.

"I think the timing of when (Making A Murderer) was released was great both in terms of the medium … but also in terms of what's going on in the world today," said Demos.

"The idea that maybe those in power aren't always being held in check and aren't always answering to the people … Even that question, I think, is tapping into what people are interested in right now."

Shane Smith, director of programming at Canada's documentary film festival, Hot Docs, called the series "smartly structured." He's been tuning in and said he's "hooked."

Documentaries can 'change lives,' says Hot Docs director


5 years ago
Shane Smith, director of programming for Canada's Hot Docs festival, weighs in on what makes Making a Murderer so engrossing 1:16

"It's structured like a soap opera: you're watching an episode, there's a cliffhanger at the end, you can't wait to watch the next episode and the stakes are high," he said. "These are real people's lives that are being impacted."

Smith suggested the "Netflix effect" can create large-scale impact, adding that documentaries are an art form that can "change lives."

"Movements can form, petitions can be started, social media can go crazy buzzing about this new show that everybody's able to watch at the same time, in the same way, in multiple countries," he said. "It can become a global phenomenon … a show broadcast on one network, in one country, over 10 weeks really sort of dissipates its power."

According to the filmmakers, that feeling of encouraging social justice was a driving force behind Making a Murderer.

"Our main hope, really, is that people will have a new view of the American criminal justice system, that there will be a newfound appreciation for the complexity of these matters and that people will be more tolerant of the ambiguity of these matters," said Ricciardi.

With files from Kim Brunhuber and Deana Sumanac-Johnson


To encourage thoughtful and respectful conversations, first and last names will appear with each submission to CBC/Radio-Canada's online communities (except in children and youth-oriented communities). Pseudonyms will no longer be permitted.

By submitting a comment, you accept that CBC has the right to reproduce and publish that comment in whole or in part, in any manner CBC chooses. Please note that CBC does not endorse the opinions expressed in comments. Comments on this story are moderated according to our Submission Guidelines. Comments are welcome while open. We reserve the right to close comments at any time.

Become a CBC Member

Join the conversationCreate account

Already have an account?