News Editor's Blog·Editor's Note

On George Floyd's death, journalism and inclusive newsrooms

Hard questions were asked this week by the CBC audience and staff as George Floyd’s death lit the fuse on a powder keg of anger and frustration over anti-Black racism. CBC News editor in chief Brodie Fenlon offers some answers.

CBC News is committed to making changes to ensure content and leadership better reflect contemporary Canada

The death in Minneapolis police custody of George Floyd last month was a call to action for many but also left people across the U.S. and around the world with a deep sense of futility and sadness, another brutal reminder of the overt and systemic racism Black people experience and feel on a daily basis. (Jonathan Bachman/Reuters)

Two weeks ago today, George Floyd, a Black man, was killed by a white police officer in Minneapolis. Bystander video captured the moment Floyd's life ended under the officer's knee, which had been pressed tight against his neck for a full eight minutes and 46 seconds.

That video lit the fuse on a powder keg of anger and frustration across North America and around the world. It was for many a call to action. It left others with a deep sense of futility and sadness, another brutal reminder of the overt and systemic racism Black people experience and feel on a daily basis.

Those same feelings swept through our newsrooms at CBC. At the same time, our audience, fed up with racism and white-dominated media, demanded accountability.

Just one example:

After days of detailed live coverage of U.S. protests by CBC News Network, we made a series of errors last Sunday morning. We broadcast video of police vehicles driving into crowds of protestors in New York City. The script was poorly worded and mischaracterized the events, framing them mostly from the police perspective. Our team realized this and improved the language, but when we rebroadcast the clip, we had a technical production error that cut the video short — not showing the final moments when the police drove into the crowd.

That's all it took. 

Someone edited a side-by-side comparison of the original footage with our video, posted it to social media, and within days, we were an international meme and "proof" of the media's complicity with police. The audience reaction on social media was fierce and unrelenting. 

It did not matter that we had corrected, apologized, ran the full video multiple times after the error and before it was ever pointed out. We apologized again. But as I told our staff in an internal note, intent and workflow do not matter when it comes to this story or matters of race.

The expectation is simply that we get it right. Every time. And that's a fair expectation. 

We didn't meet that expectation last week. With the scrutiny on our work at its highest level, we owned up to some examples where our storytelling was one-sided, or missing perspectives, or nuance, or sensitivity. 

A demonstrator in Atlanta faces a line of police during a protest last Monday. Scrutiny of the media's coverage of the protests has been high, with audiences quick to point to missing perspectives and context. (Ben Gray/Atlanta Journal-Constitution/The Associated Press)

The pain is real

On the inside of CBC News, many of our staff were reeling. People of colour told us the Floyd story is personal and deeply felt. The pain is real. Our mistakes laid bare their long-held complaint that we aren't moving fast enough to ensure our workforce — from entry level to leadership — looks like the country we serve. How can we ever deepen our awareness and understanding of race if more people of colour, more Indigenous people, more women, more people with disabilities, aren't in positions of power and influence throughout our newsrooms? 

And we heard complaints, not new, that our interpretation of CBC's journalistic standards and practices (JSP) is so rigid it can muzzle within the organization important voices and lived experiences. Do our definitions of objectivity, balance, fairness and impartiality — and our insistence that journalists not express personal opinions on the stories we cover — work against our goals of inclusion and being part of the community and country we serve?

This question will be among the thorniest to untangle, for I believe strongly that our adherence to the JSP is the central reason CBC News is one of the most trusted news organizations in Canada. But I'm equally convinced that being open to this conversation and looking at the JSP through the prism of inclusivity will result in greater clarity for staff and managers, a mutual understanding of JSP intent and greater trust.

The central question we face: Can our journalists be active citizens of the world without compromising their objectivity?

We will make other changes, big and small at CBC News, Current Affairs and Local Services:

  • We've committed that one in two new hires in our department at all levels will come from underrepresented equity groups.
  • We will review our leadership and ensure we continue to hire and promote the very best by drawing from diverse groups.
  • Unconscious bias training will be mandatory for our journalists and anyone who leads people.
  • A CBC program for emerging diverse leaders will be expanded.
  • We are training editorial teams on how to think more inclusively when chasing interviews, guests and experts.
  • We will ask every CBC News program team this year to develop a strategy that makes the reflection of contemporary Canada one of the key pillars of their editorial choices. 

And in addition, we announced a change to our Language Guide that will see us capitalize "Black" when we refer to racial identity or culture, as we did with the word "Indigenous" a few years ago. 

We are committed to change. 

But the overriding objective is that the inside of CBC News mirrors the makeup of the country we serve. Only then can our storytelling truly reflect the many interests, sensitivities, beliefs and viewpoints found in Canada. 

Malaysia Hammond, 19, places flowers at a memorial mural for Floyd near where he was killed in Minneapolis. Floyd's death and the widespread protests it sparked have prompted many institutions to examine their own practices and commit to doing more to address systemic racism. (John Minchillo/The Associated Press)


Brodie Fenlon

Editor in chief

Brodie Fenlon is editor in chief and executive director of programs and standards for CBC News.