Travelling by public transit in Toronto exposes you to damaging bursts of sound, study says

The sudden screeches, squeals and clangs that are a regular feature of commuting by public transit in Toronto could be contributing to long-term hearing loss and health effects, according to a new study.

Sudden bursts of loud noise can cause hearing loss and lead to a host of health problems

Clang! Honk! Screeeech! A new study finds that short, loud sounds in the city can have a cumulative effect on commuters. (John Rieti/CBC)

The sudden screeches, squeals and clangs that are a regular feature of commuting by public transit in Toronto could be contributing to long-term hearing loss and other health problems, says a new study out Wednesday in the Journal of Otolaryngology - Head and Neck Surgery.

Though average noise levels while walking, biking, driving or taking transit fell within safe exposure levels, the study found that sudden bursts of sound that exceed safe decibel levels are a common occurrence while commuting by transit or bike.  

"We knew that it was going to be noisy but I was surprised with the frequency of the peaks," Dr. Vincent Lin of Sunnybrook Hospital, one of the study's authors, told CBC News. 

Those spikes put Torontonians at risk of noise-induced hearing loss, said Lin. 

For example, nearly 20 per cent of the loudest noises on the subway exceeded 114 decibels, which is considered risky if exposure lasts more than four seconds.

Lin said metal-on-metal noises, like screeching subway train wheels or machinery, are the most common culprits. But crowds can also contribute to the problem.  

Dr. Vincent Lin of Sunnybrook Hospital says he was surprised by how many loud bursts of sound Torontonians are exposed to while travelling on transit and cycling. (CBC)

Keele, Spadina stations among loudest

To investigate how loud things get on different routes, researchers clipped measuring devices to their collars and fanned out across Toronto over the spring and summer of 2016, gathering 210 sound samples on subways, buses, streetcars, bicycles, sidewalks and in cars.

Researchers concluded that commuters were exceeding their recommended noise exposure levels in nine per cent of the measurements taken in subways and in 12 per cent of the measurements taken in buses.

By contrast, noise exposures were not exceeded in streetcars, cars, or while walking. 

They also found that noise is louder on subway platforms than inside subway cars, and that Keele, Dufferin, Spadina and Bay stations have the loudest platforms in the system.

Cycling in particular was singled out as the most potentially damaging to hearing, exposing people to larger amounts of dangerous noise than any other way of getting around, with 14 per cent of measurements exceeding recommended levels. 

The study singles out cycling as the mode of transportation that's most potentially damaging to hearing. (David Donnelly/CBC)

The hearing loss that results from regular exposures to dangerous sound levels can lead to a host of other health problems, said Lin.

"Chronic noise exposure is well associated with chronic health conditions like hypertension, depression … These things are just starting to be better understood."

He said using more sound-proofed materials in transit construction could minimize risks, and that Toronto's city planners have already shown signs of switching to sound-absorbing materials.

In the meantime, though, Toronto's transit system and streets remain noisy — so commuters may want to consider investing in a pair of earplugs.

"Even earbuds that you use to listen to music can be used as ear protectors," said Lin.