Toronto council to debate transit future

The chair of the Toronto Transit Commission has filed a petition demanding a special council meeting to deal with transit funding.

Transit Rebellion

10 years ago
Duration 3:35
Toronto’s City Council will soon vote on its much-debated transit plans.

Two transit visions

One sees a light-rail line running along Eglinton Avenue that is buried, where possible, all the way to Kennedy Station, while another would keep the same line at grade along its eastern stretch.

Mayoral preference

Mayor Rob Ford wants the Eglinton line kept underground and he has signed a memorandum of understanding with the province to do that. He is supported by other Scarborough councillors on this point.

Opposing voices

TTC chair Karen Stintz is leading the charge to return to the Transit City plan developed under David Miller’s administration. In that scenario, the Eglinton line would be buried only between Black Creek Drive and Laird Drive.

More subways?

Ford wants to extend the Sheppard subway while Stintz says "there is no funded subway plan."

The Transit City plan would put light rail on Sheppard and Finch Avenues, while converting the Scarborough RT to a light-rail system.

What happens next?

Twenty-four councillors signed a petition to call a special meeting on Wednesday, which could see council reaffirm support for the Transit City plan.

The fight over the future of Toronto's public transportation system will move into the open on Wednesday when city council has a special meeting on how to best spend more than $8 billion in provincial transit funding.

Mayor Rob Ford's plan to bury a large portion of the Eglinton Cross Town route has led TTC chair Karen Stintz to file a petition demanding the special meeting.

The petition asks council to renew its commitment to the 2009 Transit City plan of former mayor David Miller, which calls for light rail lines on Eglinton, Sheppard and Finch Avenues.  It would also call for the Scarborough Rapid Transit line to be replaced by an LRT.

Ford is on record saying he wants subways — including an extension of the Sheppard line.

When asked about the petition on Monday, Ford refused to be drawn out.

Stintz said the mayor's plan is not doable. "There's no funded subway plan.  An underground LRT is not a subway," she said.

The issue re-emerged in late January when Stintz proposed — with the knowledge of the mayor's office — a compromise plan for the Eglinton section of the line.

Instead of burying the entire line, Stintz proposed an underground section only in the portion that travels through the centre of the city.  The section built east of Laird Drive would be above ground.

Stintz lost a vote at the last TTC board meeting, when other board members — who are also city councillors — voted down a proposal to study the option.

The Eglinton project and the extension of the Sheppard subway are expected to cost about $8.4 billion.  Stintz estimated that her proposal would save about $2 billion — and suggested that money could be re-directed to the subway project.

This latest challenge to Mayor Ford comes just a day after city negotiators managed to iron out a last minute deal with CUPE 416, which represents about 6,000 outside workers, including garbage collectors, snow removal workers and paramedics.

Stintz's petition had her signature and the signatures of 23 other councillors.

"I must reiterate: there is no funded subway plan. An underground LRT is not a plan," said Stintz, who also admitted she will probably be replaced as TTC chair.

Stintz said the emergency meeting is needed so the provincial agency Metrolinx can be assured council is behind a single transit plan.

Metrolinx chairman Rob Prichard sent a letter last week asking for that kind of clarity from city council.

Also Monday, Ontario Premier Dalton McGuinty said that the province would listen to what Toronto council has to say, should a decision be made to alter the current transit plan.

"We’re looking for the council to do one of two things: either affirm the agreement that we’ve already entered into and which work is proceeding, or, if you want to make a change to that, then you need to do that as a council," McGuinty said.