TTC 'Leprechaun' spurs outrage, legal questions

An unidentified man — since dubbed the “Leprechaun” because of his bowler hat and green clothing — who was caught on video refusing to move his bag so a woman could sit down on a crowded Toronto bus is being shamed on social media.

Shaming on social media could lead to defamation case, lawyer warns

Outrage follows one woman's account of bad manners on a Toronto bus. 2:21

A nasty confrontation between two Toronto bus passengers and the viral video it spawned is raising questions about shaming on social media. 

A ride on a crowded 72 Pape bus turned ugly for Brenda Davie of Toronto when an unidentified man — since dubbed the “Leprechaun” for his green attire and bowler hat — refused to move his bag so she could sit down. 

Davie, describing the incident on Facebook, claimed the man called her an “airhead” and, as things escalated, stomped on her foot. She also claims he pushed her “backwards into a pile of people.” 

A video shot by another passenger captured part of the confrontation, but not the alleged assault. 

“I'm glad your bag is comfortable,” Davie says at one point. 

The man, waving his hand dismissively, responds “La la, you get nothing. Pay attention.” 

Legal issues 

Davie's post was viewed thousands of times in just a few hours, prompting many to respond with outrage. Some have taken up a search to try to identify the man, and someone created a mock Twitter account @TTCLeprechaun.

But Julia Lefebvre, a lawyer who specializes in social media, said the reaction raises certain legal issues. 

"It's one thing to post a picture on social media," she said. "Clearly it's documenting what happened — as far as we know it's not an altered picture — but it's another thing to post comments that go with it. Are you opening yourself up to a defamation action? Potentially."

The man "clearly is being vilified in the media for this," Lefebvre said.

A number of social media sites and hashtags call out bad behaviour on public transit, including two Tumblr blogs aimed at men who sprawl across seats and the hashtag #subwayshaming.

The TTC said it has been unable to find security footage of the incident, though spokesman Brad Ross condemned the man’s behaviour. 

"Bags do not belong on seats. Seats are for people. Bags don't pay fares, people do," Ross said. 

With files from CBC's Shannon Martin


To encourage thoughtful and respectful conversations, first and last names will appear with each submission to CBC/Radio-Canada's online communities (except in children and youth-oriented communities). Pseudonyms will no longer be permitted.

By submitting a comment, you accept that CBC has the right to reproduce and publish that comment in whole or in part, in any manner CBC chooses. Please note that CBC does not endorse the opinions expressed in comments. Comments on this story are moderated according to our Submission Guidelines. Comments are welcome while open. We reserve the right to close comments at any time.