Police charge 3 people after Black Lives Matter protesters splatter paint on statues in Toronto
Black Lives Matter Toronto claims credit for the defacing and calls on city to defund police
Toronto police have charged three people after Black Lives Matter protesters splattered paint on statues at the Ontario legislature and Ryerson University.
Two women, Jenna Reid and Danielle Smith, aged 35 and 47 respectively, and one man, Daniel Gooch, 35, all of Toronto, have all been charged with three counts of mischief under $5,000 and conspiracy to commit a summary offence, according to Toronto police.
Black Lives Matter Toronto has claimed credit for defacing the statues of former prime minister John A. Macdonald, King Edward VII Equestrian and Egerton Ryerson and called the action an artistic disruption.
The group is calling on the city and province to defund the police, invest in communities and create emergency safety services that "do not harm Black and Indigenous people."
"Along with a coalition of artists, the group artistically disrupted statues of slaveholders and monuments to colonialism at Ryerson University and at Queen's Park," the group said in a statement.
"The action comes after the City of Toronto and the Province of Ontario have failed to take action against police violence against Black people."
In a news release on Saturday afternoon, Toronto police said Smith and Gooch had been released on a promise to appear, while Reid was being held for a show cause hearing. But later Saturday evening, Const. Alex Li, spokesperson for the Toronto Police Service, told CBC News that the conditions of release had changed and all three were still in police custody.
According to the lawyer of one of the three who were arrested, all three of its members were released early Sunday and will appear in court at the end of September.
This is the power of collective action and organizing. I want to thank <a href="https://twitter.com/BLM_TO?ref_src=twsrc%5Etfw">@BLM_TO</a> for their leadership organizing this protest and all who have been boosting the message online and beyond. We will win this fight to <a href="https://twitter.com/hashtag/DefundThePolice?src=hash&ref_src=twsrc%5Etfw">#DefundThePolice</a> as long as we keep showing up.—@SaronGeb
Li said the three counts of mischief refer to three separate incidents.
Late Saturday night, Toronto police said in a tweet that the three individuals arrested were provided access to counsel.
"Hours ago, they declined to sign the release forms to leave custody. They will be released as soon as they sign, and we would like them to do so," the tweet reads.
"Further, regarding allegations being made, we worked with the family to coordinate delivery of medication to one of the arrested parties, hours ago. All care has been taken to ensure her safety while she has opted to remain in custody."
'This is a really serious miscalculation'
But Saron Gebresellassi, lawyer for one of the three, said she waited to speak to her client for more than three hours after the arrests were made and initially she didn't know where the three were being processed.
"This is a really serious miscalculation. This is a misstep in this climate," she said. "Canadians are tired of this ongoing battle. This is not the way to work with young people and to work with Canadian leaders."
The arrests came after Black Lives Matter Toronto held a rally and march on Saturday morning.
According to police, a man and two women were observed vandalizing a statue and surrounding concrete embankments in the area of Bond and Gould Streets, and then left the area.
Police were called at about 9:20 a.m. and located a van at Queen's Park. Police said a woman got out of the van, carrying tubs of paint, and she joined a crowd of people. A man and a woman were found in the van and they were covered in paint. All three were arrested.
Following the arrests, activists demonstrated for hours outside Toronto police's 52 Division, where they believed those arrested were taken for processing. The protest was still in progress on Saturday night.
Const. Edward Parks of the Toronto police said: "When they are arrested, they are brought to the station. They are presented, they will get their paperwork, they will get their release paperwork, then they will be released. They are not in any danger whatsoever."
Outside of 52 Division, protesters chanted "Black lives, they matter here!" and "Hey hey, ho ho, these racist cops have got to go!"
Ravyn Wngz, a Black Lives Matter Toronto organizer, told reporters at the protest that activists have been fighting for years for change and an end to anti-Black racism.
"We're sending a message that this is the beginning. This is the beginning of the end. We are finished with reform. We are done with piecemeal ways of trying to appease us. We are sick of city councillors not recognizing or representing us. We want change and we need it. Our people are dying," Wngz said.
Wngz said the monuments that were spray painted represent white supremacy.
Council not acting against police violence, activists say
According to Black Lives Matter Toronto, the city spends $1.13 billion a year on policing, or 25 per cent of taxpayer dollars.
Rodney Diverlus, co-founder of Black Lives Matter Toronto, said some American cities, including Minneapolis, Oakland and Seattle, are taking action in response to demands from citizens in the wake of police violence, but Toronto has not.
Diverlus pointed out that Black people are nearly 20 times more likely to be shot and killed by police in Toronto.
Several recent incidents, including the conviction of Const. Michael Theriault in the assault of Dafonte Miller and the suspension of five Toronto police officers in connection with an alleged scheme involving the tow truck industry, suggest there is corruption, he said.
"How much more corruption do you need to take action? The police are beyond reform, and the time has come to defund," Diverlus said.
At the protest, Diverlus said the protesters should not have been arrested.
"Protesters should not be charged for protesting. This was a peaceful protest. No harm was done to anybody. What is the priority? Our conversation is about saving lives. I believe lives matter more than property," Diverlus said.
"More cops were out trying to protect a statue than are out protecting Black and Indigenous lives and that's a shame."
Monuments 'glorify the ugliest parts' of history, BLM says
Syrus Marcus Ware, an organizer for Black Lives Matter Toronto, said: "Much like the institution of the police, these statues are monuments that glorify the ugliest parts of our history and our present."
Words are not enough to ensure Black lives matter, Ware said.
"Let's refuse to honour colonialism, anti-Blackness, and white supremacy. Let's tear down monuments to anti-Blackness and colonialism, including the police system. Let's build a society that truly values safety for all of us," Ware said.
Sir John A. Macdonald, Canada's first prime minister, is seen as the architect of Canada's Indian residential school system, where thousands of Indigenous children died and many others were abused.
- He's considered Canada's founding father, but many Ontario teachers want his name stripped from public schools
Egerton Ryerson, a public education advocate and a prominent figure in education and politics in Ontario in the 19th century, has also been criticized for his involvement in the creation of residential schools. Ryerson University is named after him.
- An earlier version of this story quoted Toronto police saying Danielle Smith and Daniel Gooch had been released. At the time of publication, that was incorrect information.Jul 18, 2020 8:19 PM ET
With files from Ieva Lucs, Desmond Brown, Jessica Cheung, The Canadian Press