Bob Chiarelli denies saying Andrea Horwath 'pees all over the map' amid Queen's Park debate

A heated debate at Queen's Park appeared to go straight into the toilet on Wednesday.

NDP leader was criticizing government for cancelling energy projects

Ontario Energy Minister Bob Chiarelli blasted NDP Leader Andrea Horwath for her "shotgun approach" to questioning the government at Queen's Park on Wednesday and appeared to say she "pees all over the map" with her queries. (CBC)

A heated debate at Queen's Park appeared to go straight into the toilet on Wednesday after Ontario's energy minister appeared to say NDP Leader Andrea Horwath "pees all over the map."

During question period, Bob Chiarelli appeared to say: "When the leader gets up it's hard to focus on the matter.... When she takes Kenora in the North and she takes Toronto in the south, Mr. Speaker, and she pees all over the map." 

Chiarelli later clarified his statement — made during a fierce debate about how the Liberal government has handled several energy projects — saying he used a word that had been "interpreted to be an offensive slang word."

Chiarelli pointed out that Hansard, which records what's said in Queen's Park, revised his statement to: "she's — she's all over the map."

"If my pronunciation was unclear and it appeared as though I said something I didn't, I would like to offer an apology to the Leader of the Third Party," Chiarelli said later at Queen's Park, after he rose on a point of personal privilege.

Queen's Park debate goes straight into the toilet with this one 1:07

The comment was made as politicians criticized the government for how it's dealt with cancelled energy projects.

On Wednesday, the Ontario Provincial Police launched a criminal investigation over allegations that that government officials destroyed documents related to a cancelled wind project near Lake Ontario wind project.

Horwath called for the premier to launch a commission of inquiry into how public energy contracts are awarded and managed in the province. "People end up paying the price, speaker," Horwath said.

That prompted Chiarelli's comment. 

The energy minister also blasted Horwath's "shotgun approach," to criticizing the government and said that she's jealous of the government's success — highlighted by Moody's recently upgrading Ontario's credit rating to stable.

"She won't talk about any of that, Mr. Speaker. She's embarrassed by how successful we are."

Debate broke down following Chiarelli's comments as politicians on both sides yelled at one another. 


To encourage thoughtful and respectful conversations, first and last names will appear with each submission to CBC/Radio-Canada's online communities (except in children and youth-oriented communities). Pseudonyms will no longer be permitted.

By submitting a comment, you accept that CBC has the right to reproduce and publish that comment in whole or in part, in any manner CBC chooses. Please note that CBC does not endorse the opinions expressed in comments. Comments on this story are moderated according to our Submission Guidelines. Comments are welcome while open. We reserve the right to close comments at any time.