'Ain't your grandmother's Anne': new series gives gritty Green Gables amid glut of Anne adaptations

A new TV series and a new trilogy of TV movies are both competing for fans of Anne. But will this glut of Green Gables remakes overload viewers or win over a whole new generation?

Are we facing Anne overload? With a new series and 3 TV movies, we might find out soon

Amybeth McNulty, 15, who plays Anne Shirley in the new TV series Anne, says it's the character's spirit that provides the story's enduring appeal, even to young people today. (CBC)

Anne of Green Gables may be the most popular Canadian tale of all time — the 1908 novel about the feisty, red-haired orphan has sold more than 50 million copies, been adapted countless times and inspired a tourist industry on P.E.I.

But has our appetite for Anne Shirley reached its limit?

A new eight-hour TV series, along with a new trilogy of TV movies, may test whether audiences can't get enough Anne.

There was great excitement last year when CBC and Netflix announced a collaboration that would bring Vancouver-born Emmy-winner Moira Walley-Beckett — the writer behind some of Breaking Bad's best episodes — back to Canada.

[Anne]doesn't pretend to be anybody else.— Series star Amybeth McNulty

What lured her home was not another boundary-pushing, drug-fuelled drama — but adapting a book that's beloved by pre-teen girls.

"How do you go from a meth lab to Green Gables farm in 1896?" Walley-Beckett asked during a recent interview. 

"This ain't your grandmother's Anne. I'm really attracted to human stories and character stories. That's what Breaking Bad was… And that's what Anne is."

"This is a cable, character drama," Walley-Beckett said, akin to shows on channels such as HBO or AMC, rather than mainstream TV networks. "Certainly the issues in the book for Anne — themes of identity, bullying, prejudice — are extremely topical right now."

Ella Ballentine says playing Anne Shirley helped her relate to her own great-grandmother due to the story's setting. She appears in L.M. Montgomery's Anne of Green Gables: The Good Stars on YTV. (Corus Entertainment)

Different look and feel

Executive producer Miranda de Pencier says what makes this Anne different is the look and feel.

"We wanted a documentary level of realism… so that it doesn't feel like a period piece from another time, it feels like you're infused in that time period and living and breathing what 1890s life was in Prince Edward Island."

That means a tremendous level of detail went into the sets and costumes, says veteran Canadian stage and screen actor R.H. Thomson, who plays Anne's adoptive father figure Matthew.

It's about belonging, it's about love.— Kate Macdonald Butler

"Do you wear costumes or do you wear clothes? We wear clothes. You don't wear costumes. That's a different game," he said in an interview conducted on the interior farmhouse set in a Toronto studio.

"I think it's that kind of approach which is Moira [Walley-Beckett]'s approach into the story, our approach as actors into the story, the designers' approach — this set is indicative of the ambition they set for themselves."

Audiences will see for themselves when Anne premieres on Sunday, March 19 on CBC TV, and on May 12 on Netflix.

Moira Walley-Beckett wrote all eight episodes and serves as showrunner for CBC's Anne, which premieres on March 19. (Getty Images)

Duelling Annes

Two recent Anne of Green Gables TV movies on YTV will be followed by a third, Fire & Dew, on July 1. All three are also airing on PBS in the U.S. 

The glut of adaptations speaks to its enduring appeal. "I think it touches so many people on so many levels," said Kate Macdonald Butler, the granddaughter of Anne of Green Gables author Lucy Maud Montgomery and an executive producer of the TV movies.

"It's about belonging, it's about love, growing up, so it just seems to touch people, older people too, looking back to when they may have originally read the book."

Butler does worry about reaching "peak" Anne and overloading the market, but said "it's an evergreen property and a classic."

Actor Sara Botsford (who plays Marilla, Matthew's sister) says Montgomery is still a one-woman employment factory.

"It just keeps going and going," she told CBC News recently. "It's such a fantastic story, such an optimistic wonderful story about a young girl becoming a young woman. We need more of those these days."

There are high ambitions for the new Anne series, according to veteran Canadian actor R.H. Thomson, who co-stars with Amybeth McNulty. (CBC)

Enduring appeal

But how do younger viewers today relate to the feisty redhead when they could be watching Pretty Little LiarsKeeping Up with the Kardashians, or their favourite YouTube channel?

Ella Ballentine, 15, who plays Anne in the new TV movies, says the story helped her understand the era when her own great-grandmother grew up. It also offers a gentler viewing experience for viewers her age.

"This is the kind of film that's just simple and smooth and it's easy, and you can watch it without having any anxiety going on. It's just sweet."

Irish-Canadian actor Amybeth McNulty, also 15, plays the lead in the series. She says it's the character's spirit that provides the enduring appeal.

"She's just very honest and she doesn't have a filter over herself, she doesn't pretend to be anybody else, she doesn't pretend to be somebody that she isn't, which I think is a very important thing to convey today," she said. 

"There are shows today that have girls very prettified — the girl next door who is not like the girl next door, the one that's the model. And I think girls and boys like seeing a character that is like them, that is not perfect, that is just very real and very honest."

Period dramas still hot

Veteran TV columnist Bill Brioux fondly recalls watching the original Anne mini-series that premiered in 1985.

"It was a spectacular success. And the casting was perfect. I have very cherished memories of it. But it's like anything else from 30 years ago: it's time for another generation to take a shot at it," he said. 

Brioux also noted, with the popularity of shows such as Downton Abbey and Murdoch Mysteries, "period dramas have really never been hotter."

"I think what's one reason why we're seeing Anne come back."

Sara Botsford, left, and Ella Ballentine star in L.M. Montgomery's Anne of Green Gables: The Good Stars on YTV. (Corus Entertainment)

So how much more Anne do we have in store?

Butler notes there are "no firm plans" for more TV movies, but Walley-Beckett says the series producers have a five-year plan that would take Anne right through her high school years.

"We hope we're going to go for years and years and years," De Pencier said. 

Anne of Green Gables returns — again

7 years ago
Duration 2:17
Featured VideoAre Canadians facing Anne overload? With a new series on CBC and three TV movies, Vancouver-born Emmy-winner Moira Walley-Beckett might find out soon.