Union slams TTC over subway air pollution study, raises concerns about worker health

"How long did the TTC know, when did the TTC know, and what has the TTC done to protect the workers and riders over the years?" questioned one union representative over research showing high levels of air pollution in Toronto's subway system.

Airborne pollutants in subway system up to 10 times higher than outside air, study found

Conducted back in 2010 and 2011, the study found pollutants on trains and platforms in Toronto were up to 10 times higher than outside air. Some question what that means for the health of TTC employees working in the subway system. (THE CANADIAN PRESS)

The largest TTC workers' union has slammed the transit commission over new study results revealing high air pollution levels within the city's subway system — which they fear could be causing long-term health impacts among workers.

The research, published on Tuesday in the journal Environmental Science & Technology, found airborne pollutants on trains and platforms in the city's subway system were up to 10 times higher than outside air.

"This has potential long-term effects on the people that work there ... these workers have been working down there, in some cases, 30 to 40 years," said Kevin Morton, secretary-treasurer of Local 113, which represents around 11,000 active TTC workers.

"They've been breathing this stuff in."

A team of researchers from Health Canada, McGill University and the University of Toronto compared Toronto's subway lines to Vancouver's SkyTrain and Montreal's Metro systems back in 2010 and 2011. Toronto's stations and trains were found to have the highest levels of air pollution.

They found an average of 100 micrograms of pollutants per cubic metre within the Toronto system, which study co-author Greg Evans, a University of Toronto engineering professor, compared to "a typical day in Beijing."

University of Toronto engineering professor Greg Evans co-authored the study on air pollution in Toronto's subway system. (Tyler Irving)

The pollutants were made up of high concentrations of metal, which Evans said could be due to the abrasion of the wheels on the tracks. 

"We believe a lot of the particles that we detect in the air come in because of the abrasion of the wheels on the tracks," Evans said.

That comes as no surprise to Morton, who questioned why it took an external study to shine light on something that's been long-discussed internally.

"For years and years and years, our union — and the other unions — have addressed the fact that brake dust and iron dust from the wheels was potentially cancer-causing, as well as respiratory issues, asthma, all the other associated illnesses," he said.

Morton said the union is asking for an immediate meeting with the TTC and other major bodies, including the ministries of health, labour, and the environment.

"How long did the TTC know, when did the TTC know, and what has the TTC done to protect the workers and riders over the years?" he asked.

Particles can get into lungs, bloodstream

Dr. John Molot, an environmental health expert at Women's College Hospital, said he "wouldn't be surprised" if there was a health impact on TTC workers.

He said the airborne particles discussed in the new study — those smaller than 0.00025 centimetres — can get deep into the lungs and be absorbed into the bloodstream.

"These particles land on the surface of the bronchial tubes and trigger a response from the immune system to try and clear it up," he said.

They can also lead to various types of diseases and biological changes, which can impact the respiratory system, central nervous system, and brain function, according to Molot.

He stressed that studying TTC workers is crucial to knowing how their exposure to subway air pollution is impacting their health.

"They have to compare these workers to people who have much less exposure," he said.

In a statement, the TTC stressed the research published on Tuesday was conducted years ago, at a time when the commission had already started taking steps to improve air quality on the trains and reduce certain pollutants in stations.

That includes the introduction of Toronto Rocket trains on Line 1  — the Yonge-University-Spadina line — which have cleaner air thanks to newer ventilation systems.

Councillor Mary Fragadakis says she fears about falling onto the subway tracks on crowded days. (Bruce Reeve/CBC)

TTC should make study 'results public'

As for the impact on both riders and workers, the TTC said it is indeed planning to conduct a broader subway air quality study.

"The information we have is from 1995 and we know it needs updating," the statement reads. "We will work with our employees through joint health and safety committees on that study this year."

TTC spokesperson Stuart Green also noted that the research looked at samples from 2010 and 2011. Since that time, the commission has improved its filtration and HVAC systems, which Green said should have already improved air quality.

In past studies — conducted in 1977, 1980 and 1995 — the levels of pollutants were found to have decreased over time, Green said.  

"The 1995 study found that none of the 280 samples taken were above the occupational exposure limits for employees," he said in an email. "It was determined that the subway air quality would not affect the health of employees or customers who do not have pre-existing serious respiratory conditions."

Jessica Bell, executive director of advocacy group TTCRiders, said it's good the TTC is taking steps to reduce air pollution, but said studying whether or not that's making an impact on both riders and workers is key, stressing that "they need to make those results public."

Morton also wants to see concrete answers, for the sake of workers who spend so much of their lives working in the underbelly of the city.

"You as a rider might be on the TTC for 15 to 40 minutes," he said.

"How about walking in the tunnels? How about working in the tunnels? How about an operator who does an eight or ten hour shift — and has to breathe in that air?"

With files from Julia Whalen