Toronto

'It started snowing Styrofoam': Residents concerned over construction site debris

A Weston neighbourhood's gardens, streets and gutters are littered with bits of Styrofoam and it's all coming from a nearby construction site. Residents are frustrated, concerned and they want answers from the city.

Homeowners not happy with the city's response to debris strewn through Weston neighbourhood

Gardens, streets and gutters are littered with bits of Styrofoam in the Weston Road and Lawrence Avenue area from a construction site more than a block away. (Sabrina Jonas/CBC)

When Mike Smith left his house earlier this week, he said he felt as though he'd stepped into a snow storm. 

What looked at first to be snowflakes were actually white beads of polystyrene, better known as Styrofoam, blowing around the Weston Road and Lawrence Avenue area and settling into gardens, streets and gutters. 

"It started snowing Styrofoam and the whole neighbourhood was wondering what was happening," said Smith, standing on his white-spotted front lawn. 

It didn't take long for them to identify the culprit. 

An apartment building being upgraded more than a block away at 33 King Street sent the airborne debris spreading several blocks and coating the neighbourhood.

White beads of Styrofoam are pictured floating around the King Street construction site where insulation is underway. (Sabrina Jonas/CBC)

"You can see it even in spider webs. It's all over everybody's porches; it's just tucked around everywhere," said Smith.

Although the debris is an eyesore for the neighbourhood, residents are more concerned about the impact on the environment.

"My real concern is that... all of this is going to wash down into the storm sewers and out into the lake," said Robert Strand, another neighbourhood resident. 

Smith's first instinct was to report the issue to the non-emergency police line, which turned out to be the first of many actions he would have to take on his own.

'Is it even possible to clean up?'

Smith said he was shocked by what he says was a lack of concern or reprimand from authorities for "the mass pollution."

He says he was told to call the City of Toronto instead.

"If you litter, you can get a ticket. If you pollute a community on a widespread scale, you would think there'd be at least an investigation," said Smith. 

Mike Smith said the city hasn't been much help and he wants something to be done. (Jonathan Castell/CBC)
 

After a 30-minute phone call with the city, Smith was left only a name and number of the city-appointed building inspector for the construction site, Frank Labriola, who he says hasn't returned his calls.

CBC Toronto also reached out to Labriola and the city in a group email Wednesday, but only received a response from the city. 

Officials say Toronto Building and Construction staff met with the property management company and the building contractor after Smith's complaint.

Toronto Building staff said the company has agreed to use netting to limit the spread of the Styrofoam debris and to continue vacuuming the area around the building.

The contractor also said they will rasp the Styrofoam slower in an effort to manage the containment more effectively, Toronto Building staff told CBC Toronto in an email Thursday. 

But that has had little effect on the damage already done, Smith said.

"We would like to know who is actually going to be cleaning this up, but a better question is, 'Is it even possible to clean up?' Because I don't know how you would go around and pick up something the size of lice," said Smith. 

The city said it's classifying Smith's complaint as an air quality complaint for "dust" in accordance with city protocol. 

But Smith disputes that classification, saying he believes Styrofoam's impact on human health and the environment is much worse than dust's.

Human impact 

Smith said he is hesitant to grow vegetables in his garden due to the carcinogenic chemicals found in Styrofoam that can seep into the soil.

Thomas Tenkate, an expert in environmental health at Ryerson University, said Smith's concern is justified. 

He said among the chemicals in Styrofoam, the chemical most detrimental to humans is styrene.

"That chemical has been associated with causing cancer, particularly leukemia and lymphoma," said Tenkate. Breathing it in has also been associated with cancer within the nose, he said. 

"Once [Styrofoam] is in the environment, it doesn't break down very easily... And so it could get into the groundwater, it gets into the soil. And then once the Styrofoam particles are in there, the styrene can leach out," he said. 

In its statement to CBC Toronto, Toronto Building said it's developing a proactive strategy to address the negative impacts of large-scale construction in the city. 

But many residents of the Weston neighbourhood remain convinced the remnants will be there for years.

With files from Laura McQuillan

Comments

To encourage thoughtful and respectful conversations, first and last names will appear with each submission to CBC/Radio-Canada's online communities (except in children and youth-oriented communities). Pseudonyms will no longer be permitted.

By submitting a comment, you accept that CBC has the right to reproduce and publish that comment in whole or in part, in any manner CBC chooses. Please note that CBC does not endorse the opinions expressed in comments. Comments on this story are moderated according to our Submission Guidelines. Comments are welcome while open. We reserve the right to close comments at any time.